Really tough at 39. Galiardi had one really good season for us then bounced around the 4th line and press box, never finding the same form from that year and his huge playoff series again. Ville had back-to-back double digit goal scoring seasons, both years playing less than 55 games. Had some injuries and was very hot and cold, but is also a Stanley Cup champion with us and played a key part in the '01 playoffs with 10 points and 2 of his 4 goals being game-winners. Almost went with Arnason for the lulz factor, but ultimately I have to stab my friend in the back and go with Ville over TJ.
At 40, loved Svatos like crazy but Tanguay has been an incredible Av. 5 20+ goal seasons, 4 times over 25 goals. 50 assists three different times. Massive game 7 in the '01 Cup finals. 466 points as a member of the Colorado Avalanche.
Puck Pose at 41. Andy had one great season for us, but Skoula put in 5 years for us, won a Cup on our 3rd pairing and actually played some massive minutes in those playoffs due to injuries. Took a lot of crap from our fanbase, but Marty was a quiet, solid contributor.