Top Playoff Goaltending, 1968-2017 (Error Rate Analysis)

[quoipourquoi]

I have compiled an error rate vs. expectation report for every individual playoff run from a goaltender who played in 3 or 4 rounds in the post-1967 expansion NHL. Error rate vs. expectation measures a goaltender's error rate in a playoff round (GA/SA) against an opponent's regular season shooting percentage to determine how much a goaltender allows relative to what the opponent would be expected to score. Rounds are then weighted based upon shots allowed for a cumulative statistic (EvE) that reads as a percentage, with 100% being what a league average goaltender would be expected to allow.

The ultimate goal is to present a rough ranking for separate categories:

Three-Round Goaltenders
This category is primarily Finalists from 1968-1979, as well as Conference Finalists from 1980-2017. These goaltenders played no other playoff hockey, and their generally smaller sample size may allow for greater fluctuation of their error rate vs. expectation, either positively or negatively. Not represented in this report are goaltenders from the 1976 Philadelphia Flyers, the 1981 Calgary Flames, or the 1987 Montreal Canadiens, as the primary goaltenders on these Conference Finalists did not play in 3 playoff rounds. Included, however, are goaltenders who played in the 1975-1979 preliminary round while making it to the Semifinals.

Player | Year | R1 SV | R1 SA | R1 SV% | R1 OPP | R1 EvE | R2 SV | R2 SA | R2 SV% | R2 OPP | R2 EvE | R3 SV | R3 SA | R3 SV% | R3 OPP | R3 EvE | SA | EvE
Gump Worsley | 1968 | 98 | 106 | .925 | .105 | 71.9% | 97 | 103 | .942 | .099 | 58.8% | 84 | 91 | .923 | .080 | 96.15% | 300 | 74.8%
Glenn Hall | 1968 | 182 | 196 | .929 | .092 | 77.6% | 168 | 188 | .894 | .090 | 118.2% | 140 | 151 | .927 | .102 | 71.42% | 535 | 90.1%
Rogie Vachon | 1969 | 22 | 25 | .880 | .081 | 148.2% | 119 | 125 | .952 | .117 | 41.0% | 104 | 107 | .972 | .094 | 29.83% | 257 | 46.8%
Jacques Plante | 1969 | 105 | 108 | .972 | .080 | 34.7% | 103 | 108 | .954 | .076 | 60.9% | 56 | 62 | .903 | .099 | 97.75% | 278 | 59.0%
Gerry Cheevers | 1970 | 165 | 177 | .932 | .090 | 75.3% | 99 | 109 | .908 | .102 | 89.9% | 93 | 100 | .930 | .090 | 77.78% | 386 | 80.1%
Glenn Hall | 1970 | 81 | 90 | .900 | .096 | 104.2% | 54 | 58 | .931 | .076 | 90.7% | 70 | 78 | .897 | .096 | 106.84% | 226 | 101.6%
Tony Esposito | 1971 | 124 | 132 | .939 | .085 | 71.3% | 228 | 242 | .942 | .093 | 62.2% | 188 | 208 | .904 | .114 | 84.35% | 582 | 72.2%
Ken Dryden | 1971 | 260 | 285 | .912 | .126 | 69.6% | 178 | 196 | .908 | .079 | 116.3% | 210 | 228 | .921 | .115 | 68.65% | 709 | 82.2%
Ed Giacomin | 1972 | 149 | 163 | .914 | .117 | 73.4% | 25 | 27 | .926 | .112 | 66.1% | 75 | 86 | .872 | .126 | 101.51% | 276 | 81.5%
Gerry Cheevers | 1972 | 71 | 77 | .922 | .083 | 93.9% | 64 | 69 | .928 | .081 | 89.5% | 91 | 101 | .901 | .113 | 87.62% | 247 | 90.1%
Ken Dryden | 1973 | 211 | 227 | .930 | .103 | 68.4% | 141 | 154 | .916 | .113 | 74.7% | 138 | 159 | .868 | .122 | 108.26% | 540 | 82.0%
Tony Esposito | 1973 | 97 | 101 | .960 | .088 | 45.0% | 152 | 162 | .938 | .110 | 56.1% | 157 | 189 | .831 | .132 | 128.27% | 452 | 83.8%
Bernie Parent | 1974 | 101 | 107 | .944 | .090 | 62.3% | 208 | 224 | .929 | .118 | 60.5% | 180 | 193 | .933 | .132 | 51.03% | 524 | 57.4%
Gilles Gilbert | 1974 | 146 | 155 | .942 | .101 | 57.5% | 145 | 164 | .884 | .127 | 91.2% | 154 | 169 | .911 | .103 | 86.17% | 488 | 78.8%
Glenn Resch | 1975 | 37 | 45 | .822 | .118 | 150.7% | 124 | 128 | .969 | .118 | 26.5% | 175 | 188 | .931 | .109 | 63.44% | 361 | 61.2%
Bernie Parent | 1975 | 92 | 98 | .939 | .102 | 60.0% | 96 | 108 | .889 | .112 | 99.2% | 164 | 175 | .937 | .120 | 52.38% | 381 | 67.6%
Gerry Desjardins | 1975 | 96 | 106 | .906 | .108 | 87.4% | 88 | 106 | .830 | .146 | 116.3% | 87 | 102 | .853 | .109 | 134.92% | 314 | 112.6%
Ken Dryden | 1976 | 107 | 110 | .973 | .108 | 25.3% | 135 | 148 | .912 | .122 | 72.0% | 83 | 92 | .902 | .116 | 84.33% | 350 | 60.6%
Glenn Resch | 1976 | 58 | 62 | .935 | .114 | 56.6% | 18 | 22 | .818 | .125 | 145.5% | 100 | 110 | .909 | .123 | 73.91% | 194 | 76.5%
Ken Dryden | 1977 | 101 | 105 | .962 | .100 | 38.1% | 114 | 126 | .905 | .122 | 78.1% | 87 | 93 | .935 | .130 | 49.63% | 324 | 57.0%
Billy Smith | 1977 | 32 | 35 | .914 | .106 | 80.9% | 132 | 142 | .930 | .119 | 59.2% | 117 | 131 | .893 | .137 | 78.01% | 308 | 69.7%
Gerry Cheevers | 1977 | 96 | 116 | .828 | .111 | 155.3% | 113 | 121 | .934 | .128 | 51.7% | 74 | 90 | .822 | .137 | 129.76% | 327 | 109.9%
Mike Palmateer | 1978 | 44 | 47 | .936 | .097 | 65.8% | 205 | 218 | .940 | .134 | 44.5% | 114 | 130 | .877 | .137 | 89.84% | 395 | 62.0%
Ken Dryden | 1978 | 112 | 122 | .918 | .111 | 73.8% | 79 | 85 | .929 | .114 | 61.9% | 141 | 154 | .916 | .137 | 61.62% | 361 | 65.8%
Bernie Parent | 1978 | 32 | 35 | .914 | .107 | 80.1% | 130 | 141 | .922 | .116 | 67.3% | 111 | 130 | .854 | .137 | 106.68% | 306 | 85.5%
Gerry Cheevers | 1978 | 38 | 43 | .884 | .098 | 118.7% | 90 | 102 | .882 | .112 | 105.0% | 139 | 157 | .885 | .137 | 83.69% | 302 | 95.9%
Ken Dryden | 1979 | 120 | 130 | .923 | .109 | 70.6% | 162 | 182 | .890 | .141 | 77.9% | 83 | 94 | .883 | .128 | 91.42% | 406 | 78.7%
