Speculation: All Time Fighter Line

[Sheppy]

Steve MacIntyre is 6'5 250, he'd have handed everyone their ass, he had 35 lbs of muscle over Brown.

If we're drafting all time fighters, I draft him with my first overall pick.

If he's an option for an all time fighter line, he'd better be on it.

He more or less ended Belak and Boogaard. And Ivanans.

McGrattan > MacIntyre.

 

[bigwoz62]

For mask alone...

 

[McSorley33]

Sharks

San Jose Sharks

Dave Brown, Todd Ewen, Craig Cox, Tim Hunter, Marty McSorley,

 

[Jack Tripper]

canucks:

center - orland kurtenbach
wing - gino odjick
wing - donald brashear
defence - jack mcilhargey
defence - harold snepsts
goal - sean burke
coach - harry neale

 

[Legionnaire11]

Predators (off the top of my head)

Jim McKenzie - Stu Grimson - Patrick Cote
Wade Belak - Shea Weber
Tomas Vokoun

HM to Jordin Tootoo and Darcy Hordichuk who I'd rather have skating a regular shift than any of the forwards mentioned. And I hesitated to put Vokoun as obviously Pekka Rinne would have the size advantage, but Vokoun would get mad and shove a guy once in a while, or get his stick into someone's legs, though the Preds really haven't had any "tough guy" goalies.

 

[Beatle17]

Dave Schultz - Dave Brown - Paul Holmgren
Behn Wilson - Glen Cochrane
Ron Hextall

 

[Bryanbryoil]

Steve MacIntyre is 6'5 250, he'd have handed everyone their ass, he had 35 lbs of muscle over Brown.

If we're drafting all time fighters, I draft him with my first overall pick.

If he's an option for an all time fighter line, he'd better be on it.

He more or less ended Belak and Boogaard. And Ivanans.

How did he end Belak and Boogard? I don't recall him having a decisive victory over Boogard. And as good as he was he still lost badly to Goddard.

 

[Bryanbryoil]

You really wouldn't stick MacIntyre in there? He'd probably SMACk any of those guy as well as anyone else like ever lol

Dave Brown - Semenko - Laraque
McSorley - MacIntyre

He played defense at times too, so how's that lineup for you?

 

[gifted88]

Donald Brashear - John Ferguson - Chris Nilan
Larry Robinson - Sprague Cleghorn
Patrick Roy

 

[GMR]

Dave Schultz - Dave Brown - Paul Holmgren
Behn Wilson - Glen Cochrane
Ron Hextall

Talk about a frightening lineup. You could even put Brashear or Berube in there for Holmgren.

Wilson and Brown on the ice together would be scary.

 

[Beatle17]

Another old school one:

Tony Twist - Todd Ewen - Kelly Chase
Bob Gassoff - Bob Plager
Grant Fuhr (needed a goalie)

 

[Nevins]

Donald Brashear - John Ferguson - Chris Nilan
Larry Robinson - Lyle Odelein

Also Laraque-Kordic

Patrick Roy

Pat Burns

 

[TheNuge]

Think the Canadiens are up there in any conversation of the toughest SOBs

Laraque - Ferguson - Brashear

That alone is scary tough... Laraque man handled a ton of customers in his day.

 

[GMR]

Think the Canadiens are up there in any conversation of the toughest SOBs

Laraque - Ferguson - Brashear

That alone is scary tough... Laraque man handled a ton of customers in his day.

If you're talking guys who played for them at some time, that's correct.

However, I don't remember Laraque fighting that much by then and Brashear wasn't a good fighter in his early days for Montreal. Both of those fighters were better elsewhere.

 

[SgtJoseph*]

dave schultz - dave brown - paul holmgren
behn wilson - glen cochrane
ron hextall

absolutely !

 

[HFBS]

Dave Schultz - Dave Brown - Paul Holmgren
Behn Wilson - Glen Cochrane
Ron Hextall

Certainly the dirtiest line ever.

 

[CHGoalie27]

McGrattan > MacIntyre.

Nope!

 

[CHGoalie27]

How did he end Belak and Boogard? I don't recall him having a decisive victory over Boogard. And as good as he was he still lost badly to Goddard.

Those guys weren't the same after they fought Mac from what I recall.

Godard got in a good shot and if the refs let it continue, he probably wouldve came back and won that round. Godard didnt want face him again that game.

 

[David Bruce Banner]

canucks:

center - orland kurtenbach
wing - gino odjick
wing - donald brashear
defence - jack mcilhargey
defence - harold snepsts
goal - sean burke
coach - harry neale

I like it, but I feel the need to mess with it...

Center - Curt Fraser
Wing - Gino Odjick
Wing - Donald Brashear
Defence - Ed Jovanovski
Defence - Jack McIlhargey
Goal - Dan Cloutier
Coach - Pat Quinn

HM: Rypien, Coxe, Kurtenbach, Delorme and Cochrane.

 

[Sheppy]

Nope!

McGrattan is also 1-0 against Big Mac.

 

[Sheppy]

Those guys weren't the same after they fought Mac from what I recall.

Godard got in a good shot and if the refs let it continue, he probably wouldve came back and won that round. Godard didnt want face him again that game.

He got floored with a punch. The refs got in because MacIntyre was clearly rocked...You can be as biased to to MacIntyre as much as you want but he got absolute drilled, and lost badly.

 

[THall4]

McGrattan > MacIntyre.

Eric Godard also smashed MacIntyre's face in..

 

[ORRMAN]

O'Reilly-Neely-Cashman
Chara- Shore

Every one is a multiple All-Star, and with the exception of Cashman, each is (will be) Hall of Famers. Toughness from top players.

 

[Leetch66]

Domi/Langdon/Fotiu - Beukeboom/Rudy Poeschek and Dan Cloutier in net .

 

[Say Hey Kid]

I'm going to do my favorite NHL line instead:

Tiger Williams - Dale Hunter - Tie Domi - Chris Chelios - Dave Manson - Ron Hextall