seventieslord
Student Of The Game
This arguement can be spun back around......Gartner. I take Dino on my team every single time over Gartner
Why dont you worry about Bondra and Palffy getting in if they get in, not as an argument against Dino getting in...
You might be right about Gartner/Ciccarelli. Gartner was only marginally more dominant as a goalscorer, while Ciccarelli brought grit, net presence and a better playoff resume (if you look solely at goals, that is. PIMs and +/- are massive concerns)
Honestly I might be convinced that Ciccarelli is a better HHOFer than Gartner. Doesn't mean we shouldn't be up in arms over this one.
Still, the names I mentioned were just as dominant as Dino.