Bob Sauve | 1980 | 45 | 46 | .978 | .110 | 19.8% | 63 | 69 | .913 | .100 | 87.0% | 106 | 116 | .914 | .127 | 67.88% | 231 | 64.0%
Gilles Meloche | 1980 | 12 | 13 | .923 | .117 | 65.8% | 205 | 226 | .907 | .130 | 71.5% | 44 | 56 | .786 | .121 | 177.10% | 295 | 91.3%
Steve Baker | 1981 | 103 | 114 | .904 | .151 | 63.9% | 132 | 154 | .857 | .145 | 98.5% | 91 | 113 | .805 | .147 | 132.44% | 381 | 98.2%
Dan Bouchard | 1982 | 146 | 162 | .901 | .133 | 74.3% | 62 | 67 | .925 | .134 | 55.7% | 113 | 130 | .869 | .156 | 83.83% | 359 | 74.3%
Murray Bannerman | 1982 | 99 | 111 | .892 | .131 | 82.5% | 109 | 124 | .879 | .128 | 94.5% | 64 | 72 | .889 | .118 | 94.16% | 307 | 90.1%
Pete Peeters | 1983 | 98 | 106 | .925 | .148 | 51.0% | 174 | 197 | .883 | .132 | 88.5% | 148 | 178 | .831 | .124 | 135.92% | 481 | 97.8%
Murray Bannerman | 1983 | 82 | 89 | .921 | .114 | 69.0% | 82 | 93 | .882 | .125 | 94.6% | 42 | 56 | .750 | .159 | 157.23% | 238 | 99.8%
Steve Penney | 1984 | 74 | 76 | .974 | .140 | 18.8% | 143 | 156 | .917 | .157 | 53.1% | 106 | 123 | .862 | .147 | 94.02% | 355 | 59.9%
Don Beaupre | 1984 | 66 | 72 | .917 | .113 | 73.8% | 201 | 218 | .922 | .121 | 64.5% | 73 | 90 | .811 | .171 | 110.46% | 380 | 77.1%
Mario Gosselin | 1985 | 90 | 104 | .865 | .126 | 106.8% | 162 | 185 | .876 | .128 | 97.1% | 165 | 182 | .907 | .132 | 70.76% | 471 | 89.1%
Murray Bannerman | 1985 | 85 | 91 | .934 | .138 | 47.8% | 214 | 242 | .884 | .107 | 108.1% | 173 | 211 | .820 | .155 | 116.19% | 544 | 101.2%
Greg Millen | 1986 | 65 | 71 | .915 | .127 | 66.5% | 190 | 205 | .927 | .124 | 59.0% | 43 | 51 | .843 | .128 | 122.55% | 327 | 70.6%
John Vanbiesbrouck | 1986 | 150 | 163 | .920 | .123 | 64.8% | 148 | 170 | .871 | .130 | 99.6% | 130 | 144 | .903 | .140 | 69.44% | 477 | 78.6%
Greg Stefan | 1987 | 79 | 82 | .963 | .113 | 32.4% | 27 | 38 | .711 | .119 | 243.3% | 119 | 129 | .922 | .158 | 49.06% | 249 | 73.2%
Sean Burke | 1988 | 148 | 164 | .902 | .127 | 76.8% | 154 | 174 | .885 | .114 | 100.8% | 155 | 176 | .881 | .116 | 102.86% | 514 | 93.9%
Greg Stefan | 1988 | 65 | 73 | .890 | .113 | 97.0% | 76 | 89 | .854 | .122 | 119.7% | 62 | 73 | .849 | .155 | 97.22% | 235 | 105.7%
Alain Chevrier | 1989 | 157 | 175 | .897 | .136 | 75.6% | 140 | 152 | .921 | .118 | 66.9% | 142 | 156 | .910 | .128 | 70.11% | 483 | 71.1%
Ron Hextall | 1989 | 182 | 201 | .905 | .122 | 77.5% | 136 | 158 | .861 | .152 | 91.6% | 78 | 86 | .907 | .128 | 72.67% | 445 | 81.6%
Greg Millen | 1990 | 130 | 144 | .903 | .110 | 88.4% | 56 | 68 | .824 | .126 | 140.1% | 74 | 88 | .841 | .140 | 113.64% | 300 | 107.5%
Mike Liut | 1990 | 44 | 53 | .830 | .120 | 141.5% | 106 | 118 | .898 | .117 | 86.9% | 44 | 51 | .863 | .111 | 123.65% | 222 | 108.4%
Grant Fuhr | 1991 | 191 | 210 | .910 | .132 | 68.5% | 142 | 158 | .899 | .141 | 71.8% | 104 | 120 | .867 | .100 | 133.33% | 488 | 85.5%
Andy Moog | 1991 | 151 | 168 | .899 | .103 | 98.2% | 203 | 220 | .923 | .114 | 67.8% | 155 | 181 | .856 | .142 | 101.16% | 569 | 87.4%
Bill Ranford | 1992 | 166 | 182 | .912 | .119 | 73.9% | 157 | 171 | .918 | .107 | 76.5% | 110 | 131 | .840 | .097 | 165.26% | 484 | 99.5%
Andy Moog | 1992 | 157 | 177 | .887 | .111 | 101.8% | 94 | 102 | .922 | .109 | 72.0% | 88 | 106 | .830 | .135 | 125.79% | 385 | 100.5%
Felix Potvin | 1993 | 183 | 212 | .863 | .133 | 102.9% | 202 | 213 | .948 | .116 | 44.5% | 189 | 211 | .896 | .118 | 88.36% | 636 | 78.5%
Glenn Healy | 1993 | 155 | 174 | .891 | .120 | 91.0% | 183 | 208 | .880 | .135 | 89.0% | 127 | 142 | .894 | .122 | 86.59% | 524 | 89.0%
Martin Brodeur | 1994 | 181 | 194 | .933 | .119 | 56.3% | 70 | 78 | .897 | .097 | 105.7% | 242 | 259 | .934 | .104 | 63.11% | 531 | 66.9%
Felix Potvin | 1994 | 156 | 166 | .940 | .100 | 60.2% | 166 | 187 | .888 | .120 | 93.6% | 152 | 167 | .910 | .106 | 84.74% | 520 | 80.1%
Ed Belfour | 1995 | 175 | 193 | .907 | .089 | 104.8% | 97 | 103 | .942 | .095 | 61.3% | 170 | 183 | .929 | .115 | 61.77% | 479 | 79.0%
Ron Hextall | 1995 | 134 | 146 | .918 | .102 | 80.6% | 109 | 119 | .916 | .091 | 92.3% | 152 | 172 | .884 | .094 | 123.70% | 437 | 100.8%
Ken Wregget | 1996 | 127 | 131 | .969 | .095 | 32.1% | 158 | 172 | .919 | .102 | 79.8% | 20 | 25 | .800 | .107 | 186.92% | 328 | 68.9%
Chris Osgood | 1996 | 45 | 48 | .938 | .114 | 54.8% | 128 | 139 | .921 | .086 | 92.0% | 116 | 135 | .859 | .123 | 114.42% | 322 | 95.9%
Mike Richter | 1997 | 151 | 161 | .938 | .093 | 66.8% | 178 | 182 | .978 | .089 | 24.7% | 126 | 145 | .869 | .104 | 125.99% | 488 | 68.7%
Patrick Roy | 1997 | 170 | 183 | .929 | .090 | 78.9% | 164 | 175 | .937 | .100 | 62.9% | 187 | 201 | .930 | .093 | 74.89% | 559 | 72.5%
Dominik Hasek | 1998 | 167 | 176 | .949 | .103 | 49.7% | 148 | 158 | .937 | .103 | 61.5% | 167 | 180 | .928 | .098 | 73.70% | 514 | 61.7%
Ed Belfour | 1998 | 119 | 131 | .908 | .097 | 94.4% | 119 | 123 | .967 | .091 | 35.7% | 130 | 145 | .897 | .099 | 104.49% | 399 | 80.0%
Patrick Roy | 1999 | 169 | 184 | .918 | .091 | 89.6% | 210 | 224 | .938 | .093 | 67.2% | 219 | 242 | .905 | .104 | 91.39% | 650 | 82.5%
Curtis Joseph | 1999 | 180 | 189 | .952 | .094 | 50.7% | 111 | 124 | .895 | .116 | 90.4% | 108 | 127 | .850 | .096 | 155.84% | 440 | 92.2%
