Proposal: Toronto - Columbus
- Thread starter SnizzNasty88
- Start date
- Status
We don’t need a new Marner to Columbus trade every forty five minutes. Don’t you have a trade masturbation thread on the Leafs board you can quarantine this sort of thing to?
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
No. The answer is already no. All that has to be seen is the pieces we're giving up and the answer is already set. Nobody will ever willingly pay or propose what it would take for the Jackets to give up both of those guys together.
- Jul 25, 2012
- 40,476
- 35,941
Seems pretty bad for columbus…
They do want to start competing soonish…. And don’t need the leafs no show bums on their roster
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Throw in a Fantilli-for-Robertson swap, obviously. That way they can have all of our franchise cornerstones, past, present, and future.
Ragdoll
Registered User
- Feb 15, 2018
- 1,202
- 1,625
The combination of Marner "disappearing in the playoffs" and wanting to get paid 11m+ on his next contract is so unappealing. I don't see any reason for Columbus to do this, they already have a small skilled playmaker in Gaudreau.
And you throw in Jenner who their management and fan base has stated is not being traded on multiple occasions. Trade makes less than zero sense for Columbus.
And you throw in Jenner who their management and fan base has stated is not being traded on multiple occasions. Trade makes less than zero sense for Columbus.
So when are your "franchise cornerstones" gonna bring cbj into a playoff spot?
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Not sure exactly but I'd guess it's before y'alls take the Leafs to a Conference final.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Hon, I'm actually pushing for the Leafs. But, y'know, ask a pointed question, get a pointed answer.
SnizzNasty88
Registered User
I expected some of the answers here. I get it. Marner is legit a total loser when it matters. However, don’t be surprised that if we move him in the off-season, the CBJ comes calling, especially because they’ve already offer sheeted Marner before.
They'd be calling, but Laine would be heading the other way.
So unless the Leafs value Laine, the discussion won't go anywhere.
SnizzNasty88
Registered User
Laine, Johnson, Fantilli, Gaudreau, Jenner, Marchencko, Chinahkov all need some sort of top 6 minutes or PP opportunity. They have Brindley and Dumais coming up. You think they're going to add another winger into that fold because...?
Their roster may be flawed, but adding Marner is not the solution. They aren't going to be spending 30 mil on 3 wingers, doesn't take a genius to see that. But that doesn't fit the 'let's help out the Leafs narrative' so lets all put on blinders to reality and team needs.
Cowumbus
Registered User
Leaf Fans
Registered User
- Sep 29, 2017
- 20,135
- 8,618
hamzarocks
Registered User
Both jacket players are overpaid and overrated. Werenski is super injury prone and cant be relied o
Marner sucks too in the playoffs
I think leafs just got to get a 1st + B+ prospect for rental marner
Dont add cap onto other teams failed core players. Stay away from CBJ organization. Too many guys havent devloped well and failed to play to expectations. We cant expect them to play better in a more intense market in toronto
Use the cap space in 2026 once Tavares is also expiring to add guys who your confident can compliment Matthews + Nylander + Rielly
Marner sucks too in the playoffs
I think leafs just got to get a 1st + B+ prospect for rental marner
Dont add cap onto other teams failed core players. Stay away from CBJ organization. Too many guys havent devloped well and failed to play to expectations. We cant expect them to play better in a more intense market in toronto
Use the cap space in 2026 once Tavares is also expiring to add guys who your confident can compliment Matthews + Nylander + Rielly
Cowumbus
Registered User
how much do you think Jenner makes?
I’ll give you a hint, it’s about 2 million less than Bertuzzi.
You can't be relied on to research (or to finish your sentence).
Werenski did indeed miss more time this year and he nonetheless nearly led the league in 5v5 scoring by a D-man. Great year by him.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
That was under Kekalainen, and we've subsequently brought in Gaudreau in free agency.
Viqsi
"that chick from Ohio"
Hon, Jenner is the best value non-ELC contract on the Blue Jackets, and is arguably a strong contender for best value non-ELC contract in the league. This stuff is not hard to look up at all. Try it sometime before spouting off.
hamzarocks
Registered User
Last 5 years:
2020: Werenski missed 7 out of 70 games
2021: Werenski missed 21 out of 56 games
2022: Werenski missed 14 out of 82 games
2023: Werenski missed 69 out of 82 games
2024: Weresnki missed 12 out of 82 games
He has been injured 123 of a possible 372 games last 5 years (33%)
Jenner has also missed 15, 23, 14, and 24 games the last 4 years due to injuries
Both have been super injury prone
Werenski makes 9.5M. Having one great year in the last 5 doesnt make up for his unreliable production and he is not worth the money he makes
Your right I was wrong on Jenner his deal is only 3.75M
Hon, Jenner is the best value non-ELC contract on the Blue Jackets, and is arguably a strong contender for best value non-ELC contract in the league. This stuff is not hard to look up at all. Try it sometime before spouting off.
Thought he was making 5M+ for some reason.
He is worth his deal for sure
Still he is also quite injury prone and a risk to decline like Foligno did for the leafs.
Not a guy leafs should be targetting in a marner trade
Last edited:
- Status
