Sorry I looked and was shocked to find nothing.
There are a lot of "greatest goalies" debate on this forum. But Tretiak's name never comes up and this has allways surprised me. Guy is a legend. Why no love?
To say that his name "never comes up" is an exaggeration. Anyway, the reasons for him not usually being in the top 3 or so:
- First and foremost, he didn't play in the NHL and most posters here are North American (i.e. the same problem as with a lot of other greats from Eastern Bloc)
- People often try to prove his greatness by referring to single great performances (1975 game vs. the Habs, 1981 Canada Cup final etc.), which is not quite enough
- His world championship record is not as impressive as it probably should be (he was named the best goalie 3 times... it's not bad but shouldn't it be more like 5-10 times or something?)
- In the 1970s, Tretiak wasn't always even considered to be the best goalie in Europe, it was quite often Jiri Holecek (though Tretiak more or less proved himself against the best Canadians, which Holecek never really did). Don't forget that USSR lost the world championship to Czechoslovakia three times in the 1970s (1972, 1976-77); that is obviously not all Tretiak's fault, though
On a personal note, I wouldn't put him above, say, Hasek and Roy either, but he belongs in the top 10 in my opinion. But from what I've seen (dozens of games from the 1970s and 1980s), the difference between his good day and his bad day was pretty huge. He is rarely referred to as 'inconsistent' anywhere, but that's what I personally think.
Some of his great performances (addition to those already mentioned above):
1976 vs. Boston Bruins (1975-76 Super Series)
1978 vs. Czechoslovakia (1978 World Championships - A VERY important game for USSR - beat Holecek in that one)
The whole 1981 Canada Cup tournament
The first 4 games in the 1972 Summit Series
Games 1 and 2 in the 1974 Summit series
And some of his bad ones (where he doesn't look like a legend at all):
1979 Challenge Cup, game 2 (faced 16 shots, let in 4 goals, just terrible)
1980 vs. Buffalo Sabres, the 1979-80 Super series (lets in numerous shots from bad angles, doesn't get much help from his team/defence, but it doesn't change the fact that he plays like crap)
The whole 1980 Olympic tournament was a bad one for him
3-8 loss vs. Czechoslovakia in the 1977 Izvestia tournament
2-7 loss vs. Czechoslovakia in the 1974 World Championships
But overall, I would think that "he didn't play in the NHL" is what prevents most North Americans (at least) to put him at the top of their lists.