Every year, instead of trying to rank the playoff teams 1-16, I divide them into broader categories about how I generally feel about them and how I'd react if they won the cup, and several I just don't feel strongly enough about to actually rank them ahead of each other. Feel free to copy my format or make up your own, or whatever.
Would be very happy:
Tampa Bay Lightning
(significant gap)
St. Louis Blues
Would be mildly happy:
Colorado Avalanche
Minnesota Wild
Carolina Hurricanes
Meh:
Nashville Predators
Dallas Stars
Washington Capitals
Would be mildly unhappy:
Calgary Flames
Edmonton Oilers
New York Rangers
Pittsburgh Penguins
Toronto Maple Leafs
Die:
Los Angeles Kings
Boston Bruins
Florida Panthers
Only team I had second thoughts about is that I originally put Toronto in the "die" category and then decided that I didn't feel that strongly about them; I only put them there at first because they're Tampa Bay's opponent.
Would be very happy:
Tampa Bay Lightning
(significant gap)
St. Louis Blues
Would be mildly happy:
Colorado Avalanche
Minnesota Wild
Carolina Hurricanes
Meh:
Nashville Predators
Dallas Stars
Washington Capitals
Would be mildly unhappy:
Calgary Flames
Edmonton Oilers
New York Rangers
Pittsburgh Penguins
Toronto Maple Leafs
Die:
Los Angeles Kings
Boston Bruins
Florida Panthers
Only team I had second thoughts about is that I originally put Toronto in the "die" category and then decided that I didn't feel that strongly about them; I only put them there at first because they're Tampa Bay's opponent.