Patrick Roy | 2000 | 107 | 117 | .915 | .105 | 81.4% | 137 | 144 | .951 | .106 | 45.9% | 156 | 170 | .918 | .101 | 81.54% | 431 | 69.6%
Brian Boucher | 2000 | 116 | 124 | .935 | .096 | 67.2% | 161 | 175 | .920 | .113 | 70.8% | 167 | 185 | .903 | .092 | 105.76% | 484 | 83.2%
Roman Turek | 2001 | 150 | 161 | .932 | .096 | 71.2% | 106 | 112 | .946 | .115 | 46.6% | 95 | 109 | .872 | .113 | 113.66% | 382 | 76.1%
Johan Hedberg | 2001 | 151 | 161 | .938 | .099 | 62.7% | 166 | 182 | .912 | .099 | 88.8% | 122 | 139 | .878 | .114 | 107.28% | 482 | 85.4%
Curtis Joseph | 2002 | 172 | 193 | .891 | .103 | 105.6% | 188 | 205 | .917 | .098 | 84.6% | 149 | 159 | .937 | .092 | 68.36% | 557 | 87.3%
Patrick Roy | 2002 | 163 | 176 | .926 | .101 | 73.1% | 169 | 187 | .904 | .111 | 86.7% | 188 | 209 | .900 | .099 | 101.49% | 572 | 87.9%
Patrick Lalime | 2003 | 129 | 136 | .949 | .092 | 56.0% | 124 | 134 | .925 | .083 | 89.9% | 162 | 179 | .905 | .083 | 114.42% | 449 | 89.4%
Dwayne Roloson | 2003 | 81 | 91 | .890 | .105 | 104.7% | 118 | 128 | .922 | .111 | 70.4% | 33 | 38 | .868 | .090 | 146.20% | 257 | 93.7%
Evgeni Nabokov | 2004 | 119 | 127 | .937 | .086 | 73.3% | 158 | 165 | .958 | .098 | 43.3% | 154 | 169 | .911 | .089 | 99.73% | 461 | 72.2%
Robert Esche | 2004 | 146 | 155 | .942 | .088 | 66.0% | 136 | 148 | .919 | .107 | 75.8% | 175 | 195 | .897 | .100 | 102.56% | 498 | 83.2%
Ilya Bryzgalov | 2006 | 90 | 93 | .968 | .094 | 34.3% | 117 | 121 | .967 | .114 | 29.0% | 62 | 71 | .873 | .102 | 124.28% | 285 | 54.5%
Ryan Miller | 2006 | 146 | 159 | .918 | .103 | 79.4% | 156 | 169 | .923 | .111 | 69.3% | 172 | 194 | .887 | .112 | 101.25% | 522 | 84.3%
Dominik Hasek | 2007 | 119 | 129 | .922 | .114 | 68.0% | 135 | 144 | .938 | .109 | 57.3% | 156 | 171 | .912 | .098 | 89.51% | 444 | 72.8%
Ryan Miller | 2007 | 123 | 134 | .918 | .098 | 83.8% | 187 | 200 | .935 | .090 | 72.2% | 141 | 155 | .910 | .108 | 83.63% | 489 | 79.0%
Marty Turco | 2008 | 125 | 137 | .912 | .088 | 99.5% | 175 | 186 | .941 | .089 | 66.5% | 171 | 188 | .910 | .089 | 101.60% | 511 | 88.3%
Martin Biron | 2008 | 198 | 218 | .908 | .094 | 97.6% | 163 | 177 | .921 | .108 | 73.2% | 127 | 145 | .876 | .106 | 117.11% | 540 | 94.9%
Cam Ward | 2009 | 227 | 242 | .938 | .088 | 70.4% | 182 | 199 | .915 | .109 | 78.4% | 118 | 135 | .874 | .108 | 116.60% | 576 | 84.0%
Nikolai Khabibulin | 2009 | 160 | 175 | .914 | .095 | 90.2% | 124 | 142 | .873 | .104 | 121.9% | 94 | 104 | .904 | .097 | 99.13% | 421 | 103.1%
Jaroslav Halak | 2010 | 217 | 231 | .939 | .116 | 52.3% | 203 | 219 | .927 | .093 | 78.6% | 99 | 112 | .884 | .090 | 128.97% | 562 | 77.8%
Evgeni Nabokov | 2010 | 138 | 149 | .926 | .104 | 71.0% | 117 | 132 | .886 | .081 | 140.3% | 114 | 126 | .905 | .094 | 101.32% | 407 | 102.9%
Dwayne Roloson | 2011 | 243 | 256 | .949 | .088 | 57.7% | 123 | 133 | .925 | .085 | 88.5% | 134 | 152 | .882 | .091 | 130.13% | 541 | 85.6%
Antti Niemi | 2011 | 120 | 139 | .863 | .088 | 155.3% | 229 | 246 | .931 | .093 | 74.3% | 133 | 153 | .869 | .098 | 133.39% | 538 | 112.0%
Mike Smith | 2012 | 229 | 241 | .950 | .093 | 53.5% | 150 | 159 | .943 | .103 | 55.0% | 189 | 202 | .936 | .075 | 85.81% | 602 | 64.7%
Henrik Lundqvist | 2012 | 205 | 217 | .945 | .094 | 58.8% | 166 | 179 | .927 | .095 | 76.5% | 145 | 158 | .918 | .096 | 85.71% | 554 | 72.2%
Jonathan Quick | 2013 | 167 | 177 | .944 | .093 | 60.8% | 195 | 205 | .951 | .076 | 64.2% | 122 | 136 | .897 | .100 | 102.94% | 518 | 73.2%
Tomas Vokoun | 2013 | 66 | 69 | .957 | .091 | 47.8% | 159 | 170 | .935 | .070 | 92.4% | 97 | 106 | .915 | .082 | 103.54% | 345 | 86.9%
Carey Price | 2014 | 94 | 104 | .904 | .095 | 101.2% | 219 | 234 | .936 | .099 | 64.8% | 16 | 20 | .800 | .079 | 253.16% | 358 | 85.9%
Corey Crawford | 2014 | 201 | 215 | .935 | .100 | 65.1% | 150 | 162 | .926 | .091 | 81.4% | 187 | 213 | .878 | .076 | 160.61% | 590 | 104.1%
Henrik Lundqvist | 2015 | 124 | 132 | .939 | .084 | 72.2% | 211 | 223 | .946 | .098 | 54.9% | 194 | 215 | .902 | .107 | 91.28% | 570 | 72.6%
Frederik Andersen | 2015 | 109 | 118 | .924 | .091 | 83.8% | 112 | 121 | .926 | .105 | 70.8% | 210 | 233 | .901 | .079 | 124.95% | 472 | 100.8%
Ben Bishop | 2016 | 152 | 160 | .950 | .086 | 58.1% | 118 | 128 | .922 | .094 | 83.1% | 9 | 9 | 1.000 | .089 | 0.00% | 297 | 67.1%
Brian Elliott | 2016 | 236 | 254 | .929 | .094 | 75.4% | 183 | 197 | .929 | .101 | 70.4% | 84 | 95 | .884 | .095 | 121.88% | 546 | 81.7%
Craig Anderson | 2017 | 152 | 165 | .921 | .085 | 92.7% | 186 | 205 | .907 | .104 | 89.1% | 206 | 220 | .936 | .101 | 63.01% | 590 | 80.4%
John Gibson | 2017 | 113 | 122 | .926 | .093 | 79.3% | 162 | 181 | .895 | .095 | 110.5% | 153 | 163 | .939 | .093 | 65.97% | 466 | 86.8%

Four-Round Goaltenders
This category is primarily Finalists from 1980-2017. These goaltenders played in every round, and their generally greater sample size may result in less extremes in their error rate vs. expectation, either positively or negatively. Also included in this category is John Davidson from the 1979 New York Rangers, the only goaltender to play in the 1975-1979 preliminary round and make it to the Stanley Cup Finals.

