Trade Mark Stone for Tyler Seguin?

[acfurino]

Would really appreciate you guys weighing in on this potential trade... who is the better player in a keeper league and why? Thanks

20 team keeper league I’m in win now mode
G, A, P, PPP, Hits, GWG

Click to read more...

 

[Skinnyjimmy08]

I prefer Seguin. I dont like whats going on in Ottawa and i really dont know what type of points Stone will put up this season(especially if EK is dealt)...where as its pretty much a guarentee Seguin puts up 75ish or more.

I actually think this season Seguin will have a career year and put up better totals than his previous high of 84 points.

 

[BlackEye from Xhekaj]

I like Seguin here. Ottawa is a dumpster fire, and although Duchene/Stone will be playing a ton (Seguin/Stone both playing for new contracts).. Seguin had the supporting cast to keep him in the league's elite. Stone is more so in the league's very good.

 

[Isles72]

Seguin all day long ; Stone cant seem to stay healthy during fantasy league playoff crunch time and as the other poster mention theres probably anywhere from a 15 to 20 point gap between their point totals

 

[Brockon]

I'll also back the Seguin bandwagon, just because of the heavy talent pool around him on the top 6 in Dallas.

Benn - Seguin - xx
Or
Xx - Seguin - Radulov

Is a more favourable line combo to bet on for production over

Xx - Duchene - Stone
Or
Xx - Brown/White/JG Pageau - Stone

Ottawa just doesn't have the same caliber of supporting players around Stone in the top 6 unless you're willing to bank on multiple rookies seizing top 6 roles and excelling.

 

[Skinnyjimmy08]

Not to mention Stars just hired a deadly coach that will bring excitement back to the team. I am expecting high point totals from Stars big guns this season

 

[RonTextall]

Seguin 5
Stone 0

 

[rangerssharks414]

Seguin for sure unless it's a cap league. The Stars have one of the better lines in the league if they keep Benn/Seguin/Radulov together. Plus, they have Klingberg on the back end to help on the power play. Seguin should be a point per game guy at minimum, while I don't see Stone cracking 60 points on that terrible Ottawa team.

 

[TheSix34]

Stone is a great player but it’s Seguin for me, he’s on another level regardless if EK stays or anything else.

 

[67 others]

How is this even a question?
Seguin all day

 

[POVERTY]

Seguin AINEC

 

[Skinnyjimmy08]

It's unanimous!!

 

[Steveshutt]

Odd question. Seguin, obviously. Stay away from anything Ottawa is the advice I've given myself (along with Montreal).

 

[Leonhard Euler]

Even if Mark Stone didn't play for Sens this would be very clearly Seguin

 

[JayKnowsHockey]

If you gotta ask this auestion than id just keep Stone

Let someone else enjoy Seguin

 

[Connor McConnor]

Love Stone but unless your league counts takeaways, his injury risk and team situation around him makes it hard to compete with what Seguin brings on a consistent basis.