I'll weigh in a bit...
I'm a Caps fan, so I'll get that bias out of the way first off.
I know for a fact that the 2nd ranking was extremely high. The only reason we sniffed the top 5 is because of Oulette, Stana, and the potential that Ghearson and Danigauelt might show as well. Stana has looked pretty solid when called up, and Oulette is a out and out number 1 in the making, whenever he gets more seasoning (or Olie keels over). The other goalie prospects are all desirable commodities that some teams will come calling for in a little while. Especially when this old crop of goaltenders finally start hanging up the skates.
As for the rest of the prospects, it is a little light on pure scoring talent, and skill. But so are many other organizations. The reason the Caps took chances (measured risks if you're a business guy) on Aullin, Fleischman, Klepis, and Johannson is due to the Caps knowing they're going to need to find some solid goal scoring, speed and talent out of the bunch. All four of them have some scoring touch, and some have good potential to be decent point producers at the NHL level. But they all have questions. Developing sure fire point producers in the NHL is difficult. It's a crap shoot. Who in the world would have thought Robert Lang, St. Louis and some others would be some of the top point producers in the NHL? It's not an exact science. For each Kovalchuk, Nash, or other highly touted prospect, there are others who just have breakout seasons. With the plentiful numbers of guys with potential, they're hopefully going to find one or two.
They've already found one with Semin. Straight out, this guy has all the tools in the world to post Bondra like numbers when it comes to scoring goals. (In the past) He's got speed, moves, passing, acceleration, awareness on the ice, and a solid shot (which he hasn't displayed as much so far). He also is working on his defensive parts of the game, which he'll never be a top 2 way winger, but with his feisty play, should be adequate. He does need to add a little bulk, and learn English. But watching him play is a treat. He does suffer from a bit of inconsistency, but I believe some of that is surrounding cast as much as just youth. Last night for example, he was making some pretty nice passes to set up some players, but none of them really had good position to do much with the passes. or shanked the shots. He is more than a one dimensional goal scorer as well... who should hopefully develop his passing (which looks to be solid) as well. He still has a long road to go to reach those scoring levels, and find a consistency. But... he could be an All star.
As for the rest of the Prospects, I like what's to be seen from the grinders they're picking up. Old Caps teams were built on grinding wingers, who would work hard, kill penalties, and play solid two way hockey. McPhee is stocking the system with those type of role players. Fehr looks like he could be a big two way forward, and I can't wait to see him play with the big boys at training camp next year. He's got the size and the touch to do some damage. 20-30 goals a year could be realistic, with some in the trenches power play time. Werner could turn into something, with time as well. But he'll take a while. Defensive wise, the Caps need to add a lot. They've got some potential, but the only clear player in the bunch (beyond Morrisonn who is already a pretty solid player) is Emminger. He'll be a solid 2-3 eventually, but needs more work seasoning. He has looked ok in the times he's been called up. And Boumedienne looks better than I've expected.
I'm also happy with all the picks that are being stocked. The Caps will most certainly address the defensive side with at least 2-3 picks going there. They'll probably take a top Russian forward, and maybe a big Center. They've got one guy in Zubrus, who still is quite young, developing into a good center, but need to add a premier showcase player up there.
I'll also address the Fussey comment here. He came up last night, and watched him play. He just shows energy. He's got a high motor, not afraid to rough it up, and has a little touch. He's never going to be a star. But he's the type of hardworking players the Caps need more of, not less.
Similar case with Sutherby. If not for the nagging injuries, and Cassidy's anti-Rookie approach, he might already be playing a big role. He is a potential leader, who's not afraid to stand up for his teammates. He's also not a bad middleweight fighter. He just needs to get some seasoning. Same with Boyd Gordon. All of them have potential, but just need some time developing.
bah. sorry for the long windedness. bored, on my break period.