My thoughts on the players so far:
Backlund: Grossly underrated. He may never be that 50-60 point center, but he's become an exceptional two way guy. He's creating chances, moving the puck, and holding his own against top competition.
Bollig: I think we may have seen what could be called the end of McGrattan. He may not fight as well, but he does everything else much better than Brian. I questioned this acquisition at first, but he's growing on me.
Bouma: Again, he's improved so much. He was a beast against Winnipeg. While he's an amazing bottom 6 guy, I hope we don't see him in the top 6 again.
Colborne: He's showing top 6 potential. He's showing a lot of confidence, and he's becoming more and more physical. I hope he starts shooting more, but I can't complain with 8 assists.
Gaudreau: He's been having a quietly great start. I've noticed teams are keeping a close eye on him, and trying to limit the room he gets. Regardless, he's made some amazing plays. He's only going to get better.
Glencross: Honestly, I haven't noticed him much. He's been sound defensively, but I'm starting to wonder if these injuries are catching up with him. As it stands, I'd lean towards dealing him at the deadline. As someone else has already mentioned, Reinhart could be ready to fill his spot by next year.
Hudler: He's been good so far. Keeps creating chances, great at moving the puck. Not really much else I could ask from him.
Jones: What can I say? He's done. If he were a UFA, I'm sure there would be a few teams signing him to be a 13th guy or bottom line winger. He doesn't make many mistakes, but offensively, he's just about dried up.
Jooris: He's been one of the biggest surprises this year. The definition of effort/heart. I hope he sticks this year.
McGrattan: Meh.
Monahan: He had a slow start, but he's still been consistent. I'm sure he'll pick up the pace.
Raymond: Yet another big surprise. He's contributing a lot of chances, and he's capitalized often. I am a bit concerned he'll drop off out of nowhere, as he has a past of doing so.
Setoguchi: Another meh. Raymond worked out well so far, but the same can't be said for Seto.
Stajan: He's had a slow start, but he can still be relied on for what he's best at. Being a serviceable 2nd/3rd line center with a strong two way game. I'm not sure how effective he'll be in the next few years, but it's still early.
Brodie: My god, what the **** happened to him? Last year, he was a decent #2. Now, he's looking like a legitimate #1. IMO, he's been better than Giordano so far. Possibly the best Flame this year.
Diaz: Was he really a better option than Brookbank?
Engelland: He's been... okay. Decent bottom pairing guy, and he's another physical threat who can bash a few skulls if need be.
Giordano: A lot of people thought he might drop off again. They were clearly wrong. I hope this doesn't wind up being taken the wrong way, but I really wonder if Iggy was actually as good of a leader as he is made out to be. Once Gio became Captain, it seemed everyone came together last year.
Russell: He's been great as well, especially with Wideman. Looking like a decent #3. Seems he's quite the leader as well, I'd never have guessed he'd get an A on his jersey.
Smid: Slow (okay, very slow), but effective. I hope we see him paired with Wotherspoon again this year. He showed some excellent chemistry with him.
Wideman: Every year, we have a whipping boy. For a while, it was Stajan, but he pulled himself out of it. I didn't expect Wideman to have that title removed. However, it seems he just might. Ever since he was a scratch, he's been exceptional.
Hiller/Ramo: Both have been great, but Hiller has been stellar. He may wind up being one of the better signings in the NHL this past summer.