Best defensive defenseman we ever had was Chara and it's not even close. I also believe he should have won a Norris or two as a senator but shady politics was already part of the NHL awards back then.
Sencond best? Prime Philips, Volchenkov or Methot? Hard to say. I think I would go with Methot because of his mobility and physical play. Then Prime Phillips 2002-2007, then Volche who was an absolute warrior.
What Vegas was asking in order to select Claesson instead of Methot is disgusting. I'm glad Dorion didn't bite. It sucks to lose Methot, I'm still pissed at how poorly GMPD dealt through this but I'm already over it. Let's focus on how to replace him.
One side of me wants to see Claesson be promoted while Boro, Harpur, Englund and Chabot can fight for the last spot, on the other hand, I don't want to relive the fail experiment this organization repeat every time we lose an important asset and we decide to "improve from withtin". If we can grab Alzner as a UFA. I'm sure anybody would love to be EK65 partner. Or even Markov on a 1 year, as a PP specialist.