Who would you rather have on your team: Jack Eichel or Alex Tuch?

[La Cosa Nostra]

LOL. Tuch makes less then HALF then Eichel and has been far far better since the trade. Tuch AINEC.

 

[Regal]

Last year when people were critical of Eichel for his poor performance people said "wait until next year when he gets a full camp and adjusts to his new team"... well he went on to pace for a 73 point season.

Let's face it, he may always be a 100 point talent but he'll never likely get anywhere near that with his 10 cent attitude and brain.

To be fair, he did start the year strong before getting injured and he hasn’t been the same since, so he likely has been playing through something. I don’t know if this year means he still can’t be that franchise player, but you’re right, at some point he’s going to have to actually show it consistently

 

[SnuggaRUDE]

I think Eichel is the better player by a fair margin. It’s not an interesting question without factoring contracts.

 

[NiagaraKraken]

Fully healthy Eichel, but not sure we will ever see a fully healthy Eichel again.

 

[lawrence]

Jack Eichel. He's just way more talented like cmon guys. Tuch had to be traded with 3 additional parts for him. However I don't like Eichels complaining through social media antic. No matter how badly buffalo treated him.

 

[Steddy33]

Who cares if Eichel is more talented. He rarely performs to expectations and is way overpaid.