younggunshockey final ranking
- Thread starter Ola
- Start date
- Status
BlueAndWhite
Registered User
Final TOP 15
1 Alexander Ovechkinhttp://younggunshockey.com/ovechkin.htm</FONT></FONT>
2 Evgeni Malkinhttp://younggunshockey.com/malkin.htm
3 Alvaro Montoyahttp://younggunshockey.com/montoya.htm</FONT>
4 Alexander Radulovhttp://younggunshockey.com/radulov.htm</FONT>
5 Lauri Tukonen</FONT>
6 Andrew Laddhttp://younggunshockey.com/ladd.htm</FONT>
7 Drew Staffordhttp://younggunshockey.com/stafford.htm</FONT>
8 Cam Barkerhttp://younggunshockey.com/barker.htm
9 Alexandre Picardhttp://younggunshockey.com/picard.htm</FONT>
10 Rostislav Oleszhttp://younggunshockey.com/olesz.htm
11 Robbie Schremphttp://younggunshockey.com/schremp.htm
12 Andrew Laddhttp://younggunshockey.com/ladd.htm</FONT>
13 A.J. Thelenhttp://younggunshockey.com/thelen.htm
14 Cory Schneiderhttp://younggunshockey.com/schneider.htm
15 Lauri Korpikoski</FONT>
Hello controversy..
1 Alexander Ovechkinhttp://younggunshockey.com/ovechkin.htm</FONT></FONT>
2 Evgeni Malkinhttp://younggunshockey.com/malkin.htm
3 Alvaro Montoyahttp://younggunshockey.com/montoya.htm</FONT>
4 Alexander Radulovhttp://younggunshockey.com/radulov.htm</FONT>
5 Lauri Tukonen</FONT>
6 Andrew Laddhttp://younggunshockey.com/ladd.htm</FONT>
7 Drew Staffordhttp://younggunshockey.com/stafford.htm</FONT>
8 Cam Barkerhttp://younggunshockey.com/barker.htm
9 Alexandre Picardhttp://younggunshockey.com/picard.htm</FONT>
10 Rostislav Oleszhttp://younggunshockey.com/olesz.htm
11 Robbie Schremphttp://younggunshockey.com/schremp.htm
12 Andrew Laddhttp://younggunshockey.com/ladd.htm</FONT>
13 A.J. Thelenhttp://younggunshockey.com/thelen.htm
14 Cory Schneiderhttp://younggunshockey.com/schneider.htm
15 Lauri Korpikoski</FONT>
Hello controversy..
Last edited:
rtafts
Registered User
DaveyCrockett said:
:lol I first thought it was a mistake by BlueandWhite, but no, it's on their website...
Let's see how long it takes before they change it.
:attn:
Captain Conservative
Registered User
What a joke. Stafford ahead of Olesz and Barker?? Ladd listed twice? Those guys need to get their act together if they want to be taken seriously.
RangerBoy
Dolan sucks!!!
rtafts said:
Montoya is highly regarded
You can make a case for Al being the 4th best player in the draft behind the 2 Russians and Cam Barker
RangerBoy
Dolan sucks!!!
Slats432
Registered User
There is no doubt it is a small fan site that is trying to be legitimate. Hopefully they get their act together because that is where you build credibility. Having a duplicate in the top 15 with "controversial" rankings isn't a good way to start.RangerBoy said:
rtafts said:
I would imagine that there's at least a couple teams out there that have him in their top 5.
Doesn't look like there's much consensus outside of the top two picks. Us fans would be shocked if we saw the disparity between the real lists of the NHL teams...
Just for accuracy sake, they have Schneider ranked #14 in thier in-depth coverage...The "double" Ladd in the bottom right top 15 list was just an error which I'm sure they will correct real soon......That error aside, I like their "controversial" rankings even if I don't agree with all of them...They just see more positives in a few players that others don't and, who knows, they may be right..
Jaded-Fan
Registered User
EroCaps said:
One could read it that way . . . or if one were of the 'glass half empty' persuassion those picking from 7 on are going to end up with a second round calibre pick.