Player | Year | R1 SV | R1 SA | R1 SV% | R1 OPP | R1 EvE | R2 SV | R2 SA | R2 SV% | R2 OPP | R2 EvE | R3 SV | R3 SA | R3 SV% | R3 OPP | R3 EvE | R4 SV | R4 SA | R4 SV% | R4 OPP | R4 EvE | SA | EvE
John Davidson | 1979 | 66 | 68 | .971 | .121 | 24.3% | 146 | 154 | .948 | .111 | 46.8% | 139 | 152 | .914 | .156 | 54.8% | 142 | 161 | .882 | .131 | 90.1% | 535 | 59.2%
Billy Smith | 1980 | 69 | 73 | .945 | .125 | 43.8% | 140 | 154 | .909 | .139 | 65.4% | 136 | 149 | .913 | .136 | 64.2% | 160 | 183 | .874 | .121 | 103.9% | 559 | 74.8%
Pete Peeters | 1980 | 37 | 41 | .902 | .133 | 73.4% | 136 | 143 | .951 | .129 | 37.9% | 30 | 36 | .833 | .124 | 134.4% | 137 | 157 | .873 | .127 | 100.3% | 377 | 77.0%
Billy Smith | 1981 | 76 | 79 | .962 | .117 | 32.5% | 106 | 121 | .876 | .137 | 90.5% | 86 | 94 | .915 | .127 | 67.0% | 125 | 141 | .887 | .113 | 100.4% | 435 | 78.1%
Gilles Meloche | 1981 | 64 | 71 | .901 | .136 | 72.5% | 118 | 132 | .894 | .133 | 79.7% | 137 | 151 | .907 | .152 | 61.0% | 39 | 51 | .765 | .147 | 160.1% | 405 | 81.6%
Richard Brodeur | 1982 | 103 | 108 | .954 | .142 | 32.6% | 161 | 175 | .920 | .123 | 65.0% | 167 | 180 | .928 | .129 | 56.0% | 114 | 131 | .870 | .156 | 83.2% | 594 | 60.4%
Billy Smith | 1982 | 105 | 113 | .929 | .122 | 58.0% | 131 | 151 | .868 | .138 | 96.0% | 113 | 122 | .926 | .154 | 47.9% | 102 | 112 | .911 | .118 | 75.7% | 498 | 71.0%
Billy Smith | 1983 | 62 | 68 | .912 | .125 | 70.6% | 106 | 116 | .914 | .134 | 64.3% | 161 | 182 | .885 | .133 | 86.8% | 122 | 128 | .953 | .159 | 29.5% | 494 | 64.4%
Andy Moog | 1983 | 77 | 86 | .895 | .122 | 85.8% | 144 | 157 | .917 | .140 | 59.1% | 110 | 121 | .909 | .133 | 68.4% | 86 | 101 | .851 | .124 | 119.8% | 465 | 79.6%
Grant Fuhr | 1984 | 107 | 114 | .939 | .132 | 46.5% | 197 | 221 | .891 | .121 | 89.7% | 71 | 76 | .934 | .136 | 48.4% | 76 | 84 | .905 | .147 | 64.8% | 495 | 69.2%
Billy Smith | 1984 | 130 | 142 | .915 | .123 | 68.7% | 132 | 145 | .910 | .122 | 73.5% | 129 | 141 | .915 | .125 | 68.1% | 122 | 139 | .878 | .171 | 71.5% | 567 | 70.5%
Pelle Lindbergh | 1985 | 92 | 102 | .902 | .124 | 79.1% | 117 | 126 | .929 | .143 | 50.0% | 151 | 163 | .926 | .133 | 55.4% | 85 | 96 | .885 | .155 | 73.9% | 487 | 62.6%
Grant Fuhr | 1985 | 99 | 106 | .934 | .133 | 49.7% | 105 | 116 | .905 | .141 | 67.3% | 141 | 165 | .855 | .129 | 112.8% | 120 | 133 | .902 | .132 | 74.0% | 520 | 79.8%
Patrick Roy | 1986 | 72 | 78 | .923 | .126 | 61.1% | 145 | 157 | .924 | .140 | 54.6% | 135 | 144 | .938 | .110 | 56.8% | 113 | 125 | .904 | .128 | 75.0% | 504 | 61.3%
Mike Vernon | 1986 | 84 | 92 | .913 | .116 | 75.0% | 147 | 164 | .896 | .161 | 64.4% | 172 | 193 | .891 | .120 | 90.7% | 118 | 132 | .894 | .140 | 75.8% | 581 | 77.4%
Ron Hextall | 1987 | 158 | 170 | .929 | .124 | 56.9% | 169 | 185 | .914 | .113 | 76.5% | 167 | 188 | .888 | .124 | 90.1% | 204 | 226 | .903 | .158 | 61.6% | 769 | 71.1%
Grant Fuhr | 1987 | 78 | 89 | .876 | .129 | 95.8% | 98 | 107 | .916 | .114 | 73.8% | 97 | 107 | .907 | .120 | 77.9% | 189 | 206 | .917 | .129 | 64.0% | 509 | 74.5%
Reggie Lemelin | 1988 | 95 | 109 | .872 | .118 | 108.8% | 99 | 104 | .952 | .124 | 38.8% | 142 | 160 | .888 | .123 | 91.5% | 47 | 55 | .855 | .155 | 93.8% | 428 | 83.4%
Grant Fuhr | 1988 | 126 | 142 | .887 | .116 | 97.1% | 103 | 114 | .904 | .149 | 64.8% | 106 | 122 | .869 | .143 | 91.7% | 80 | 92 | .870 | .116 | 112.4% | 470 | 90.9%
Patrick Roy | 1989 | 95 | 102 | .931 | .122 | 56.3% | 97 | 107 | .907 | .115 | 81.3% | 125 | 133 | .940 | .129 | 46.6% | 167 | 184 | .908 | .128 | 72.2% | 526 | 64.5%
Mike Vernon | 1989 | 166 | 183 | .907 | .103 | 90.2% | 84 | 95 | .884 | .149 | 77.7% | 105 | 113 | .929 | .113 | 62.7% | 142 | 158 | .899 | .128 | 79.1% | 549 | 79.2%
Bill Ranford | 1990 | 186 | 207 | .899 | .123 | 82.5% | 127 | 137 | .927 | .143 | 51.0% | 151 | 171 | .883 | .120 | 97.5% | 148 | 156 | .949 | .111 | 46.2% | 671 | 71.4%
Andy Moog | 1990 | 124 | 135 | .919 | .121 | 67.3% | 125 | 136 | .919 | .116 | 69.7% | 88 | 94 | .936 | .117 | 54.6% | 103 | 119 | .866 | .140 | 96.0% | 484 | 72.6%
Tom Barrasso | 1991 | 151 | 168 | .899 | .109 | 92.8% | 97 | 100 | .970 | .109 | 27.5% | 157 | 175 | .897 | .119 | 86.4% | 173 | 186 | .930 | .100 | 69.9% | 629 | 73.9%
Jon Casey | 1991 | 122 | 135 | .904 | .111 | 86.8% | 158 | 174 | .908 | .122 | 75.4% | 99 | 110 | .900 | .123 | 81.3% | 131 | 152 | .862 | .142 | 97.3% | 571 | 85.0%
Ed Belfour | 1992 | 116 | 130 | .892 | .117 | 92.0% | 96 | 102 | .941 | .129 | 45.6% | 70 | 78 | .897 | .133 | 77.1% | 77 | 88 | .875 | .135 | 92.6% | 398 | 77.3%
Tom Barrasso | 1992 | 163 | 186 | .876 | .133 | 93.0% | 187 | 205 | .912 | .122 | 72.0% | 115 | 122 | .943 | .101 | 56.8% | 99 | 109 | .908 | .097 | 94.6% | 622 | 79.2%
Patrick Roy | 1993 | 190 | 203 | .936 | .139 | 46.1% | 130 | 142 | .915 | .125 | 67.6% | 137 | 147 | .932 | .129 | 52.7% | 144 | 155 | .929 | .118 | 60.1% | 647 | 55.7%
Kelly Hrudey | 1993 | 77 | 93 | .828 | .122 | 141.0% | 148 | 168 | .881 | .130 | 91.6% | 195 | 218 | .894 | .113 | 93.4% | 162 | 177 | .915 | .122 | 69.5% | 656 | 93.2%
Kirk McLean | 1994 | 203 | 222 | .914 | .114 | 75.1% | 171 | 182 | .940 | .112 | 54.0% | 160 | 169 | .947 | .111 | 48.0% | 227 | 247 | .919 | .104 | 77.9% | 820 | 65.6%
Mike Richter | 1994 | 87 | 90 | .967 | .112 | 29.8% | 114 | 126 | .905 | .106 | 89.8% | 179 | 194 | .923 | .115 | 67.2% | 194 | 213 | .911 | .106 | 84.2% | 623 | 72.2%
Martin Brodeur | 1995 | 126 | 131 | .962 | .091 | 41.9% | 132 | 140 | .943 | .129 | 44.3% | 103 | 117 | .880 | .114 | 105.0% | 68 | 75 | .907 | .115 | 81.2% | 463 | 64.9%
Mike Vernon | 1995 | 104 | 114 | .912 | .089 | 98.6% | 55 | 61 | .902 | .112 | 87.8% | 88 | 99 | .889 | .106 | 104.8% | 82 | 96 | .854 | .094 | 155.1% | 370 | 113.1%
John Vanbiesbrouck | 1996 | 163 | 177 | .921 | .099 | 79.9% | 204 | 215 | .949 | .111 | 46.1% | 210 | 224 | .938 | .137 | 45.6% | 108 | 119 | .908 | .123 | 75.2% | 735 | 58.8%
Patrick Roy | 1996 | 139 | 156 | .891 | .112 | 97.3% | 159 | 173 | .919 | .122 | 66.3% | 153 | 169 | .905 | .123 | 77.0% | 147 | 151 | .974 | .107 | 24.8% | 649 | 66.9%
Mike Vernon | 1997 | 133 | 145 | .917 | .098 | 84.4% | 123 | 131 | .939 | .105 | 58.2% | 100 | 110 | .909 | .106 | 85.8% | 102 | 108 | .944 | .104 | 53.4% | 494 | 71.0%
Garth Snow | 1997 | 126 | 139 | .906 | .118 | 79.3% | 93 | 103 | .903 | .113 | 85.9% | 29 | 35 | .829 | .102 | 168.1% | 24 | 28 | .857 | .093 | 153.6% | 305 | 98.5%
Olaf Kolzig | 1998 | 226 | 239 | .946 | .099 | 54.9% | 161 | 168 | .958 | .080 | 52.1% | 159 | 170 | .935 | .097 | 66.7% | 150 | 163 | .920 | .099 | 80.6% | 740 | 62.6%
