Thanks for the scouting reports. Can you give a bit more insight on Gavrikov though? For a "shutdown" guy his on ice Goals Against at even strength has been pretty terrible for the last three years... 3.6/60 to 4.2/60...
Those types of stats are heavily contextual IMO and don't paint a very complete picture because team systems/personnel fits vary greatly team-to-team. For CBJ, our team systems (and goaltending) are garbage – our whole defense looks lost all the time – and our personnel back there doesn't fit very well together.
The reason he's seen as a shutdown guy first is because as a rookie he was playing primarily with Savard and that was their niche. Last year he played a lot with (and covered up for) Boqvist. When Werenski's been out the last couple of years, Gavrikov has stepped up and played big minutes.
Just from watching his game since he came over, I've seen him evolve from a shutdown-only guy to a two-way guy who can play big minutes. I think he'd be enormously valuable on a good team.
Also, let's just assume Gavrikov is worth a 1st. I buy that.
How then are Robinson and a 3rd worth Broberg and Puljujarvi? Assuming you value Pulju as a 3rd (I don't think Holland does, but anyway...)... that would still put Robinson = Broberg and that's not in the realm of realistic to me.
The market for Gavrikov (a big-minute, versatile defenseman on a cheap contract) is going to be big enough that his value will, as the deadline approaches, grow to be "first round pick plus good prospect."
Robinson also strikes me as a good add for a contender. Good size and instincts, great (borderline elite) speed and a really cheap contract. So, to me, it's more of "Gavrikov + 3rd for Broberg + 1st" with a Robinson-Puljujarvi swap added.