NYIschremp44
Registered User
I really like Schneider, but considering Schwarz isn't even on the top 15 I don't know what those people at YGH.com are doing. Let's see what happens when the Ladd error gets fixed, do you think he'll keep the 6 or 12 ranking? Does that move everyone up a slot and a new guy at 15 or is there someone missing that was supposed to be inserted into either 6 or 12 a la Schwarz?
Even if the rankings weren't insane and the Ladd error hadn't been made, the writing on the website is awful. It is, written like this, with way too many, commas. Oh well, i'd rather spend $0 on this than whatevr RLR charges!
Even if the rankings weren't insane and the Ladd error hadn't been made, the writing on the website is awful. It is, written like this, with way too many, commas. Oh well, i'd rather spend $0 on this than whatevr RLR charges!
JNRhockeyGURU said:I really like Schneider, but considering Schwarz isn't even on the top 15 I don't know what those people at YGH.com are doing. Let's see what happens when the Ladd error gets fixed, do you think he'll keep the 6 or 12 ranking? Does that move everyone up a slot and a new guy at 15 or is there someone missing that was supposed to be inserted into either 6 or 12 a la Schwarz?
Even if the rankings weren't insane and the Ladd error hadn't been made, the writing on the website is awful. It is, written like this, with way too many, commas. Oh well, i'd rather spend $0 on this than whatevr RLR charges!
Ooops, my bad! I made things worse for them...They have Schwarz at 12 with Ladd at 6.....ANd Schneider at 14
Vlad The Impaler
Registered User
Captain Conservative said:
After their rankings last year, I don't know if I can ever do that...
Captain Conservative
Registered User
Slats432
Registered User
http://younggunshockey.com/about.htmCaptain Conservative said:
Notable oddities?
Phaneuf at 15?
Stehlik at 16?
Carter at 31?
Kastsitsyn at 41?
Seabrook at 54?
Belle at 76?
Eriksson at 82?
Vlad The Impaler
Registered User
DaveyCrockett said:
First off, I guess we should be happy that someone actually started a thread about us.
That said, I'll answer some of the points people brought up in the next few posts.Ladd X 2: This was a mistake. Every slot from 1-15 was supposed to be Ladd.
But seriously, here's what happened. We sent our web designer the new 1-15 order last night, along with all the new revised profiles. He updated them overnight and looked like he did a great job. Until we got to #12 on our chart 
He scewed up. Nothing more, nothing less. Our company is based in NY and our web designer is based in the UK. He's a friend of a friend who said he could help us out, without charging an arm and a leg. He does good work but isn't perfect and when something goes wrong we can't just open up our computer and fix it. We have to wait for him to do it. He told me it would be fixed by tomorrow. My fingers are crossed. Something similar happened once before and although it's embarassing, I think the quality of work stands for itself. What can ya do? Someone already pointed this out earlier but in our draft guide there was no such mistake. Marek Schwarz is number 12.
Captain Conservative said:
If you've got a crystal ball that shows who'll have a better NHL career then you should rent it out to NHL teams. The fact is we won't know which players have better careers until it happens. We still have Barker as the top-ranked D-man in the draft so his being #8 shouldn't be seen as some kind of knock on him. Nor should anyone look at our rankings as a mock draft. We're sure Barker will go either at #3 or #4. We just think the players we have ranked ahead of him will be better. Just our opinion. Part of the problem with draft rankings is that there's so few resources. All you seem to get are a lot of the same re-hashed opinions when the fact is if you looked at the draft boards for all of the NHL teams, I think you'd be shocked at just how different the rankings are. I would be willing to bet that there probably aren't 2 teams that have the same players ranked in the same order 1-15.
- Status
Ad
Latest posts
-
GDT: 4/25/24 - 7:00PM EDT - #1 Florida vs #1 WC Tampa Bay [ECQF GAME 3]
- Latest: Hockeyville USA
-