Chris Osgood | 1998 | 138 | 156 | .885 | .099 | 116.6% | 158 | 171 | .924 | .116 | 65.5% | 152 | 162 | .938 | .110 | 56.1% | 92 | 99 | .929 | .098 | 72.2% | 588 | 77.6%
Dominik Hasek | 1999 | 156 | 162 | .963 | .095 | 39.0% | 134 | 146 | .918 | .095 | 86.5% | 75 | 81 | .926 | .116 | 63.9% | 186 | 198 | .939 | .104 | 58.3% | 587 | 60.7%
Ed Belfour | 1999 | 86 | 93 | .925 | .096 | 78.4% | 163 | 175 | .931 | .096 | 71.4% | 182 | 197 | .924 | .104 | 73.2% | 143 | 152 | .941 | .096 | 61.7% | 617 | 70.6%
Ed Belfour | 2000 | 102 | 113 | .903 | .098 | 99.3% | 126 | 133 | .947 | .100 | 52.6% | 191 | 204 | .936 | .106 | 60.1% | 187 | 201 | .930 | .092 | 75.7% | 651 | 70.2%
Martin Brodeur | 2000 | 98 | 104 | .942 | .111 | 52.0% | 108 | 117 | .923 | .114 | 67.5% | 154 | 169 | .911 | .095 | 93.4% | 138 | 147 | .939 | .101 | 60.6% | 537 | 70.8%
Patrick Roy | 2001 | 79 | 88 | .898 | .098 | 104.4% | 165 | 175 | .943 | .110 | 51.9% | 170 | 181 | .939 | .100 | 60.8% | 167 | 178 | .938 | .114 | 54.2% | 622 | 62.6%
Martin Brodeur | 2001 | 106 | 114 | .930 | .096 | 73.1% | 130 | 148 | .878 | .102 | 119.2% | 92 | 99 | .929 | .117 | 60.4% | 127 | 146 | .870 | .113 | 115.2% | 507 | 96.2%
Arturs Irbe | 2002 | 79 | 86 | .919 | .084 | 96.9% | 71 | 75 | .947 | .099 | 53.9% | 152 | 158 | .962 | .106 | 35.8% | 148 | 161 | .919 | .099 | 81.6% | 480 | 64.9%
Dominik Hasek | 2002 | 131 | 146 | .897 | .109 | 94.3% | 118 | 128 | .922 | .095 | 82.2% | 155 | 168 | .923 | .094 | 82.3% | 113 | 120 | .942 | .092 | 63.4% | 562 | 81.4%
Jean-Sebastien Giguere | 2003 | 165 | 171 | .965 | .110 | 31.9% | 189 | 202 | .936 | .099 | 65.0% | 122 | 123 | .992 | .095 | 8.6% | 183 | 201 | .910 | .083 | 107.9% | 697 | 59.3%
Martin Brodeur | 2003 | 126 | 134 | .940 | .093 | 64.2% | 129 | 137 | .942 | .091 | 64.2% | 178 | 191 | .932 | .108 | 63.0% | 148 | 160 | .925 | .090 | 83.3% | 622 | 68.8%
Miikka Kiprusoff | 2004 | 190 | 206 | .922 | .099 | 78.5% | 176 | 187 | .941 | .103 | 57.1% | 136 | 147 | .925 | .095 | 78.8% | 157 | 170 | .924 | .100 | 76.5% | 710 | 72.4%
Nikolai Khabibulin | 2004 | 137 | 141 | .972 | .101 | 28.1% | 126 | 133 | .947 | .092 | 57.2% | 162 | 179 | .905 | .095 | 100.0% | 157 | 171 | .918 | .089 | 92.0% | 624 | 72.4%
Dwayne Roloson | 2006 | 221 | 238 | .929 | .108 | 66.1% | 163 | 175 | .931 | .107 | 64.1% | 170 | 182 | .934 | .097 | 68.0% | 19 | 23 | .826 | .112 | 155.3% | 618 | 69.4%
Cam Ward | 2006 | 125 | 133 | .940 | .098 | 61.4% | 100 | 109 | .917 | .097 | 85.1% | 128 | 142 | .901 | .110 | 89.6% | 184 | 200 | .920 | .102 | 78.4% | 584 | 78.5%
Jean-Sebastien Giguere | 2007 | 30 | 31 | .968 | .093 | 34.7% | 147 | 155 | .948 | .090 | 57.3% | 149 | 164 | .909 | .091 | 100.5% | 90 | 101 | .891 | .108 | 100.8% | 451 | 81.2%
Ray Emery | 2007 | 100 | 110 | .909 | .113 | 80.5% | 137 | 148 | .926 | .088 | 84.5% | 113 | 123 | .919 | .123 | 66.1% | 108 | 124 | .871 | .098 | 131.7% | 505 | 90.7%
Chris Osgood | 2008 | 53 | 54 | .981 | .094 | 19.7% | 96 | 105 | .914 | .095 | 90.2% | 119 | 129 | .922 | .108 | 71.8% | 132 | 142 | .930 | .106 | 66.4% | 430 | 68.0%
Marc-Andre Fleury | 2008 | 107 | 112 | .955 | .104 | 42.9% | 133 | 144 | .924 | .079 | 96.7% | 124 | 132 | .939 | .104 | 58.3% | 205 | 222 | .923 | .089 | 86.0% | 610 | 74.6%
Chris Osgood | 2009 | 103 | 110 | .936 | .093 | 68.4% | 176 | 193 | .912 | .096 | 91.8% | 138 | 148 | .932 | .097 | 69.7% | 173 | 186 | .930 | .108 | 64.7% | 637 | 74.7%
Marc-Andre Fleury | 2009 | 178 | 193 | .922 | .107 | 72.6% | 158 | 180 | .878 | .098 | 124.7% | 109 | 118 | .924 | .088 | 86.7% | 178 | 195 | .913 | .097 | 89.9% | 686 | 93.6%
Antti Niemi | 2010 | 151 | 164 | .921 | .087 | 91.1% | 150 | 167 | .898 | .106 | 96.0% | 129 | 136 | .949 | .099 | 52.0% | 157 | 178 | .882 | .090 | 131.1% | 645 | 95.2%
Tim Thomas | 2011 | 212 | 229 | .926 | .082 | 90.5% | 142 | 149 | .953 | .098 | 47.9% | 206 | 225 | .916 | .093 | 90.8% | 238 | 246 | .967 | .098 | 33.2% | 849 | 66.5%
Roberto Luongo | 2011 | 158 | 175 | .903 | .096 | 101.2% | 153 | 164 | .933 | .090 | 74.5% | 176 | 189 | .931 | .086 | 80.0% | 163 | 183 | .891 | .091 | 120.1% | 711 | 94.3%
Jonathan Quick | 2012 | 164 | 172 | .953 | .093 | 50.0% | 96 | 102 | .941 | .082 | 71.7% | 124 | 132 | .939 | .086 | 70.5% | 125 | 132 | .947 | .096 | 55.2% | 538 | 60.4%
Martin Brodeur | 2012 | 166 | 180 | .922 | .081 | 96.0% | 123 | 134 | .918 | .098 | 83.8% | 153 | 165 | .927 | .095 | 76.6% | 135 | 150 | .900 | .075 | 133.3% | 629 | 97.2%
Tuukka Rask | 2013 | 216 | 234 | .923 | .115 | 66.9% | 147 | 157 | .936 | .085 | 74.9% | 134 | 136 | .985 | .113 | 13.0% | 218 | 234 | .932 | .100 | 68.4% | 761 | 59.4%
Corey Crawford | 2013 | 132 | 139 | .950 | .085 | 59.2% | 184 | 198 | .929 | .084 | 84.2% | 127 | 137 | .927 | .092 | 79.3% | 185 | 200 | .925 | .082 | 91.5% | 674 | 80.2%
Henrik Lundqvist | 2014 | 158 | 172 | .919 | .094 | 86.6% | 204 | 217 | .940 | .099 | 60.5% | 142 | 154 | .922 | .090 | 86.6% | 179 | 194 | .923 | .076 | 101.7% | 737 | 82.9%
Jonathan Quick | 2014 | 222 | 243 | .914 | .084 | 102.9% | 163 | 178 | .916 | .102 | 82.6% | 184 | 207 | .889 | .096 | 115.7% | 136 | 146 | .932 | .079 | 86.7% | 774 | 98.6%
Corey Crawford | 2015 | 51 | 60 | .850 | .086 | 174.4% | 124 | 131 | .947 | .090 | 59.4% | 243 | 264 | .920 | .093 | 85.5% | 151 | 161 | .938 | .107 | 58.0% | 616 | 81.4%
Ben Bishop | 2015 | 153 | 166 | .922 | .095 | 82.4% | 156 | 166 | .940 | .092 | 65.5% | 174 | 193 | .902 | .096 | 102.5% | 133 | 144 | .924 | .079 | 96.7% | 669 | 87.1%
Matt Murray | 2016 | 85 | 89 | .955 | .100 | 44.9% | 187 | 202 | .926 | .099 | 75.0% | 132 | 146 | .904 | .093 | 103.1% | 127 | 138 | .920 | .095 | 83.9% | 575 | 79.6%
Martin Jones | 2016 | 114 | 125 | .912 | .085 | 103.5% | 200 | 217 | .922 | .089 | 88.0% | 126 | 137 | .920 | .089 | 90.2% | 191 | 205 | .932 | .089 | 76.7% | 684 | 87.9%
Pekka Rinne | 2017 | 123 | 126 | .976 | .096 | 24.8% | 151 | 162 | .932 | .100 | 67.9% | 172 | 186 | .925 | .091 | 82.7% | 111 | 125 | .888 | .101 | 110.9% | 599 | 72.4%

Rounds 1-3 from Four-Round Goaltenders
This category takes the entire list of Four-Round Goaltenders and isolates the first 3 rounds, removing performance in the Stanley Cup Finals. This presents a comparable sample size to the Three-Round Goaltenders, and because error rate vs. expectation is a measurement that can either increase or decrease with additional play, gives an opportunity for evaluating performance up to an equivlent point without requiring an additional round of statistical maintenance. More than that, for 1983-2017 goaltenders, this captures their performance in the Conference playoffs, which may hold value to some. Also included is Marc-Andre Fleury from the 2017 Pittsburgh Penguins, who did not play in the fourth round.

