Who would you rather have '04

montreal · May 26, 2004

Taken from the thread on current NHL drafted prospects, I thought I would do the same for this draft.

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

montreal · May 26, 2004

Guess I'll start

Malkin
Thelen
Schwarz
Meszaros
Volshenko
Nokelainen
Hedman
Valabik
Picard
Stafford
Olesz
Hromas
Schneider
Pineault
Soderberg
Berti
Lisin

Cayouche5 · May 26, 2004

I don't see 19/20 of them so I will only go by what i read or see.

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik Didn't see or read anything
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti Didn't see or read anything
Lisin or Sindel

degroat* · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neill
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Schneider or Dubnyk
Lisin or Sindel

Legionnaire · May 26, 2004

Malkin
Thelen
Montoya
Meszaros
Radulov
Korpikoski
Fransson
O'Neil
Picard
Stafford
Tukonen
Gracik
Dubnyk
Pineault
Soderberg
Berti
Lisin

thestonedkoala · May 26, 2004

Malkin
Barker
Schwarz
Smid
Radulov
Korpikoski
Hedman
Valabik
Picard
Stafford
Olesz
Gracik (don't know anything about these two)
Schneider
Graham
Soderberg
Berti
Lisin

BrettNYR · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

eSabre · May 26, 2004

Malkin
Barker
Montoya
Meszaros
Radulov
Korpikoski
Fransson
Valabik
Picard
Stafford
Tukonen
Gracik
Schneider
Pineault
Salomonsson
Garlock
Sindel

Epsilon · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

PhoPhan · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

UpsideHockey · May 26, 2004

montreal said:
Guess I'll start

Malkin
Thelen
Schwarz
Meszaros
Volshenko
Nokelainen
Hedman
Valabik
Picard
Stafford
Olesz
Hromas
Schneider
Pineault
Soderberg
Berti
Lisin

The exact opposite of yours Montreal except 1st & last (Malkin & Lisin)!

Epsilon · May 26, 2004

After 10 posts, Malkin is the ONLY guy that everyone has picked. I don't expect that to change any time soon either.

Duff88 · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

rt · May 26, 2004

It looks like you guys are split right down the middle on Tukonen V. Olesz. What were your reasons for picking the one over the other?

Classic Devil · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

Russian Fan · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

Munchausen · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik (don't know much about either)
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

Seachd · May 26, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Voloshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salmonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

monster_bertuzzi · May 27, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Voloshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salmonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel[/QUOTE]

Blue Bullet · May 27, 2004

Malkin
Barker
Schwarz
Smid
Radulov
Nokelainen
Fransson
Valabik
Picard
Stafford
Olesz
Gracik
Schneider
Graham
Salomonsson
Garlock
Lisin

Boomhower · May 27, 2004

Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

ChemiseBleuHonnete · May 27, 2004

Malkin
Thelen
Montoya
Smid
Radulov
Korpikoski
Fransson
O'Neil
Picard
Chipchura
Olesz
Hromas
Schneider
Graham
Salomonsson
Berti
Sindel

Captain Conservative · May 27, 2004

Duff88 said:
Malkin or Ladd
Barker or Thelen
Montoya or Schwarz
Smid or Meszaros
Radulov or Volshenko
Korpikoski or Nokelainen
Fransson or Hedman
Valabik or O'Neil
Wolski or Picard
Chipchura or Stafford
Tukonen or Olesz
Hromas or Gracik
Schneider or Dubnyk
Pineault or Graham
Salomonsson or Soderberg
Garlock or Berti
Lisin or Sindel

Agree w/ this.

West · May 27, 2004

montreal said:
Taken from the thread on current NHL drafted prospects, I thought I would do the same for this draft.

Malkin
Thelen
Montoya
Meszaros
Radulov
Korpikoski
Fransson
O'Neil
Wolski
Chipchura
Olesz
Gracik
Schneider
Pineault
Soderberg
Berti
Sindel

moosefan · May 27, 2004

Malkin
Barker
Schwarz
Smid
Radulov
Korpikoski
Fransson
O'Neil
Wolski
Stafford
Olesz
Hromas
Schneider
Graham
Salomonsson
Garlock
Sindel

Who would you rather have '04

Go Habs Go

Go Habs Go

Registered User

degroat*

Guest

Help On The Way

thestonedkoala

Guest

Registered User

Registered User

#basta

Registered User

Registered User

#basta

Registered User

The Kinder, Gentler Version

Spirit of 1988

Registered User

Munchausen

Guest

Registered User

registered user

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Registered User

Ad

Ad

Ad