Proposal: TOR-WPG-CAR

[typicalsavage]

To Carolina

Ehlers
Brown

To Toronto

Pesce

To Winnipeg

Kadri
Fleury

Click to read more...

 

[Troy]

Winnipeg is not on Kadris no trade list, this trade obviously favours the leafs of course. Jets give up Ehlers, Canes give up Pesce and Fleury. While the only significant piece Leafs give up is Kadri, which would never fetch a top 3 defenseman like Pesce

 

[MinJaBen]

No thanks from the Canes. We are giving up two of our defensemen...who both play on our left side and after trading away another LHD in de Haan...for Ehlers who is nice and Brown who we don't need at all.

Easy pass.

 

[Big Daddy Cane]

Slavin - Hamilton
Bean - Faulk
Forsling - van Riemsdyk

That's not good enough.

Pesce to Toronto was in the grave already. The de Haan trade buried it. Carolina can no longer afford to trade him. It's time to let go of that idea.

 

[Guffman]

Why bring the Leafs into this to pollute the trade?

Ehlers for Pesce is the basis for a potential trade but this was discussed with Canes fans already for a bit.

 

[Snowman]

The only team that says yes is Toronto.

 

[typicalsavage]

Winnipeg is not on Kadris no trade list, this trade obviously favours the leafs of course. Jets give up Ehlers, Canes give up Pesce and Fleury. While the only significant piece Leafs give up is Kadri, which would never fetch a top 3 defenseman like Pesce

A 60 point C being paid $4.5M isnt worth Pesce? Trouba just went for a low 1st and a crappy dman
And hes a lot better than Pesce. Look at what Miller got. Im pretty sure Winnipeg is wishing they got Kadri for Pesce right now.

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

A 60 point C being paid $4.5M isnt worth Pesce? Trouba just went for a low 1st and a crappy dman
And hes a lot better than Pesce. Look at what Miller got. Im pretty sure Winnipeg is wishing they got Kadri for Pesce right now.

How do people seriously try to use the return for Trouba as a basis for a potential return on Pesce?

 

[MisterT]

Winnipeg needs to add. With his cap hit vs production, Ehlers doesn’t bring that return.

 

[Guffman]

A 60 point C being paid $4.5M isnt worth Pesce? Trouba just went for a low 1st and a crappy dman
And hes a lot better than Pesce. Look at what Miller got. Im pretty sure Winnipeg is wishing they got Kadri for Pesce right now.

Wait, you’re comparing the return for Trouba, who was one year away from UFA in a distressed situation to someone with a good value, 5 year contract?

WHAT?!

LMAO

 

[DougGilmour93]

Nylander + Holl + Sparks

For

Kuokkanan + Pesce + Mckeown

 

[JetsHomer]

A 60 point C being paid $4.5M isnt worth Pesce? Trouba just went for a low 1st and a crappy dman
And hes a lot better than Pesce. Look at what Miller got. Im pretty sure Winnipeg is wishing they got Kadri for Pesce right now.

Kadri has broken 60 points once in his 9 season career. 3 years ago

 

[spockBokk]

Nylander + Holl + Sparks

For

Kuokkanan + Pesce + Mckeown

Nope, no team is going to trade away all their RD depth for Nylander.

 

[MinJaBen]

Nylander + Holl + Sparks

For

Kuokkanan + Pesce + Mckeown

Like Nylander. Don't need Holl. Don't need Sparks. Not trading Pesce plus Kuollanan plus McKeown all for just Nylander. Personally, I wouldn't do Pesce straight up for Nylander without the leafs adding, but I could see our organization doing that, so I won't say never on that.

 

[typicalsavage]

Kadri has broken 60 points once in his 9 season career. 3 years ago

Fine 55 point center. Happy?

 

[typicalsavage]

How do people seriously try to use the return for Trouba as a basis for a potential return on Pesce?

I know the situation is totally different but still, Kadri is most definitely worth Pesce. Everyone acts like Pesce is some prime piece but truth is hes a good #3 dman that can compliment a star offensive dman like Rielly. Hes not worth a star talent.

 

[BatVader]

To Carolina

Ehlers
Brown

To Toronto

Pesce

To Winnipeg

Kadri
Fleury

What crap is this?
Jets would just trade directly with Carolina and get Pesce for Ehlers.
WTF do we need Toronto included in this for?
Zero interest in Kadri.

 

[Ahoy there]

I know the situation is totally different but still, Kadri is most definitely worth Pesce. Everyone acts like Pesce is some prime piece but truth is hes a good #3 dman that can compliment a star offensive dman like Rielly. Hes not worth a star talent.

Cool. We'll gladly keep our non-prime piece. If you've failed to notice, no Canes' fan has ever proposed a trade including Pesce.

 

[Cane mutiny]

Please stop with the constant Pesce envy. He's not going anywhere anytime soon.

 

[Jeti]

If Carolina was willing to move Pesce for Ehlers+, the Jets can do this deal without Toronto. This is just wishful thinking from a Leafs fan

 

[Roboturner913]

Leafs trade proposals with Pesce are like some creepy dude at a bar hitting on a girl who keeps turning him down and then he gets mad and yells "Fine! You're not that pretty anyway!" only to come back 10 minutes later apologizing and asking for another chance.

Please move on and find another girl to annoy

 

[typicalsavage]

If Carolina was willing to move Pesce for Ehlers+, the Jets can do this deal without Toronto. This is just wishful thinking from a Leafs fan

I mean I thought the Jets would want a center like Kadri rather than spending a 1st every trade deadline on a rental. But idk my bad

 

[snowkiddin]

Horrific for the Jets.

 

[Jeti]

I mean I thought the Jets would want a center like Kadri rather than spending a 1st every trade deadline on a rental. But idk my bad

Kadri isn't worth as much as Ehlers or Pesce and the Jets need a young top 4 D more than they need to make Little redundant.

 

[Whileee]

Fine 55 point center. Happy?

He's hit 55 points twice in 9 seasons. Try again?

How about a hot-headed, undisciplined C that has had less overall impact in the last 4 seasons than Andrew Copp (based on Goals Above Replacement)?

If you want other comparisons, over the past 4 seasons:

5v5 points/60:

Kadri 1.65
Copp 1.48

And then you have the fact that Copp has been much better defensively over the past 3 seasons (see below):