SpitfireIX
Registered User
Let me be clear. I do not want to trade Marchand whatsoever. However, KPD was right about the Seguin rumours even though many of us thought it was impossible so if he says Marchand is being put up for grabs there is a good chance its true. If so this is the type of deal that makes sense to me. Again I don't want Marchand to be traded he is one of my favs but if we have no choice something like this would make it hurt less.
To Philly: Marchand, Bartkowski and Koklachev
To Boston: Coturier, Simmonds and a 3rd round pick.
With Seguin gone Couturier would give us a solid "franchise" type center for the future who would also be a good understudy to Bergy since Couturier is a very good defensive player already. If Bergy was to get hurt Couturier could slide up one roster spot and we would still be able to compete.
In order to take on Marchand the Flyers would have to give up some contract and Simmonds would make the most sense there. He would also give us a servicable replacement for Marshy.
Philly is weak on defense at the moment and they are supposed to be looking at offloading Coburn and or Mezaros. Bartkowski is alot more valuable then people think because of his cheap contract and relative upside.
Koko is needed in the deal to offset the upside lost by the Flyers in trading a younger player like Couturier.
This would be our lineup:
Lucic Krejci Iginla
Simmonds Bergeron Eriksson
Soderberg Couturier Kelly
Paille Campbell Thornton
Chara Hamilton
Seidenberg Boychuk
Krug McQuaid
Rask
Johnson
Again really don't want to tarde Marsh but if we had to this would be what it would take to prevent me from throwing up and crying at the same time. Change is good but we are bordering on "too much change." Let me know what you think.
To Philly: Marchand, Bartkowski and Koklachev
To Boston: Coturier, Simmonds and a 3rd round pick.
With Seguin gone Couturier would give us a solid "franchise" type center for the future who would also be a good understudy to Bergy since Couturier is a very good defensive player already. If Bergy was to get hurt Couturier could slide up one roster spot and we would still be able to compete.
In order to take on Marchand the Flyers would have to give up some contract and Simmonds would make the most sense there. He would also give us a servicable replacement for Marshy.
Philly is weak on defense at the moment and they are supposed to be looking at offloading Coburn and or Mezaros. Bartkowski is alot more valuable then people think because of his cheap contract and relative upside.
Koko is needed in the deal to offset the upside lost by the Flyers in trading a younger player like Couturier.
This would be our lineup:
Lucic Krejci Iginla
Simmonds Bergeron Eriksson
Soderberg Couturier Kelly
Paille Campbell Thornton
Chara Hamilton
Seidenberg Boychuk
Krug McQuaid
Rask
Johnson
Again really don't want to tarde Marsh but if we had to this would be what it would take to prevent me from throwing up and crying at the same time. Change is good but we are bordering on "too much change." Let me know what you think.