Player | Year | R1 SV | R1 SA | R1 SV% | R1 OPP | R1 EvE | R2 SV | R2 SA | R2 SV% | R2 OPP | R2 EvE | R3 SV | R3 SA | R3 SV% | R3 OPP | R3 EvE | SA | EvE
John Davidson | 1979 | 66 | 68 | .971 | .121 | 24.3% | 146 | 154 | .948 | .111 | 46.8% | 139 | 152 | .914 | .156 | 54.8% | 374 | 46.0%
Pete Peeters | 1980 | 37 | 41 | .902 | .133 | 73.4% | 136 | 143 | .951 | .129 | 37.9% | 30 | 36 | .833 | .124 | 134.4% | 220 | 60.3%
Billy Smith | 1980 | 69 | 73 | .945 | .125 | 43.8% | 140 | 154 | .909 | .139 | 65.4% | 136 | 149 | .913 | .136 | 64.2% | 376 | 60.7%
Billy Smith | 1981 | 76 | 79 | .962 | .117 | 32.5% | 106 | 121 | .876 | .137 | 90.5% | 86 | 94 | .915 | .127 | 67.0% | 294 | 67.4%
Gilles Meloche | 1981 | 64 | 71 | .901 | .136 | 72.5% | 118 | 132 | .894 | .133 | 79.7% | 137 | 151 | .907 | .152 | 61.0% | 354 | 70.3%
Richard Brodeur | 1982 | 103 | 108 | .954 | .142 | 32.6% | 161 | 175 | .920 | .123 | 65.0% | 167 | 180 | .928 | .129 | 56.0% | 463 | 54.0%
Billy Smith | 1982 | 105 | 113 | .929 | .122 | 58.0% | 131 | 151 | .868 | .138 | 96.0% | 113 | 122 | .926 | .154 | 47.9% | 386 | 69.7%
Andy Moog | 1983 | 77 | 86 | .895 | .122 | 85.8% | 144 | 157 | .917 | .140 | 59.1% | 110 | 121 | .909 | .133 | 68.4% | 364 | 68.5%
Billy Smith | 1983 | 62 | 68 | .912 | .125 | 70.6% | 106 | 116 | .914 | .134 | 64.3% | 161 | 182 | .885 | .133 | 86.8% | 366 | 76.6%
Grant Fuhr | 1984 | 107 | 114 | .939 | .132 | 46.5% | 197 | 221 | .891 | .121 | 89.7% | 71 | 76 | .934 | .136 | 48.4% | 411 | 70.1%
Billy Smith | 1984 | 130 | 142 | .915 | .123 | 68.7% | 132 | 145 | .910 | .122 | 73.5% | 129 | 141 | .915 | .125 | 68.1% | 428 | 70.1%
Pelle Lindbergh | 1985 | 92 | 102 | .902 | .124 | 79.1% | 117 | 126 | .929 | .143 | 50.0% | 151 | 163 | .926 | .133 | 55.4% | 391 | 59.8%
Grant Fuhr | 1985 | 99 | 106 | .934 | .133 | 49.7% | 105 | 116 | .905 | .141 | 67.3% | 141 | 165 | .855 | .129 | 112.8% | 387 | 81.8%
Patrick Roy | 1986 | 72 | 78 | .923 | .126 | 61.1% | 145 | 157 | .924 | .140 | 54.6% | 135 | 144 | .938 | .110 | 56.8% | 379 | 56.8%
Mike Vernon | 1986 | 84 | 92 | .913 | .116 | 75.0% | 147 | 164 | .896 | .161 | 64.4% | 172 | 193 | .891 | .120 | 90.7% | 449 | 77.9%
Ron Hextall | 1987 | 158 | 170 | .929 | .124 | 56.9% | 169 | 185 | .914 | .113 | 76.5% | 167 | 188 | .888 | .124 | 90.1% | 543 | 75.1%
Grant Fuhr | 1987 | 78 | 89 | .876 | .129 | 95.8% | 98 | 107 | .916 | .114 | 73.8% | 97 | 107 | .907 | .120 | 77.9% | 303 | 81.7%
Reggie Lemelin | 1988 | 95 | 109 | .872 | .118 | 108.8% | 99 | 104 | .952 | .124 | 38.8% | 142 | 160 | .888 | .123 | 91.5% | 373 | 81.9%
Grant Fuhr | 1988 | 126 | 142 | .887 | .116 | 97.1% | 103 | 114 | .904 | .149 | 64.8% | 106 | 122 | .869 | .143 | 91.7% | 378 | 85.6%
Patrick Roy | 1989 | 95 | 102 | .931 | .122 | 56.3% | 97 | 107 | .907 | .115 | 81.3% | 125 | 133 | .940 | .129 | 46.6% | 342 | 60.3%
Mike Vernon | 1989 | 166 | 183 | .907 | .103 | 90.2% | 84 | 95 | .884 | .149 | 77.7% | 105 | 113 | .929 | .113 | 62.7% | 391 | 79.2%
Andy Moog | 1990 | 124 | 135 | .919 | .121 | 67.3% | 125 | 136 | .919 | .116 | 69.7% | 88 | 94 | .936 | .117 | 54.6% | 365 | 64.9%
Bill Ranford | 1990 | 186 | 207 | .899 | .123 | 82.5% | 127 | 137 | .927 | .143 | 51.0% | 151 | 171 | .883 | .120 | 97.5% | 515 | 79.1%
Tom Barrasso | 1991 | 151 | 168 | .899 | .109 | 92.8% | 97 | 100 | .970 | .109 | 27.5% | 157 | 175 | .897 | .119 | 86.4% | 443 | 75.6%
Jon Casey | 1991 | 122 | 135 | .904 | .111 | 86.8% | 158 | 174 | .908 | .122 | 75.4% | 99 | 110 | .900 | .123 | 81.3% | 419 | 80.6%
Ed Belfour | 1992 | 116 | 130 | .892 | .117 | 92.0% | 96 | 102 | .941 | .129 | 45.6% | 70 | 78 | .897 | .133 | 77.1% | 310 | 73.0%
Tom Barrasso | 1992 | 163 | 186 | .876 | .133 | 93.0% | 187 | 205 | .912 | .122 | 72.0% | 115 | 122 | .943 | .101 | 56.8% | 513 | 76.0%
Patrick Roy | 1993 | 190 | 203 | .936 | .139 | 46.1% | 130 | 142 | .915 | .125 | 67.6% | 137 | 147 | .932 | .129 | 52.7% | 492 | 54.3%
Kelly Hrudey | 1993 | 77 | 93 | .828 | .122 | 141.0% | 148 | 168 | .881 | .130 | 91.6% | 195 | 218 | .894 | .113 | 93.4% | 479 | 102.0%
Kirk McLean | 1994 | 203 | 222 | .914 | .114 | 75.1% | 171 | 182 | .940 | .112 | 54.0% | 160 | 169 | .947 | .111 | 48.0% | 573 | 60.4%
Mike Richter | 1994 | 87 | 90 | .967 | .112 | 29.8% | 114 | 126 | .905 | .106 | 89.8% | 179 | 194 | .923 | .115 | 67.2% | 410 | 66.0%
Martin Brodeur | 1995 | 126 | 131 | .962 | .091 | 41.9% | 132 | 140 | .943 | .129 | 44.3% | 103 | 117 | .880 | .114 | 105.0% | 388 | 61.8%
Mike Vernon | 1995 | 104 | 114 | .912 | .089 | 98.6% | 55 | 61 | .902 | .112 | 87.8% | 88 | 99 | .889 | .106 | 104.8% | 274 | 98.4%
John Vanbiesbrouck | 1996 | 163 | 177 | .921 | .099 | 79.9% | 204 | 215 | .949 | .111 | 46.1% | 210 | 224 | .938 | .137 | 45.6% | 616 | 55.6%
Patrick Roy | 1996 | 139 | 156 | .891 | .112 | 97.3% | 159 | 173 | .919 | .122 | 66.3% | 153 | 169 | .905 | .123 | 77.0% | 498 | 79.6%
Mike Vernon | 1997 | 133 | 145 | .917 | .098 | 84.4% | 123 | 131 | .939 | .105 | 58.2% | 100 | 110 | .909 | .106 | 85.8% | 386 | 75.9%
Garth Snow | 1997 | 126 | 139 | .906 | .118 | 79.3% | 93 | 103 | .903 | .113 | 85.9% | 29 | 35 | .829 | .102 | 168.1% | 277 | 93.0%
Olaf Kolzig | 1998 | 226 | 239 | .946 | .099 | 54.9% | 161 | 168 | .958 | .080 | 52.1% | 159 | 170 | .935 | .097 | 66.7% | 577 | 57.6%
Chris Osgood | 1998 | 138 | 156 | .885 | .099 | 116.6% | 158 | 171 | .924 | .116 | 65.5% | 152 | 162 | .938 | .110 | 56.1% | 489 | 78.7%
