Winnipeg or Toronto Quartet...

[bobholly39]

Ehlers is better than Ehlers? I disagree.

I'd go Ehlers >>> Ehlers >>> Ehlers

Ehlers.

You're vastly overrating Ehlers imo

 

[All Mod Cons]

I’ll go with the Jets

Matthews is better than Schiefele but it’s close, and I think Ehlers is just a smidge better than Ehlers.

Then I have Connor + Dubois >> Tavares + Nylander. The cap space is huge, too. You could turn that into some real quality pieces. The Toronto group just makes too much money, especially Tavares.

You also had the Leafs missing the playoffs.

 

[Atomos2]

Matthews > Scheifele
Tavares > Dubois
Marner > Ehlers
Nylander < Connor

Leafs

 

[Rhaegar Targaryen]

Matthews > Scheifele
Tavares > Dubois
Marner > Ehlers
Nylander < Connor

Leafs

With contracts you would take Tavares over Dubois?

 

[Dekes For Days]

This is easily the Leafs.

This is my 2nd poll comparing the Toronto quartet , and it amazes me why people take Toronto factoring in contracts.

So essentially, you're making polls in attempts to make the Leaf players lose... something that is incredibly easy to do with the anti-Leaf bias that exists in this forum... and yet you're still failing at it?

are people aware no nhl player in the history of the nhl, with a cap hit of 10 mil AAV or higher has ever won a 7 game playoff series....like ever!

For the overwhelming majority of "the history of the NHL" until the last few years, revenue (and the salary cap) was too low for 10m+ players to exist (not to mention the impact now illegal retirement contracts had), so not sure what you think that proves, especially when you're taking out series wins through added criteria. It's also an incredibly arbitrary number, most evident by the fact that last year's cup winner featured a 9.5m player, and an 8.5m player that didn't even play.

 

[Filthy Dangles]

The one with Auston Matthews in it. And the Marner kid he ain’t bad either

 

[CatchyTune]

I’ll go with the Jets

Matthews is better than Schiefele but it’s close, and I think Ehlers is just a smidge better than Ehlers.

Then I have Connor + Dubois >> Tavares + Nylander. The cap space is huge, too. You could turn that into some real quality pieces. The Toronto group just makes too much money, especially Tavares.

im getting

vibes

also i really hope you werent going to say Ehlers is better than Marner.

 

[All Mod Cons]

im getting

vibes

also i really hope you werent going to say Ehlers is better than Marner.

Hahaha. That image is absolutely perfect for Targaryen

 

[Pyrophorus]

Marner might be better than Ehlers, but not by much and he's twice as expensive.

I was going to say he produces twice as much to be facetious, truthfully I was just about dead on.
So....how is he not better, by that much?

 

[Iapyi]

This is my 2nd poll comparing the Toronto quartet , and it amazes me why people take Toronto factoring in contracts.

are people aware no nhl player in the history of the nhl, with a cap hit of 10 mil AAV or higher has ever won a 7 game playoff series....like ever!

they have 40 million tied up in 4 players as mentioned by the poster above me, and yet the majority still pick Toronto. I just think it’s fascinating

At least you admit you were trying to create an unbalanced poll. How suave and conniving of you.

 

[Pyrophorus]

With contracts you would take Tavares over Dubois?

44pts over 33
yes.

 

[Iapyi]

You also had the Leafs missing the playoffs.

That person would still pick the Leafs today to miss the playoffs. They still haven't clinched and yada blah yada blah blah yada.

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

I’ll go with the Jets

Matthews is better than Schiefele but it’s close, and I think Ehlers is just a smidge better than Ehlers.

Then I have Connor + Dubois >> Tavares + Nylander. The cap space is huge, too. You could turn that into some real quality pieces. The Toronto group just makes too much money, especially Tavares.

You'll go with the Jets because you literally ALWAYS vote against Toronto

 

[Mats13]

The question is aksing which 4 would you take considering their contracts. 4 players 40 mils Toronto vs 4 players 24 mils Jets.
If I would build a new team, the difference in cap space is huge.

As for moving assets, I would say it is easier to build around 4 top forwards than around 3...If you trade Tavares from that quartet, you are left with 3 forwards making more money than the Jest quartet, yet combining (this season) for fewer goals, fewer assits and fewer points. And somehow this is better because.... Something something, Toronto.

If it’s easier to build around the Winnipeg guys, why are the Leafs better?

 

[Michael HOMERUNing]

You guys keep talking about the extra cap space, let's look at who the Jets are spending this cap on:
4 million dollar 3rd liner Mathieu Perreault
3 million dollar #6 d-man Dylan Demelo
6 million dollar fringe 2nd liner Bryan Little

If you go through every team in the league, you're gonna see the same situation with 90 percent of them. The reality is, most GMs struggle to use their cap space effectively. And you guys actually think you can do a better job.

 

[Jimmy Firecracker]

This is my 2nd poll comparing the Toronto quartet , and it amazes me why people take Toronto factoring in contracts.

are people aware no nhl player in the history of the nhl, with a cap hit of 10 mil AAV or higher has ever won a 7 game playoff series....like ever!

they have 40 million tied up in 4 players as mentioned by the poster above me, and yet the majority still pick Toronto. I just think it’s fascinating

Dude just make a “Leafs 4 vs Lightning 4” if you want Toronto to lose a poll so badly. I mean honestly it’s not hard to get Leafs players to lose polls on this board.