you said you wouldn't be surprised if they were over JT and AM with an injury, intitially... not that it'd be close if there was injury... implying that you expect it to be close if everyone is healthy, which it quite clearly isn't.
You're also talking about a 8 point difference a quarter of the way through the season, with the most productive player missing half that time. Project that out over the course of the season, and that's a 32 point difference, again, assuming Matthews misses half the remaining time. Since there's nothing to suggest he's only going to play a 40 game season, it's really not looking close. You're just using gross numbers to try and make your point look better.
JT and AM are clearly the better offensive producers here, with less ice time... and they're probably the better defensive players as well. This is and always has been an absolutely ridiculous poll.