Who is worse?

[The Macho King]

Sustr or Carle?

Click to read more...

 

[Hoek]

Carle is worse money wise but I can't think of a game where Sustr surprised me with how good he was. Even Carle has had good, quiet nights here and there.

 

[dechire]

Voted Giraffe because there's not a single pairing that he hasn't been able to drag down. Traffic Cone just sucks by himself. He doesn't infect everyone else he plays with.

 

[ThunderAlleyNomad]

Giraffe. Can anybody name anything he does well? I've seen him a lot tonight and every single time he's ****ing up.

 

[These Are The Days]

6 votes giraffe 2 votes traffic cone. It's a sign

 

[Stammertime91]

Giraffe, by a safari mile.

 

[Klutch86]

Sustr AINEC he's so goddamn terrible it's painful watching that clown play. 0 NHL caliber skill and dosent move his feet constantly outmuscled and worked. If Carle had a better contract he'd be tolerable.

 

[MattM92]

Carle is slightly better than Sustr, but Carle makes like 4 times the money. I'll take Sustr any day over Carle and a cardboard cutout of 70 year old Leonard Nimoy over either of them.

 

[FinnLightning26]

I became depressed trying to think who is worse. Thinking about their flaws and then realizing they both play about 16-18 minutes every night does that. Thank god Coop has started to healthy scratch them.

But, I voted for the Giraffe. Like Hoek said, Carle atleast surprises you with an occasional good night.

 

[Victhor Ollesson]

Both probably shouldn't be in the NHL at this point. But I'll say Carle, because of his salary. Having them on the roster is hindering this team from unlocking its true potential, and that makes me .

 

[xteesy]

Carle actually stepped up last game (not tonights) and did a few impressive things. He's not a fit for THIS team, but he definitely has a few more years of NHL level play in him.

Just not for $5.5M a year...

He needs a guy like Hedman on his wing that will make his mistakes "hidden" so to speak and allow him to look better by association.

The giraffe.... The giraffe is a freakin giraffe, nuff said...

 

[Sky04]

Carle actually stepped up last game (not tonights) and did a few impressive things. He's not a fit for THIS team, but he definitely has a few more years of NHL level play in him.

Just not for $5.5M a year...

He needs a guy like Hedman on his wing that will make his mistakes "hidden" so to speak and allow him to look better by association.

The giraffe.... The giraffe is a freakin giraffe, nuff said...

Carle has decent moments, he'll do some stupid **** at times but he can play in the NHL, I truly believe we're only playing Sustr so much because we've already invested so much time in him, pretty much a sunk cost right now.

I think we'd have a better chance of getting something for Carle than Sustr.

 

[The Gongshow]

Carle. He makes more than Hedman. Think about that. (I know Heddy is up for a big pay day but still) Carle is bad, and needs to go so we can have that money back. That money pays for Stamkos with hopefully a little bit of change left over

 

[Kramerica Industries]

I only vote Carle based on contract. I think it'll ultimately be easier to let go of Sustr than it will be with Carle.

 

[LightningStrikes]

I'm voting Carlo. One's a young fella trying to find his place in this league, the other is the highest paid defenseman on the team who's supposed to lead by example, showing his experience and chip in offensively. Instead he's a liability on the 3rd pairing or a healthy scratch like last night.

 

[2MinutesforGiraffing]

I voted Sustr based on play, but for the team as a whole Carle is worse. His contract is an albatross. I'll be very surprised if we keep Sustr past this contract. He's just not developing like they'd hoped (physically or otherwise).

 

[AlphaCatalyst]

It's like a reverse Sophie's choice.

I voted Sustr based on play, but for the team as a whole Carle is worse. His contract is an albatross. I'll be very surprised if we keep Sustr past this contract. He's just not developing like they'd hoped (physically or otherwise).

This is pretty much the answer.
Sustr is worse but if it came down to getting rid of one over the other Caryle and his contract would be the guy I'd like to see gone.

 

[Hoek]

Yeah, Carle would be a greater addition by subtraction all things considered.

 

[Lord Stan 2020]

after last nights play nestea atrocious coburn bad sustr worse

i am seriously happy that the team is keeping carle for the cup run right now

i hate carle and that contract but he is sooooooo much better then sustr on the ice is no comparison

am hoping for slater and nestea to get big minutes improve and take sustr and carles spots but last night left a ton to be desired i dont even have words of the disgust i felt to be honest was not even going to talk into the daily stuff on this till nestea got sent down i was that frustrated honestly

carle is ok coburn is ok sustr just is bad last night nestea was bad bad bad so having a guy who has been in league forever is safe for now

yes i want carle moved just unsure how wise that is till we fight for the cup think we need to probably keep the man this full season and then sell for anything we can get even keep some money to move him after this year

i want a legit cup shot and carle right now is the better option for that unfortunately cause his contract is definitely an albatross or hinderance moving forward

so on ths same page guys just im ok if we keep carle if slater and nestea need more time we have a cup team imho but gonna need everyone even carle for that and sustr just gets worse and worse smdh

 

[DenverBoone]

Carle is the guy everybody hates but then misses when he's out. It was the same way in Philly. Wierd

 

[MattM92]

Carle is the guy everybody hates but then misses when he's out. It was the same way in Philly. Wierd

He was out last night and we didn't miss him at all. Nesterov had a horrible game and we still consider it an improvement because Nesterov is still developing.

 

[2020 Cup Champions]

Carle is the guy everybody hates but then misses when he's out. It was the same way in Philly. Wierd

This is not at all the state of affairs with regards to Carle.

 

[The Macho King]

Carle is the guy everybody hates but then misses when he's out. It was the same way in Philly. Wierd

Er....

Yeah, gonna disagree that assessment.

 

[DenverBoone]

This is not at all the state of affairs with regards to Carle.

well, what I meant was you'd want Carle in the lineup rather than Sustr or an AHL player if Carle get's hurt. I guess some would disagree.

 

[Sky04]

well, what I meant was you'd want Carle in the lineup rather than Sustr or an AHL player if Carle get's hurt. I guess some would disagree.

Koekkoek > Carle.