These are impossible to answer. The obvious choice here is the elite scorer, but there are too many factors. Maybe the elite guy's contract is $14M and the two 60 point scorers are both on league min deals.
More realistically, maybe the 60 point guys are Danualt style centers, like another poster alluded. For the Canes, Jordan Staal is having an elite season by defensive metrics. His line is an absurd like 60% of GF when he plays, and he plays against top competition with Nino and Fast. But he only has 36 points. That's an edge case, but it's true there are players who score boatloads of points who are so bad defensively that they aren't worth their cap hits.