Who is this team's best player?

[Ambassador Of Fun]

Poll to gauge everyone's opinion.

Click to read more...

 

[oconnor9sean]

Well there's no poll, but I'll say this:

I honestly can't choose between Benn or Seguin. Benn brings so much to the table, but Seguin has elite game breaking potential, and it's looking like he's getting there. If I could only keep one, I'd probably pick Seguin.

Edit: Poll is up now
Edit 2.0: Where is Goligoski on the poll?

 

[Stars99Lobo37]

Talent wise, it's by far Tyler Seguin.

Jamie is a more well rounded player (imo) and so far, the bigger the stage the bigger he performs. He's just been lights out whenever we've needed him to be.

 

[Kalamazoo Wings]

By best you mean favorite of the 3 right?

Needless to say, we've got 3 excellent players at their respective positions to choose from.

 

[Kalamazoo Wings]

Talent wise, it's by far Tyler Seguin.

Jamie is a more well rounded player (imo) and so far, the bigger the stage the bigger he performs. He's just been lights out whenever we've needed him to be.

This is exactly what I was thinking but couldn't put into word and the reason I picked Chubbs.

 

[Ambassador Of Fun]

If mods can add an "other" option, feel free to do it, but I don't think it is necessary

 

[Starsfan24]

Went with Benn, Segs has the points, but I just feel Jamie is the better all around player. I'll gladly have both on my team though.

 

[CRSeven]

Seguin's amazing, but I gotta say Benn. He impacts the game in more ways, more often.

I'm just glad we have both of them.

 

[Dr Pepper]

Gotta go with Benn, for reasons previously stated. Tough call though, since Seguin can elevate his offensive game to a higher level when he's firing on all cylinders.

Of course....even with the two of them, we'd be on the outside looking in if it wasn't for Kari. But you could probably say that for any starter.

 

[Ampersand]

Benn, better all around, yadda yadda yadda.

 

[Klockis]

I choose Seguin but my opinion changes every few days. But I did settle with Seguin because he has IMO been more consistent this season. But then when Benn shows up (usually when it matters the most) he REALLY does show up.

I would rather have a "can't choose" option available.

 

[Cin]

It's clearly Goligoski.

Went with Seguin. His ceiling is realllllllyyyyy high, and he's already starting to show that he belongs among names like Tavares and Toews.

Benn is really great, but Seguin is literally a threat anywhere on the ice.

 

[ElGuapo]

Benn. Doesn't score hat tricks and less 4-5 point games. That alone makes him better than Seguin. Seriously though, I did vote Benn.

 

[RastaRockett]

Do you like chicken, or CHICKEN?

 

[Hull Fan]

Seguin has game breaking ability on every shift and makes others around him better.

 

[LT]

I choose Seguin but my opinion changes every few days. But I did settle with Seguin because he has IMO been more consistent this season. But then when Benn shows up (usually when it matters the most) he REALLY does show up.

I would rather have a "can't choose" option available.

I'd say it's quite the opposite, honestly.

Went with Kari. No one has an impact on this team like he does. He's probably the most purely talented player we have (at his position, at least) and he uses it. The team just seems to do worse without Kari than without Benn in the small samples where that's been the case.

 

[MetalGodAOD*]

Depends. Now? Probably Benn. Overall? IMO Seguin. Benn is putting it all together this year but he's 2 years older than Seguin. Seguin's doing things at 21/22 well beyond Jamie at that time.

 

[English stars fan]

Benn at the moment, but Seguin is more offensively dynamic and has a higher ceiling.

 

[haf]

Benn at the moment, but Seguin is more offensively dynamic and has a higher ceiling.

I went with Benn. For many of the reasons stated above but would add that while Seguin is perhaps more talented, Benn just has will and he seems to bring the team with him. I think Benn's strength also makes it harder to take him out of the game. So while Seguin's upside is higher, Benn is more able to dictate his game overall. Meh. Kind of botched it, but something like that.

 

[aloonda*]

goalies are in their own club


benn is the best player
seguin has the most talent

 

[Satan]

I didn't really want to choose...


I love Kari.. He has stolen many games for us. I don't really class him with the skaters though, so I ignored him as an option.

Flipped a coin, Benn won the toss.

 

[Rune Forumwalker]

Goligoski. Whenever he is on the ice he makes everyone in the stands sit up and ask "Sergei, who?".

 

[brinkmanjs]

Really glad we have all 3

They have all taken over games this year.

I really believe Segs has Modano like potential. FO's a weakness. Only time will tell.

Benn is complete player. Plays Wing or Center, skates, shoots really well, fights and his defense is coming along. (got my vote)

Kari has stood on his head several times this season alone, stealing games we clearly should've lost.

Love this team!!!

Keep rolling!!!

 

[The Tourist]

Benn

I think he does more than Seguin and he could carry a line more than Seguin. Both are great though.

 

[marquee]

Clearly kari. Team was abysmal in his absence earlier this season.

Skaters:benn