Youngest Cup winner that never won another one

[alko]

Tyler Seguin was a lucky boy. In his first NHL season he was the member of Stanley Cup winner. As a 19 years old. It is too soon to say, that he will never win another.

So, im asking, if there were such examples?

Jaromir Jagr is also a good example. He won the first Cup in his first season. Also as an 19 years old rookie. The next season he won another one. One could say at that time, that he will win another cups. Especially after he grow to Superstar level. But that never happened. Still, he won 2 Cups.

Click to read more...

 

[IceManCat]

Eric Staal

 

[Roboturner913]

Scott Gomez

 

[Numbah4]

Staal was 21 and Gomez 20 when they won it. I wouldn't write Tyler off yet.

 

[Roboturner913]

Seguin is the youngest.

Larry Hillman and Gaye Stewart were both 18 when they won the Cup but they both went on to win it again over the course of their careers. Seguin is third youngest to win it.

 

[nolan pratt]

I believe Marty Gelinas was 19/20 when he won it. Came close a few more times with Calgary and Carolina(?) though.

 

[seventieslord]

Jagr at 18 & 19, still trying 25 years later.

 

[Moose Head]

Brent Sutter won at 19 and 20. Never again. Youngest I could recall among non active players

Langway at 21

 

[Mobiandi]

Theo Fleury won it at 20

 

[Moose Head]

Peter Svoboda had just turned 20 when he won his.

 

[Terry Yake]

i wouldn't count seguin out since he's still very young

i think jagr is the answer. won the cup at 18 and 19 and hasn't won one since now at age 45

 

[Moose Head]

i wouldn't count seguin out since he's still very young

i think jagr is the answer. won the cup at 18 and 19 and hasn't won one since now at age 45

Still officially active though. Looking at the above, I think it's Gelinas. Jagr will probably end up with the title though.

 

[Terry Yake]

Still officially active though. Looking at the above, I think it's Gelinas. Jagr will probably end up with the title though.

if jagr does win the cup in 2018, going 27 years in between cup wins has to be a record right?

 

[seventieslord]

Still officially active though. Looking at the above, I think it's Gelinas. Jagr will probably end up with the title though.

Jagr will. He will never be an important piece of a good team, his last chance to be that was 2013. He can be an important piece of a mediocre team but would not go to a contender where he would not make the top two lines, nor would they want him for that.

 

[Moose Head]

Jagr will. He will never be an important piece of a good team, his last chance to be that was 2013. He can be an important piece of a mediocre team but would not go to a contender where he would not make the top two lines, nor would they want him for that.

Would it had been too much of a shocker to see the Preds or Sens pick up a guy like Jagr at the deadline though?

I don't think a contender will ever sign him in the summer but I could still see him as a deadline pickup if he sticks around another year.

 

[seventieslord]

Would it had been too much of a shocker to see the Preds or Sens pick up a guy like Jagr at the deadline though?

I don't think a contender will ever sign him in the summer but I could still see him as a deadline pickup if he sticks around another year.

........maybe. but then, do they get to the finals with Jagr in a 2nd line RW role? I have a feeling no.

 

[garnetpalmetto]

I believe Marty Gelinas was 19/20 when he won it. Came close a few more times with Calgary and Carolina(?) though.

Yes, he was on the 2002 team that lost the SCF against the Wings.

 

[Voight]

Jagr at 18 & 19, still trying 25 years later.

Crazy thing is he could have had a kid shortly after and now that kid could possibly be a 6 or 7 year veteran.

 

[Kirikanoir]

I believe Marty Gelinas was 19/20 when he won it. Came close a few more times with Calgary and Carolina(?) though.

Your forgetting one team.

 

[reckoning]

Does anybody know what the record is for most years between Cup wins?

The longest I can think of is Chelios at 16 years from '86 to '02.

 

[Hockey Outsider]

Does anybody know what the record is for most years between Cup wins?

The longest I can think of is Chelios at 16 years from '86 to '02.

That's a good trivia question. Recchi is close behind at 15 years (1991 to 2006) - though only 14 seasons.

 

[cupcrazyman]

Jon Sim was 22 with Dallas in 1999

 

[Jets4Life]

Martin Gelinas come to mind.

 

[Jets4Life]

Staal was 21 and Gomez 20 when they won it. I wouldn't write Tyler off yet.

Both Eric(21) and Jordan(20) Staal won it very young, then never repeated the feat.

 

[kmad]

Does anybody know what the record is for most years between Cup wins?

The longest I can think of is Chelios at 16 years from '86 to '02.

This was the record when I looked it up a few years ago, can't imagine it has changed