Dominik Hasek | 1999 | 156 | 162 | .963 | .095 | 39.0% | 134 | 146 | .918 | .095 | 86.5% | 75 | 81 | .926 | .116 | 63.9% | 389 | 62.0%
Ed Belfour | 1999 | 86 | 93 | .925 | .096 | 78.4% | 163 | 175 | .931 | .096 | 71.4% | 182 | 197 | .924 | .104 | 73.2% | 465 | 73.6%
Ed Belfour | 2000 | 102 | 113 | .903 | .098 | 99.3% | 126 | 133 | .947 | .100 | 52.6% | 191 | 204 | .936 | .106 | 60.1% | 450 | 67.8%
Martin Brodeur | 2000 | 98 | 104 | .942 | .111 | 52.0% | 108 | 117 | .923 | .114 | 67.5% | 154 | 169 | .911 | .095 | 93.4% | 390 | 74.6%
Patrick Roy | 2001 | 79 | 88 | .898 | .098 | 104.4% | 165 | 175 | .943 | .110 | 51.9% | 170 | 181 | .939 | .100 | 60.8% | 444 | 65.9%
Martin Brodeur | 2001 | 106 | 114 | .930 | .096 | 73.1% | 130 | 148 | .878 | .102 | 119.2% | 92 | 99 | .929 | .117 | 60.4% | 361 | 88.5%
Arturs Irbe | 2002 | 79 | 86 | .919 | .084 | 96.9% | 71 | 75 | .947 | .099 | 53.9% | 152 | 158 | .962 | .106 | 35.8% | 319 | 56.5%
Dominik Hasek | 2002 | 131 | 146 | .897 | .109 | 94.3% | 118 | 128 | .922 | .095 | 82.2% | 155 | 168 | .923 | .094 | 82.3% | 442 | 86.2%
Jean-Sebastien Giguere | 2003 | 165 | 171 | .965 | .110 | 31.9% | 189 | 202 | .936 | .099 | 65.0% | 122 | 123 | .992 | .095 | 8.6% | 496 | 39.6%
Martin Brodeur | 2003 | 126 | 134 | .940 | .093 | 64.2% | 129 | 137 | .942 | .091 | 64.2% | 178 | 191 | .932 | .108 | 63.0% | 462 | 63.7%
Nikolai Khabibulin | 2004 | 137 | 141 | .972 | .101 | 28.1% | 126 | 133 | .947 | .092 | 57.2% | 162 | 179 | .905 | .095 | 100.0% | 453 | 65.0%
Miikka Kiprusoff | 2004 | 190 | 206 | .922 | .099 | 78.5% | 176 | 187 | .941 | .103 | 57.1% | 136 | 147 | .925 | .095 | 78.8% | 540 | 71.1%
Dwayne Roloson | 2006 | 221 | 238 | .929 | .108 | 66.1% | 163 | 175 | .931 | .107 | 64.1% | 170 | 182 | .934 | .097 | 68.0% | 595 | 66.1%
Cam Ward | 2006 | 125 | 133 | .940 | .098 | 61.4% | 100 | 109 | .917 | .097 | 85.1% | 128 | 142 | .901 | .110 | 89.6% | 384 | 78.6%
Jean-Sebastien Giguere | 2007 | 30 | 31 | .968 | .093 | 34.7% | 147 | 155 | .948 | .090 | 57.3% | 149 | 164 | .909 | .091 | 100.5% | 350 | 75.6%
Ray Emery | 2007 | 100 | 110 | .909 | .113 | 80.5% | 137 | 148 | .926 | .088 | 84.5% | 113 | 123 | .919 | .123 | 66.1% | 381 | 77.4%
Marc-Andre Fleury | 2008 | 107 | 112 | .955 | .104 | 42.9% | 133 | 144 | .924 | .079 | 96.7% | 124 | 132 | .939 | .104 | 58.3% | 388 | 68.1%
Chris Osgood | 2008 | 53 | 54 | .981 | .094 | 19.7% | 96 | 105 | .914 | .095 | 90.2% | 119 | 129 | .922 | .108 | 71.8% | 288 | 68.7%
Chris Osgood | 2009 | 103 | 110 | .936 | .093 | 68.4% | 176 | 193 | .912 | .096 | 91.8% | 138 | 148 | .932 | .097 | 69.7% | 451 | 78.8%
Marc-Andre Fleury | 2009 | 178 | 193 | .922 | .107 | 72.6% | 158 | 180 | .878 | .098 | 124.7% | 109 | 118 | .924 | .088 | 86.7% | 491 | 95.1%
Antti Niemi | 2010 | 151 | 164 | .921 | .087 | 91.1% | 150 | 167 | .898 | .106 | 96.0% | 129 | 136 | .949 | .099 | 52.0% | 467 | 81.5%
Tim Thomas | 2011 | 212 | 229 | .926 | .082 | 90.5% | 142 | 149 | .953 | .098 | 47.9% | 206 | 225 | .916 | .093 | 90.8% | 603 | 80.1%
Roberto Luongo | 2011 | 158 | 175 | .903 | .096 | 101.2% | 153 | 164 | .933 | .090 | 74.5% | 176 | 189 | .931 | .086 | 80.0% | 528 | 85.3%
Jonathan Quick | 2012 | 164 | 172 | .953 | .093 | 50.0% | 96 | 102 | .941 | .082 | 71.7% | 124 | 132 | .939 | .086 | 70.5% | 406 | 62.1%
Martin Brodeur | 2012 | 166 | 180 | .922 | .081 | 96.0% | 123 | 134 | .918 | .098 | 83.8% | 153 | 165 | .927 | .095 | 76.6% | 479 | 85.9%
Tuukka Rask | 2013 | 216 | 234 | .923 | .115 | 66.9% | 147 | 157 | .936 | .085 | 74.9% | 134 | 136 | .985 | .113 | 13.0% | 527 | 55.4%
Corey Crawford | 2013 | 132 | 139 | .950 | .085 | 59.2% | 184 | 198 | .929 | .084 | 84.2% | 127 | 137 | .927 | .092 | 79.3% | 474 | 75.5%
Henrik Lundqvist | 2014 | 158 | 172 | .919 | .094 | 86.6% | 204 | 217 | .940 | .099 | 60.5% | 142 | 154 | .922 | .090 | 86.6% | 543 | 76.2%
Jonathan Quick | 2014 | 222 | 243 | .914 | .084 | 102.9% | 163 | 178 | .916 | .102 | 82.6% | 184 | 207 | .889 | .096 | 115.7% | 628 | 101.4%
Ben Bishop | 2015 | 153 | 166 | .922 | .095 | 82.4% | 156 | 166 | .940 | .092 | 65.5% | 174 | 193 | .902 | .096 | 102.5% | 525 | 84.5%
Corey Crawford | 2015 | 51 | 60 | .850 | .086 | 174.4% | 124 | 131 | .947 | .090 | 59.4% | 243 | 264 | .920 | .093 | 85.5% | 455 | 89.7%
Matt Murray | 2016 | 85 | 89 | .955 | .100 | 44.9% | 187 | 202 | .926 | .099 | 75.0% | 132 | 146 | .904 | .093 | 103.1% | 437 | 78.3%
Martin Jones | 2016 | 114 | 125 | .912 | .085 | 103.5% | 200 | 217 | .922 | .089 | 88.0% | 126 | 137 | .920 | .089 | 90.2% | 479 | 92.7%
Pekka Rinne | 2017 | 123 | 126 | .976 | .096 | 24.8% | 151 | 162 | .932 | .100 | 67.9% | 172 | 186 | .925 | .091 | 82.7% | 474 | 62.3%
Marc-Andre Fleury | 2017 | 181 | 194 | .933 | .097 | 69.1% | 211 | 229 | .921 | .105 | 74.9% | 61 | 67 | .910 | .084 | 106.6% | 490 | 76.9%

Rounds 2-4 from Four-Round Goaltenders
This category takes the entire list of Four-Round Goaltenders and isolates the final 3 rounds, removing performance in the Conference Quarterfinals. This presents a comparable sample size to the Three-Round Goaltenders, while emphasizing the error rate vs. expectation for what are arguably the more important rounds. Again, this is presented as a comparable sample size to the Three-Round Goaltenders. Also included is Michael Leighton from the 2010 Philadelphia Flyers, who did not play in the first round.

