I think that in the next 12 months, ONE of Phaneuf or Franson will likely be gone. We're STACKED offensively from the blueline.. Phaneuf, Franson, Gardiner, Liles, and Rielly.
Defensively though? Phaneuf, Gunnarsson, and probably Ranger are our best guys defensively.. and while all three are pretty good defensively, I wouldn't say any of them are "elite" defensive guys.
Phaneuf/Franson represent two guys that have pretty solid trade value and who will be taking up large amounts of capspace over the next few seasons (assuming they were resigned).
Moving one, particularly moving Phaneuf, would hurt for the shortterm... but with Rielly/Percy/Granberg/Finn coming up the pipeline, + development from Gardiner, I think we'd be fine in 2-3 years if you removed one of Phaneuf/Franson from the group.
Anyways, it'll be interesting to see what happens. I just think we have some redundancy back there, and have big needs in terms of cheap young ELC talent, particularly at the centre position.