Which Package would u rather add to your team

[flamesforcup]

This is inspired by todays trade. Who would u rather add to ur team. Basically a way to see how Hf sees this trade

Click to read more...

 

[Moon Knight]

Hamilton + Fox > Hanifin. Hamilton is the best player in the trade and Fox is a good prospect.

Lindholm=Ferland. Just depends on what your team wants. For Carolina, getting the grittier player makes sense.

 

[Silky mitts]

I don’t know how to evaluate all the unsigned players and I will admit I have no idea who Fox is

 

[Chan790]

As a Canes fan, I think its an unmitigated disaster and that in consideration of the rest of the draft weekend, we need to run Waddell and Dudley out of town with fire and pitchforks.

Fire them today!

 

[Sabresruletheschool]

Ill take the 25 year old top pairing guy and a good prospect over a defencmen that hasn't proven much and a disappointing 40 point player demanding a million + contract.

 

[AlexBrovechkin8]

Depends on what happens with Carlson and Kempny. If Carlson resigns but Kempny walks give me Hanifin. If Kempny resigns and Carlson walks give me Hamilton.

 

[1TuchAnd1NoTuch]

I think the value is real close. Hamilton is the best player in the trade so I went with that package

 

[jetsforever]

Flames guys

 

[bobholly39]

Flames guys

Current, or ex?

 

[Halla]

2 as a leafs fan. Hamilton is the RHD we need and fox would be a nice add as a prospect

 

[Blue Shakehead]

With Buff, Trouba and Myers - the Jets don't need Hamilton (though he's obviously the best player today). There's also something weird about a 23 year old top 3 D getting traded twice in 2 years. Whats the deal with him?

Hanifin is underrated and I like Lindblom a lot more than Ferland. So I will take the former Canes players.

 

[flamesforcup]

Well as of now results are really close. Guess we can say it was an even trade for both teams.
Good solid trade all round.

 

[Elias Pettersson]

Current, or ex?

yes

 

[Peanut]

Give me Dougie

 

[VoluntaryDom]

I don’t know how to evaluate all the unsigned players and I will admit I have no idea who Fox is

Fox is a Harvard guy and is very good. Only concern is he might not sign.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Dougie~Noah
Micheal~Elias
Adam>nothing

 

[Spoilers]

I’ll take the package with the top pairing defenseman and the great prospect. I was stunned when I saw Fox was part of the deal. I think the Flames are going to regret that one. That kid has been phenomenal any time I’ve seen him.

That being said, Lindholm still has a lot of potential. Not a huge Hanafin fan but he’s a top 4 D already.

 

[Garbage Goal]

I’ll take the former Flames trio. Hamilton is the best player in the deal by far and the value is really close between the NHL players involved. If Fox hits his potential then that package blows the other one out of the water.

 

[EdJovanovski]

Hanifin & Lindholm AINEC

 

[Lemmiwinks]

Everyone's sleeping on Ferland.

 

[Pay Carl]

kind of crazy someone as talented as Dougie has been traded twice already and he's barely 25

 

[Sasso09]

Hamilton + Fox > Hanifin. Hamilton is the best player in the trade and Fox is a good prospect.

Lindholm=Ferland. Just depends on what your team wants. For Carolina, getting the grittier player makes sense.

How is Ferland = Lindholm??

 

[Haatley]

Whats this craziness people talking about Ferland being equal to Lindholm. Its not close. Lindholm is better, younger and adds more.

Hamilton is better than Hanifin currently, but the Flames needed depth and a right handed shot in their top 6. Plus Hanifin has performed fantastic for a kid his age with a super higu ceiling.

Fox may never sign in Carolina.

 

[ricky0034]

Hanifin will end up being easily the best player in this deal when it's all said and done,Carolina will regret trading him away at the age of 21

 

[Tripod]

Giroux Couts Ferland
Konecny Patrick Voracek
Lindblom Frost Simmonds

Provy Hamilton
Sanheim Myers
Ghost Fox

Lol....that may be too many PMD on defense!

 

[MardyBum]

Hanifin and Lindholm pretty easily.

1. Fox wouldn't sign with us.

2. Hamilton wouldn't get top pairing minutes so he'd be just as miserable as he was in Calgary. Hanifin as a LHD could be partnered up with Buff.

3. Lindholm can be a C which we need more than a grinding winger that can score a few goals.

In a vacuum i'd rather have the best player, Hamilton, but the other two fit the Jets better.

 

[JPeeper]

I'm happy with the trade. The more that comes out it just seems like Hamilton didn't give a shit about winning or being in Calgary (GM said as much in paraphrasing). I don't think Hamilton possesses the heart needed for a Cup winning team, he doesn't have the drive to be better defensively (it seems anyway from watching him). You watch Gio haul ass in the d-zone and defend then you watch Hamilton and you see something isn't there with him; but he's still a very good player.

I think Hanifin given a couple more years will surpass what Hamilton is today as a much more complete player, maybe not with the same offense as Dougie's shot is elite and I haven't seen Hanifin's yet.

Lindholm >>>>> Ferland.

I doubt Ferland breaks 20 goals and 30 points away from Monahan playing in Carolina, even if he plays with Aho.

Fox was never signing with Calgary anyway.

 

[Iapyi]

Hamilton is better then Hanifan. Ferland is better then Lindholm. Fox is better then nothing.

Flames lose this BIG TIME.

 

[The Beyonder]

A top RHD, a solid depth forward and a young prospect would be perfect for the leafs.

 

[tony d]

Option 2. Carolina won this deal hands down.

 

[Haatley]

Hamilton is better then Hanifan. Ferland is better then Lindholm. Fox is better then nothing.

Flames lose this BIG TIME.

Ferland is not very good.

 

[Bronson]

Hanifin + Lindholm. Imo Hamilton and Hanifin are about as skilled as each other but the Islanders desperately need a third line center and I think Lindholm would be ideal. Ferland would not fit due to all the leftwingers already on the team and Fox would probably not sign due to Dobson, Wilde, Toews, Aho, Wotherspoon, Van De Sompel and all the others of our D prospects.