What are some of the most bonehead moves made by teams at some point?

pbgoalie

Registered User
Aug 8, 2010
5,989
3,573
We REHIRED
Randy freaking Carlyle!!!!!!!!

And have now chosen a guy that if he repeats his past NHL experience
Could make us miss Carlyle!!
 

vadim sharifijanov

Registered User
Oct 10, 2007
28,844
16,334
scene: jim benning about to trade ryan kesler via the archetypal disgruntled all-star for young forward, young defenseman, draft pick package—

JB: i need a young forward

bob murray: we have some. who do you like? rickard rakell is 21, william karlsson is 22.

JB: nah, pass.

BM: too young? palmieri is 23, silfverberg is 24.

JB: i think i gotta have bonino [age 26].

BM: um, ok... what else do you need?

JB: a defenseman for the future.

BM: they’re not all available but we have fowler, lindholm, vatanen, shea theodore, josh manson, simon despres...

JB: nice try murray. luca sbisa or no deal.

BM: [sad that he’s forced to fork over his #10 overall pick in that year’s draft to make up the value on the roster players]

JB: and the 24th pick, sucker.

———

kesler: [finishes 3rd and 2nd in selke voting and averages 81 games, 21 goals, 52 points over the next three years—more than bonino, or brandon sutter, have ever scored or will ever score]

———

laurence gilman [assistant gm]: oh man this bonino guy is pretty good value. a second line center that can chip in 40 points and is decent in his own end on a cheap cap hit.

benning: let’s trade him for brandon sutter.

LG: but bonino scores more, bonino drives possession...

JB: [interrupts] i’ll throw in a second round pick to sweeten the deal.

LG: ...bonino can make plays, bonino is cheaper...

JB: [interrupts] and we’ll give sutter a five year $22 million contract extension before his current deal is even up.

———

bonino: [wins back to back cups]

———

gilman: luca sbisa is the worst defenseman in the league

benning: three year deal with a raise to $3.6 million a year. oh and gilman, you’re fired.

———

benning: [calls dale tallon] dale, i’m going to lose sbisa in the expansion draft. you gotta get me the worst defenseman in the league. erik gudbranson.

dale tallon: you still have that #24 pick that made the NHL at 18?

JB: jared mccann? sure. you need me to toss in a second round pick with that?

———

mccann: [scores more last season than sutter ever has in a canucks uniform]

fin
 
Last edited:

ricky0034

Registered User
Jun 8, 2010
15,053
7,274
scene: jim benning about to trade ryan kesler via the archetypal disgruntled all-star for young forward, young defenseman, draft pick package—

JB: i need a young forward

bob murray: we have some. who do you like? rickard rakell is 21, william karlsson is 22.

JB: nah, pass.

BM: too young? palmieri is 23, silfverberg is 24.

JB: i think i gotta have bonino [age 26].

BM: um, ok... what else do you need?

JB: a defenseman for the future.

BM: they’re not all available but we have fowler, lindholm, vatanen, shea theodore, josh manson, simon despres...

JB: nice try murray. luca sbisa or no deal.

BM: [sad that he’s forced to fork over his #10 overall pick in that year’s draft to make up the value on the roster players]

JB: and the 24th pick, sucker.

———

kesler: [finishes 3rd and 2nd in selke voting and averages 81 games, 21 goals, 52 points over the next three years—more than bonino, or brandon sutter, have ever scored or will ever score]

———

laurence gilman [assistant gm]: oh man this bonino guy is pretty good value. a second line center that can chip in 40 points and is decent in his own end on a cheap cap hit.

benning: let’s trade him for brandon sutter.

LG: but bonino scores more, bonino drives possession...

JB: [interrupts] i’ll throw in a second round pick to sweeten the deal.

LG: ...bonino can make plays, bonino is cheaper...

JB: [interrupts] and we’ll give sutter a five year $22 million contract extension before his current deal is even up.

———

bonino: [wins back to back cups]

———

gilman: luca sbisa is the worst defenseman in the league

benning: three year deal with a raise to $3.6 million a year. oh and gilman, you’re fired.

———

benning: [calls dale tallon] dale, i’m going to lose sbisa in the expansion draft. you gotta get me the worst defenseman in the league. erik gudbranson.

dale tallon: you still have that #24 pick that made the NHL at 18?

JB: jared mccann? sure. you need me to toss in a second round pick with that?

———

mccann: [scores more last season than sutter ever has in a canucks uniform]

fin

dunno if you've ever seen this but this post reminded me of it:

 
  • Like
Reactions: vadim sharifijanov

Terrier

Registered User
Sep 30, 2003
10,736
6,503
Newton, MA
Visit site
Sinden and Jacobs completely misreading what the post 05 lockout FA market would be and making sure they only carried a few contracts past 2004.

went from 104 points in 2003-04 to 74 points in 2005-06

players lost:

Nylander
Gonchar
Rolston
Knuble
Lapointe

players signed:

Zhamnov
Isbister
McEachern
Reasoner
Jurcina


On the Bruins board we had a thread about devastating losses(in the wake of Game 7), and the loss in Game 7 to the Habs in 2004, a game I attended, was crushing on and off the ice. The B's blew a 3-1 series lead, lost the finale at home, and it knocked the franchise for a loop. The Jumbo Joe era was winding down, and the B's were about to embark on their disastrous lockout strategy.

Rank the most painful losses you've experienced as a Bruins fan
 

Ad

Upcoming events

  • Toulouse vs Montpellier
    Toulouse vs Montpellier
    Wagers: 3
    Staked: $246.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Hoffenheim vs RB Leipzig
    Hoffenheim vs RB Leipzig
    Wagers: 4
    Staked: $8,351.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Torino vs Bologna
    Torino vs Bologna
    Wagers: 3
    Staked: $810.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Luton Town vs Everton
    Luton Town vs Everton
    Wagers: 4
    Staked: $1,010.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:
  • Getafe vs Athletic Bilbao
    Getafe vs Athletic Bilbao
    Wagers: 1
    Staked: $10.00
    Event closes
    • Updated:

Ad

Ad