These lists are impossible to me because I always feel like I should only comment on players I've actually watched. It just seems disingenuous to rate guys I've never really seen play.
Like, I've heard Giuseppe Meazza was incredible , but I have no idea. Paolo Rossi , Dino Zoff ... I mean, even Baresi.... I don't
really know how I'd rate these guys. Baggio's true prime was before I could really adequately judge players too.
So for guys
I've seen , I guess it'd go something like this:
1. Maldini
2. Buffon
3. Totti
4. Pirlo
5. Nesta
6. Cannavaro
7. Del Piero
8. Costacurta
9. De Rossi
10. Chiellini
11. Inzaghi
12. Gattuso
13. Zambrotta
14. Vieri
15. Marchisio
16. Barzagli
17. Luca Toni
18. Bonucci
19. Di Natale
20. Verratti
21. Cassano
22. Insigne
23. Materazzi
24. Gilardino
25. Abbiati
I dunno , this was insanely difficult.
@StevenF1919 ,
@Juve feel free to jump in. I'm sure you guys see it differently and I'm sure I forgot some dudes.