Proposal: Trade Proposal Thread Part 2

[NeptunesTrident]

Might as well have a new one since draft is just around the corner.

Click to read more...

 

[Sterling Archer]

I see this thread is a hot bed of activity. Over 200 views and this is the 1st post. Sweet!

 

[Makaveli XI]

Emelin and the 39th for Yakupov?

I have read on this forum that Desharnais has negative value, which I disagree with. Is anyone else with me? I can see him going to a team like Carolina or New Jersey for a draft pick or prospect.

 

[Habs 4 Life]

Emelin and the 39th for Yakupov?

I have read on this forum that Desharnais has negative value, which I disagree with. Is anyone else with me? I can see him going to a team like Carolina or New Jersey for a draft pick or prospect.

NO.

He does have negative value, no one wants him!

 

[Leon Lucius Black]

NO.

He does have negative value, no one wants him!

I want him gone more than anyone, but I wouldn't say he has negative value. He won't get much.. probably late pick or a mediocre prospect, but he doesn't have negative value given he only has one year left on his contract and he'll probably actually try harder this year since if he's garbage like last year he'll be playing in Europe the year after.

 

[vokiel]

Emelin and the 39th for Yakupov?

I have read on this forum that Desharnais has negative value, which I disagree with. Is anyone else with me? I can see him going to a team like Carolina or New Jersey for a draft pick or prospect.

Good luck with that.

 

[uiCk]

I want him gone more than anyone, but I wouldn't say he has negative value. He won't get much.. probably late pick or a mediocre prospect, but he doesn't have negative value given he only has one year left on his contract and he'll probably actually try harder this year since if he's garbage like last year he'll be playing in Europe the year after.

He def has negative value, we will have to retain salary (given the decent amount of trades in past couple of years that involved retaining salary), unless we pick up another bad contract in exchange.

 

[vokiel]

He def has negative value, we will have to retain salary (given the decent amount of trades in past couple of years that involved retaining salary), unless we pick up another bad contract in exchange.

Coach Therrien has him in the positive value column, sorry chaps.

 

[Makaveli XI]

Good luck with that.

I usually offer a lot more but then get roasted on here for offering too much

 

[vokiel]

I usually offer a lot more but then get roasted on here for offering too much

Just ask Edmonton fans when making Edmonton proposals, people around here generally have no clue what are the other team needs.

 

[BatVader]

I usually offer a lot more but then get roasted on here for offering too much

For Yak... Eller straight up, 1 for 1.
That's about equal value.

 

[vokiel]

For Yak... Eller straight up, 1 for 1.
That's about equal value.

Case in point. Value arguments are pointless when one side of the exchange is not needed by a team.

 

[BatVader]

Case in point. Value arguments are pointless when one side of the exchange is not needed by a team.

They don't need Eller, and as a 2RW, we can get, and need, better than Yak.
Post was just illustrating value.

 

[vokiel]

They don't need Eller, and as a 2RW, we can get, and need, better than Yak.
Post was just illustrating value.

One reason I prefer doing value of arguments using just pure picks is you can never get confused by if whoever is offered is done figuratively.

Edit: Plus the value of Eller is very arguable.

 

[Smokey Thompson]

Emelin and the 39th for Yakupov?

I have read on this forum that Desharnais has negative value, which I disagree with. Is anyone else with me? I can see him going to a team like Carolina or New Jersey for a draft pick or prospect.

Nope, you're alone on that one. He definitely has negative value.

 

[Makaveli XI]

Nope, you're alone on that one. He definitely has negative value.

None of us know for sure. Hopefully we will see this offseason.

 

[LaP]

Nope, you're alone on that one. He definitely has negative value.

Not so sure about that. He surely has no value but negative not so sure. Negative to teams wanting to win yeah but to the teams rebuilding his value might not be negative. It's the last year of his contract and he is a guy who don't really make any wave in a locker room. A team needing a contract to reach the cap floor next season after the UFA market might be interested to acquire him for a late rounds 2017 draft pick.

 

[Sterling Archer]

Plex and 9OA for Duchene.

Emelin, prospect (not names McCarron, Scherback, Juulson) for Nichushkin

Trade DD for anything

Sign Yandle for $5,500,000

Sign McGinn $3,500,000

Patches Duchene Gally
McGinn Chucky Nichushkin
Lehkonen Eller Ghetto/McCarron
Byron Danault Mitchell
Carr Flynn

Markov PK
Yandle Petry
Beau Pateryn
Barberio

Cap hit, $68,700,000. Lots of room to spare. Ideally, take Nichushkins cap and the space we have to sign Eriksson.

 

[Corky]

Subban

Subban for Trouba and 2OA

Fair for both teams?

Interesting for us?

 

[Scuba-Steve]

Subban for Trouba and 2OA

Fair for both teams?

Interesting for us?

I'd do it but I doubt the Jets would....

 

[groovejuice]

Subban for Trouba and 2OA

Fair for both teams?

Interesting for us?

I wouldn't do it. Trouba has been a disappointment since his rookie year, and the 2nd pick, while valuable, isn't near enough for PK.

 

[vokiel]

Subban for Trouba and 2OA

Fair for both teams?

Interesting for us?

No, trading our Norris dman is not interesting for us at all.

 

[Gyfu]

Idk... i think i'd go for it

 

[Richiebottles]

Trouba and Laine. Yes please.

 

[Koivu777]

Trading Subban is the last thing Bergevin should do.

I say first trade Desharnais and Eller to clear up $7M cap space. Then try to sign a couple guys like Ladd or someone in FA.