Proposal: Trade Proposal Thread XXV

[sandviper]

XXIV has hit 1,000+ posts. Rumours, nonsense proposals... what's on your mind?

Only recent "news" on the official media wires is of course, NHL Lottery superstar, Taylor Hall.



That said, given our current "cold" streak, maybe the whole team should pop some Halls.

Regardless of any moves we make, I am confident Lord Bergeron has this in good hands.

Click to read more...

 

[calder candidate]

We need to trade player like Tatar and Byron that 8.2M$ that isn’t helping us tanking or winning long term.

 

[Takeru]

We need to trade player like Tatar and Byron that 8.2M$ that isn’t helping us tanking or winning long term.

By all means, dont stop there.

Petry, at the very least, will likely not remain useful long enough that it would warrant keeping him. And is also sabotaging lottery odds.

 

[417]

How would you guys feel about moving Max Domi + ?? (Not sure what more would be required) in a trade for Taylor Hall?

 

[Adriatic]

How would you guys feel about moving Max Domi + ?? (Not sure what more would be required) in a trade for Taylor Hall?

Wouldn't it be better to add hall then to just swap one good player for another. I'd want to get Hall to add him to the core so he can play with the good players we have.

 

[Sterling Archer]

Wouldn't it be better to add hall then to just swap one good player for another. I'd want to get Hall to add him to the core so he can play with the good players we have.

Exactly. We need to ADD talent. Not swap for it.

 

[Runner77]

How would you guys feel about moving Max Domi + ?? (Not sure what more would be required) in a trade for Taylor Hall?

The question I’d be intrigued about is how much better than Hall could you fetch using Domi in a trade?

 

[Habs Halifax]

If you are listening Hall, you can be a Hero in Montreal and we have enough players to shelter the heat and pressure you would get. Price, Weber, Gallagher, Domi, Drouin. And I'm sure you know we got a few good young ones coming too. Think about the fun you would have playing with Suzuki and Caufield very soon?

We can pay you lots of money in July too! I know you wanna come

This is Hall thinking about his future in Montreal....

 

[Habssince89]

Hall and Domi should compliment one another real well, but what do we give up?

 

[blarneylad]

How would you guys feel about moving Max Domi + ?? (Not sure what more would be required) in a trade for Taylor Hall?

A signed 70 point player for a UFA to be ppg player that will make redick bank.

I wouldn't do it straight up.

 

[sampollock]

time to get it done, explain one thing here and now, you posters are very accurate,

how is team better then last year?

 

[blarneylad]

The question I’d be intrigued about is how much better than Hall could you fetch using Domi in a trade?

Yes, if you are thinking of moving Domi it should be for a signed young player. Not a UFA to be

 

[blarneylad]

time to get it done, explain one thing here and now, you posters are very accurate,

how is team better then last year?

It really isn't, youth are older and better ie Mete, Suzuki stepping in, Drouin

Chiarot is better than Benn. That is about it if you aren't counting the step back Byron took

 

[Pompeius Magnus]

I like Hall's game a lot and he's still young enough to be a part of the core for a while so he'd be a good add in my book. I'd want to add him to our top 6 without taking anything away from it though and it might just not be possible. Would NJ bite at a package built around Poehling ?

 

[calder candidate]

How would you guys feel about moving Max Domi + ?? (Not sure what more would be required) in a trade for Taylor Hall?

I don’t have any issue moving Domi but it can’t be for older player... Domi is in his prime, Hall is better but he is closer to approaching the end of is prime... Plus we have to sign him to a big $ deal, while Domi is still RFA.

 

[The Great Weal]

I think it would have to be something around Poehling/Primeau and Romanov and probably something else to get Hall with an extension.

 

[loudi94]

A deal for a signed Hall will be similar to the Stone or Karlsson deal. We will think that we gave up the farm to get him and the Devils plus other fan bases will think we fleeced the Devils.

 

[The Great Weal]

Let's not forget about his lottery winning ability.

Hall-Byfield-Caufield
Domi-KK-Drouin
Tatar-Suzuki-Gally

 

[Draft]

A deal for a signed Hall will be similar to the Stone or Karlsson deal. We will think that we gave up the farm to get him and the Devils plus other fan bases will think we fleeced the Devils.

Karlsson: Chris Tierney (Young 40pt player), Rudolfs Balcers (B-level prospect), Dylan DeMelo (Bottom pairing D), Josh Norris (1st rd pick) and conditional second (condition being they reach the SC Finals)

Stone: Erik Brannstrom (A-level prospect), Oscar Lindberg (Not even in the NHL anymore, bottom line player), and a second-round pick.

Duchene: Vitaly Abramov (B-level prospect), Jonathan Davidsson (C-level prospect), a first-round pick in the 2019 NHL Draft and a conditional first-round pick in the 2020 NHL Draft if resigned.

Pacioretty: Tatar (cap dump/middle-6 player), Suzuki (A-level prospect), 2nd round pick.

There really isn't much precedent for a lot of the types of trades being bandied about. There's little to no evidence that MTL will need to give up a core player or prospect to acquire Hall - extension or not. I don't see MTL moving any of Caufield, Primeau, Romanov, KK, or Suzuki... they're fulfilling major needs for the Habs moving forward.

 

[417]

Wouldn't it be better to add hall then to just swap one good player for another. I'd want to get Hall to add him to the core so he can play with the good players we have.

Yes but humor me...

 

[yianik]

It seems clear to me that Hall's frustration at not being on a contending team let alone a perennial play off team is sincerely important to him. We are not that. We are not a Destination for top players. I dont see him extending here.

 

[Vachon23]

The AGM and analytic guy of the Stars are again at the game.

 

[Runner77]

Yes, if you are thinking of moving Domi it should be for a signed young player. Not a UFA to be

Your post is so on point that I couldn't help posting this here:

 

[sampollock]

Roumeliotis reports that Bergevin was at Tuesday's Blackhawks and Dallas Stars game. He also adds that Bergevin has already watched several Rockford IceHogs games, the Blackhawks AHL affiliate.
Lyle Richardson of Spector's Hockey speculates the most likely target is left handed defenseman Erik Gustafsson.
The Hawks young defenseman was mentioned in lots of trade rumours this summer and will be UFA after this season. He's coming of a 60 point season.

 

[loudi94]

Roumeliotis reports that Bergevin was at Tuesday's Blackhawks and Dallas Stars game. He also adds that Bergevin has already watched several Rockford IceHogs games, the Blackhawks AHL affiliate.
Lyle Richardson of Spector's Hockey speculates the most likely target is left handed defenseman Erik Gustafsson.
The Hawks young defenseman was mentioned in lots of trade rumours this summer and will be UFA after this season. He's coming of a 60 point season.

I've never brought him up because I never thought he'd ever be available.