NotOpie
"Puck don't lie"
For Duchene? Not really, that was a haul that Columbus gave up.
The only thing that was a "haul" were the two 1sts and one of those was conditional. Giving up our 3rd and 5th best prospect (using the Athletic's Fall ranking) would have included Kuokkanen and Roy. Also, I believe the 2019 1st was Top 3 protected. I'm one that still believe's that both Kuokkanen and Roy have an NHL future, but even so, I'd have been inclined to make that trade IF and only if, we could have gotten him resigned.
Bean is probably, currently, our 2nd ranked prospect after Necas. I'd be reluctant to give up Gauthier as I've stated before.I dunno, would you have been ok with 2019 1st, conditional 2020 1st (Duchene re-signs), Bean and Gauthier? (Approx 3rd and 5th prospects at beginning of year)
To me this team isn't ready for a high-priced rental and with no guarantee that Duchene is resigning, this seems like a bad decision. If we're going the rental route, I'd be more inclined to try and pull in a Nyquist or something similar....somebody who can add pop, but won't cost high end assets....and maybe even a guy like him costs more than we should be paying.