Trade Value - current Jonas Brodin vs. Max Pacioretty in September

[Randy Randerson]

Brodin is not worth:

Tatar
Suzuki
2019 2nd

some other combination of Suzuki++ then, fair enough

 

[Cobra Commander]

some other combination of Suzuki++ then, fair enough

Suzuki+Shlemko+Benn

Warm bodies back the other way.

 

[Randy Randerson]

Suzuki+Shlemko+Benn

Warm bodies back the other way.

plus some picks, agree

 

[Cobra Commander]

plus some picks, agree

Suzuki + Vegas 2nd

That’s it that’s all, and most Habs fans will disagree.

 

[Randy Randerson]

No picks. We’re talking about a career 20 point D-man here..

nope, we're talking about a 20 ES pt Dman who can handle top pairing minutes and competition. Anyway, my whole point in this thread and the other was that it's ridiculous to think that Brodin wouldn't get a Suzuki level prospect (which I think was an assertion of another Habs homer, not you), so now that you agree he would definitely get that the rest is splitting hairs

 

[Cobra Commander]

nope, we're talking about a 20 ES pt Dman who can handle top pairing minutes and competition. Anyway, my whole point in this thread and the other was that it's ridiculous to think that Brodin wouldn't get a Suzuki level prospect (which I think was an assertion of another Habs homer, not you), so now that you agree he would definitely get that the rest is splitting hairs

I agree that he is solid defensively and can eat top minutes. That’s why I would be willing to trade for him.

 

[Randy Randerson]

I agree that he is solid defensively and can eat top minutes. That’s why I would be willing to trade for him.

ok.

 

[ole ole]

I guess this isn't going quite the way someone thought it would.

Patches.

 

[Randy Randerson]

I guess this isn't going quite the way someone thought it would.

Patches.

that's true, I'm surprised at the outcome being in Pacioretty's favour (though I think there was some confusion that value meant trade value), but the point I was making is that Brodin gets Suzuki+ and a split decision like this should reinforce that they're the same value tier of player, and being that Pacioretty got Suzuki with some valuable pluses there's a lot of margin for error on my side here

 

[Cobra Commander]

that's true, I'm surprised at the outcome being in Pacioretty's favour (though I think there was some confusion that value meant trade value), but the point I was making is that Brodin gets Suzuki+ and a split decision like this should reinforce that they're the same value tier of player, and being that Pacioretty got Suzuki with some valuable pluses there's a lot of margin for error on my side here

You’re good shit Sterling Malory Archer.