Tribute What would your all time Stars team look like?

[Notabaguette]

What would your all time Stars team look like?

Benn Modano Lehtinen
Seguin Nieuwendyk Hull
Morrow Charbonneau Ludwig
Langenbrunner Richards Eriksson
Zubov Hatcher
Klingberg Sydor
Matvichuk Boucher
Belfour
Turco

Click to read more...

 

[Satan]

Based purely on nostalgia:

Hull - Modano - Lehtinen
Benn - Seguin - Ribeiro
Morrow - Nieuwendyk - Langenbrunner
Neal - Carbonneau - Radulov
Ott, Eriksson

Hatcher - Zubov
Sydor - Klingberg
Heiskanen - Robidas
Matvichuk, Boucher

Belfour
Bishop
Turco

 

[Satan]

Left on the cutting floor: Jason Spezza, Ryan Garbutt, Eric Nystrom, Pat Verbeek, Niko Kapanen, and the entire Minnesota North Stars history.

 

[LT]

Jamie Benn - Mike Modano - Jere Lehtinen
Brendan Morrow - Tyler Seguin - Brett Hull
Mike Ribeiro - Brad Richards - Alex Radulov
Loui Eriksson - Joe Nieuwendyk - Jason Arnott
Bill Guerin, Pat Verbeek

Derian Hatcher - Sergei Zubov
Daryl Sydor - John Klingberg
Esa Lindell - Miro Heiskanen
Stephane Robidas

Ed Belfour
Marty Turco

Plenty of HMs that were good but not great. Toughest choice was Turco vs. Bishop. Lehtonen easily could've been on there too had he had better teams. He really was a top 10 goalie for probably half a decade.

 

[BrettHullsToe]

Brenden Morrow - Steve Ott - Shane Churla
Antoine Roussel - Dave Gagner - Dino Ciccarelli
Jamie Benn - Todd Harvey - Pat Verbeek
Grant Marshall - Sean Avery - Jamie Langenbrunner

Derian Hatcher - Mark Tinordi
Craig Ludwig - Stephane Robidas
Richard Matvichuk - Kevin Hatcher

Ed Belfour
Anton Khudobin

 

[Satan]

Plenty of HMs that were good but not great. Toughest choice was Turco vs. Bishop. Lehtonen easily could've been on there too had he had better teams. He really was a top 10 goalie for probably half a decade.

Yeah, that's why I went Olympic team style and took a guy to sit in the press box

 

[M88K]

Hull-Modano-Lehtinen
Benn-Seguin-Eriksson
Morrow-Neiuwendyk-Langenbrunner
Neal-Richards-Radulov

Heiskanen-Zubov
Hatcher-Klingberg
Sydor-Boucher

Belfour
Bishop

 

[Kalamazoo Wings]

Benn Modano Lehtinen
Richards Nieuwendyk Verbeek
Eriksson Turgeon Hull
Morrow Ribeiro Audette
Langenbrunner

Heiskanen Zubov
Sydor Klingberg
Tinordi Lindell
Robidas

Casey
Khudobin
Belfour

Includes Minnesota and just players I liked in their prime. Like Audette and Turgeon weren't great as Stars but I loved them as Sabres.

 

[M88K]

What would your all time Stars team look like?

Benn Modano Lehtinen
Seguin Nieuwendyk Hull
Morrow Charbonneau Ludwig
Langenbrunner Richards Eriksson
Zubov Hatcher
Klingberg Sydor
Matvichuk Boucher
Belfour
Turco

Someone has to mention this right?

 

[Notabaguette]

Someone has to mention this right?

Good defensive forward for that line.

 

[LT]

Good defensive forward for that line.

Ludwig was not a forward. Nor was he very good.

 

[Satan]

ya but think about the shinpads

 

[M88K]

Good defensive forward for that line.

Craig Ludwig played defense.
Unless there is another Ludwig from the early North Stars days, that played forward, that i'm forgetting, but i don't think so.

 

[Magic Mittens]

Benn - Modano - Seguin
Neal - Richards - Eriksson
Morrow - Nieuwendyk - Lehtinen
Hull - Spezza - Radulov

Hatcher - Zubov
Lindell - Klingberg
Sydor - Heiskanen

Belfour
Bishop ( really wanted to put Turco )

may as well let Ruff coach this team so we can see some goals!

 

[Klumppa]

Benn - Modano - Lehtinen
Morrow - Seguin - Hull
Jagr - Nieuwendyk - Langenbrunner
Lind - Faksa - J.Jokinen

Hatcher - Numminen
Lindell - Klingberg
Heiskanen - Sydor

Bishop
Belfour

 

[M88K]

Benn - Modano - Lehtinen
Morrow - Seguin - Hull
Jagr - Nieuwendyk - Langenbrunner
Lind - Faksa - J.Jokinen

Hatcher - Numminen
Lindell - Klingberg
Heiskanen - Sydor

Bishop
Belfour

You should be ashamed of yourself for leaving Zubov off in place of literally all of them

 

[Klumppa]

You should be ashamed of yourself for leaving Zubov off in place of literally all of them

I'm Finnish, the title asks what would MY allstar team looks like.

 

[MBTendy]

I'm Finnish, the title asks what would MY allstar team looks like.

well then expect to be called out for leaving a HOF/Number Retiree player off your All-Time roster over all those players.

 

[Klumppa]

well then expect to be called out for leaving a HOF/Number Retiree player off your All-Time roster over all those players.

If the title said make a lineup of the best players of the Dallas Stars of course he would be up there on the top lineup. But it didn't. He isn't one of my favorite players.

 

[The Tourist]

Benn-Modano-Hull
Lehtinen-Niewendyk-Seguin
Morrow-Ribeiro-Radulov
Spezza-Richards-Eriksson

Miro-Zubov
Hatcher-Klingberg
Sydor-Lindell

Belfour
Turco (Bishop by the time he's done here)

Left off guys who played all or majority in Minnesota (Gagner, Dino, Broten, etc). Last spot for me came down to Spezza and Arnott since I left off the Minny guys. On defense last spot came down to Lindell, Boucher, Matvichuk, and Goligoski.

 

[The Tourist]

I'm Finnish, the title asks what would MY allstar team looks like.

No love for Miettinen and Hagman?

 

[Johno]

No love for Miettinen and Hagman?

Needs more Niinimaa

 

[Saucechucker99]

Does Iginla count?

 

[Satan]

I'm Canadian, so my all time team includes Aaron Rome

 

[Magic Mittens]

Does Iginla count?

I’d say no as he never played a single game for Dallas