PsychoticHab
Registered User
We already have a 1st line C.
Not to mention that McCarron may become that "gigantic center" in the future.(Obviously less offensively talented though but perfect for 3rd/4th line if he continues to develop)
We already have a 1st line C.
If it was all about size, the big issues on the team WOULDN'T be Pacioretty and Vanek.
Anybody that has watched Pacioretty play these playoffs and blamed his center is lying to not only others but themselves. No doubt Desharnais is not the ideal center for your top scoring line, but when your 39 goal winger turns into a ghost at playoff time, it makes things pretty hard. I think Max has 1 even strength point in 9 playoff games.
DD bashing has been in vogue for quite some time now.
The Habs will win or lose with DD in the lineup against Boston. Isnt it interesting that the Habs would have really been screwed if they were relying on Galchenyuk right now. Cant be a factor if an injury is keeping him off the ice.
I hope DD proves a few people wrong tonight and the rest of the playoff series.
Regardless, win or lose, I am sure that we will get many many more DD bashing threads in the future.
DD bashing has been in vogue for quite some time now.
The Habs will win or lose with DD in the lineup against Boston. Isnt it interesting that the Habs would have really been screwed if they were relying on Galchenyuk right now. Cant be a factor if an injury is keeping him off the ice.
I hope DD proves a few people wrong tonight and the rest of the playoff series.
Regardless, win or lose, I am sure that we will get many many more DD bashing threads in the future.
but we want to WIN in the playoffs...
but seriously
i hope these playoffs have shown bergevin that you have to trade desharnais and how valuable to the team eller is
OR we ruin galchenyuk, blow it with eller, and waste plekanecs prime years as a hab
were just too god damn small up front, thats just the way it is, ..if he keeps desharnais, so be it, ..only 3 more years..hey its better than when it was 4...
Sadly that is the nature of this board. We even had a bashing thread against Plek after just one bad game (the first one in longer than most could remember). Hell, Price tried to play through an injury last year and saw his play fall and at least half the board wanted to chase him out of town even if he had been in the Vezina talks just prior to that injury.
Eller is valuable, but he still isn't a #1 center.
Right now Plekanec is the closest thing we have to a #1 center.
Boston isn't leading the series because their #1 center is big or highly productive so far, Krejci only has 1 point in the series.
Eller is valuable, but he still isn't a #1 center.
Right now Plekanec is the closest thing we have to a #1 center.
Boston isn't leading the series because their #1 center is big or highly productive so far, Krejci only has 1 point in the series.
DD has 5 points in 20 playoff games. Let that marinate for a while.
I'd put my life that galchenyuk would outproduce him in 20 games.
You and others built him up into something he isn't. At least own it.
Does it have to be bashing though?DD bashing has been in vogue for quite some time now.
The Habs will win or lose with DD in the lineup against Boston. Isnt it interesting that the Habs would have really been screwed if they were relying on Galchenyuk right now. Cant be a factor if an injury is keeping him off the ice.
I hope DD proves a few people wrong tonight and the rest of the playoff series.
Regardless, win or lose, I am sure that we will get many many more DD bashing threads in the future.
DD never should've had that role to begin with...The problem is that Galchenyuk is 20, and still getting his feet wet in the NHL, he isn't dominating in a smaller role, giving him a bigger one with more responsibility is not a recipe for success.
If Desharnais fails and everybody ***** on him, well he's an NHL veteran and if he gets "ruined" it's not the same as "ruining" a 20 year old lottery pick with big uupside. Plus the way Pacioretty is playing and getting Chara's pair, is that really who you'd want Galchenyuk playing against if he wass healthy?
Eller is valuable, but he still isn't a #1 center.
Right now Plekanec is the closest thing we have to a #1 center.
Boston isn't leading the series because their #1 center is big or highly productive so far, Krejci only has 1 point in the series.
He is a long way from 60 points.
Lol. Habs fans gotta be the only people around who act like size is irrelevant. The same people that think we can contend with a 5'6 center.
Does it have to be bashing though?
I just don't think he's good enough to warrant the role, icetime and linemates he's been given. I don't hate him, he's got some talent but yeah, this doesn't surprise me.
And I don't understand why MT feels the need to weld him to Max. Never tried Eller, never tried Galchenyuk... It was one line only. Well, here we are now...
And btw, I (like everyone else here) hopes he has an awesome game. I don't care who scores as long as we win.
Who said anything about "size alone?"I never said size wasn't relevant, but size alone wins you nothing.
I never said size wasn't relevant, but size alone wins you nothing.
If size was the be all then a guy like Boyle would be playing 23 minutes a game and making huge money in the NHL. For every Chara who is an effective big guy there are thousands who never make the NHL or play small roles.
Desharnais is the best option we have right now, if Pacioretty played with half the guts that he does he would have more tahn 1 ES point in the playoffs.
I think we can compete with the top 5 teams with DD as top center, in order to win a cup we'll have to have a better option. If that's Galchenyuk, that will be in 2-3 years, he still has a lot of growing/learning to do.
MS, it's difficult to believe you are seriously suggesting that opponents of the habs tiny roster strategy believe that size alone wins games, or that we should fill the roster with big guys who never made the NHL. Wherever did you get that idea?
It's also difficult to believe you are seriously suggesting that a 5'6" player (who actually never would have made the NHL were it not for the habs lol) is our "best option" for #1C? Or that Galchenyuk, arguably the top center from the 2012 draft, with 120 NHL games already, might be ready "in 2-3 years"? Come on guy.
But I hope dd leads the squad to victory tonight so we have one thing we can agree on.
Go DD!
Go Habs Go !!!