Player | Year | R2 SV | R2 SA | R2 SV% | R2 OPP | R2 EvE | R3 SV | R3 SA | R3 SV% | R3 OPP | R3 EvE | R4 SV | R4 SA | R4 SV% | R4 OPP | R4 EvE | SA | EvE
John Davidson | 1979 | 146 | 154 | .948 | .111 | 46.8% | 139 | 152 | .914 | .156 | 54.8% | 142 | 161 | .882 | .131 | 90.1% | 467 | 64.3%
Pete Peeters | 1980 | 136 | 143 | .951 | .129 | 37.9% | 30 | 36 | .833 | .124 | 134.4% | 137 | 157 | .873 | .127 | 100.3% | 336 | 77.4%
Billy Smith | 1980 | 140 | 154 | .909 | .139 | 65.4% | 136 | 149 | .913 | .136 | 64.2% | 160 | 183 | .874 | .121 | 103.9% | 486 | 79.5%
Gilles Meloche | 1981 | 118 | 132 | .894 | .133 | 79.7% | 137 | 151 | .907 | .152 | 61.0% | 39 | 51 | .765 | .147 | 160.1% | 334 | 83.5%
Billy Smith | 1981 | 106 | 121 | .876 | .137 | 90.5% | 86 | 94 | .915 | .127 | 67.0% | 125 | 141 | .887 | .113 | 100.4% | 356 | 88.2%
Richard Brodeur | 1982 | 161 | 175 | .920 | .123 | 65.0% | 167 | 180 | .928 | .129 | 56.0% | 114 | 131 | .870 | .156 | 83.2% | 486 | 66.6%
Billy Smith | 1982 | 131 | 151 | .868 | .138 | 96.0% | 113 | 122 | .926 | .154 | 47.9% | 102 | 112 | .911 | .118 | 75.7% | 385 | 74.8%
Billy Smith | 1983 | 106 | 116 | .914 | .134 | 64.3% | 161 | 182 | .885 | .133 | 86.8% | 122 | 128 | .953 | .159 | 29.5% | 426 | 63.4%
Andy Moog | 1983 | 144 | 157 | .917 | .140 | 59.1% | 110 | 121 | .909 | .133 | 68.4% | 86 | 101 | .851 | .124 | 119.8% | 379 | 78.2%
Billy Smith | 1984 | 132 | 145 | .910 | .122 | 73.5% | 129 | 141 | .915 | .125 | 68.1% | 122 | 139 | .878 | .171 | 71.5% | 425 | 71.1%
Grant Fuhr | 1984 | 197 | 221 | .891 | .121 | 89.7% | 71 | 76 | .934 | .136 | 48.4% | 76 | 84 | .905 | .147 | 64.8% | 381 | 76.0%
Pelle Lindbergh | 1985 | 117 | 126 | .929 | .143 | 50.0% | 151 | 163 | .926 | .133 | 55.4% | 85 | 96 | .885 | .155 | 73.9% | 385 | 58.2%
Grant Fuhr | 1985 | 105 | 116 | .905 | .141 | 67.3% | 141 | 165 | .855 | .129 | 112.8% | 120 | 133 | .902 | .132 | 74.0% | 414 | 87.6%
Patrick Roy | 1986 | 145 | 157 | .924 | .140 | 54.6% | 135 | 144 | .938 | .110 | 56.8% | 113 | 125 | .904 | .128 | 75.0% | 426 | 61.3%
Mike Vernon | 1986 | 147 | 164 | .896 | .161 | 64.4% | 172 | 193 | .891 | .120 | 90.7% | 118 | 132 | .894 | .140 | 75.8% | 489 | 77.8%
Grant Fuhr | 1987 | 98 | 107 | .916 | .114 | 73.8% | 97 | 107 | .907 | .120 | 77.9% | 189 | 206 | .917 | .129 | 64.0% | 420 | 70.0%
Ron Hextall | 1987 | 169 | 185 | .914 | .113 | 76.5% | 167 | 188 | .888 | .124 | 90.1% | 204 | 226 | .903 | .158 | 61.6% | 599 | 75.2%
Reggie Lemelin | 1988 | 99 | 104 | .952 | .124 | 38.8% | 142 | 160 | .888 | .123 | 91.5% | 47 | 55 | .855 | .155 | 93.8% | 319 | 74.7%
Grant Fuhr | 1988 | 103 | 114 | .904 | .149 | 64.8% | 106 | 122 | .869 | .143 | 91.7% | 80 | 92 | .870 | .116 | 112.4% | 328 | 88.2%
Patrick Roy | 1989 | 97 | 107 | .907 | .115 | 81.3% | 125 | 133 | .940 | .129 | 46.6% | 167 | 184 | .908 | .128 | 72.2% | 424 | 66.5%
Mike Vernon | 1989 | 84 | 95 | .884 | .149 | 77.7% | 105 | 113 | .929 | .113 | 62.7% | 142 | 158 | .899 | .128 | 79.1% | 366 | 73.7%
Bill Ranford | 1990 | 127 | 137 | .927 | .143 | 51.0% | 151 | 171 | .883 | .120 | 97.5% | 148 | 156 | .949 | .111 | 46.2% | 464 | 66.5%
Andy Moog | 1990 | 125 | 136 | .919 | .116 | 69.7% | 88 | 94 | .936 | .117 | 54.6% | 103 | 119 | .866 | .140 | 96.0% | 349 | 74.6%
Tom Barrasso | 1991 | 97 | 100 | .970 | .109 | 27.5% | 157 | 175 | .897 | .119 | 86.4% | 173 | 186 | .930 | .100 | 69.9% | 461 | 67.0%
Jon Casey | 1991 | 158 | 174 | .908 | .122 | 75.4% | 99 | 110 | .900 | .123 | 81.3% | 131 | 152 | .862 | .142 | 97.3% | 436 | 84.5%
Ed Belfour | 1992 | 96 | 102 | .941 | .129 | 45.6% | 70 | 78 | .897 | .133 | 77.1% | 77 | 88 | .875 | .135 | 92.6% | 268 | 70.2%
Tom Barrasso | 1992 | 187 | 205 | .912 | .122 | 72.0% | 115 | 122 | .943 | .101 | 56.8% | 99 | 109 | .908 | .097 | 94.6% | 436 | 73.4%
Patrick Roy | 1993 | 130 | 142 | .915 | .125 | 67.6% | 137 | 147 | .932 | .129 | 52.7% | 144 | 155 | .929 | .118 | 60.1% | 444 | 60.1%
Kelly Hrudey | 1993 | 148 | 168 | .881 | .130 | 91.6% | 195 | 218 | .894 | .113 | 93.4% | 162 | 177 | .915 | .122 | 69.5% | 563 | 85.3%
Kirk McLean | 1994 | 171 | 182 | .940 | .112 | 54.0% | 160 | 169 | .947 | .111 | 48.0% | 227 | 247 | .919 | .104 | 77.9% | 598 | 62.1%
Mike Richter | 1994 | 114 | 126 | .905 | .106 | 89.8% | 179 | 194 | .923 | .115 | 67.2% | 194 | 213 | .911 | .106 | 84.2% | 533 | 79.3%
Martin Brodeur | 1995 | 132 | 140 | .943 | .129 | 44.3% | 103 | 117 | .880 | .114 | 105.0% | 68 | 75 | .907 | .115 | 81.2% | 332 | 74.0%
Mike Vernon | 1995 | 55 | 61 | .902 | .112 | 87.8% | 88 | 99 | .889 | .106 | 104.8% | 82 | 96 | .854 | .094 | 155.1% | 256 | 119.6%
John Vanbiesbrouck | 1996 | 204 | 215 | .949 | .111 | 46.1% | 210 | 224 | .938 | .137 | 45.6% | 108 | 119 | .908 | .123 | 75.2% | 558 | 52.1%
Patrick Roy | 1996 | 159 | 173 | .919 | .122 | 66.3% | 153 | 169 | .905 | .123 | 77.0% | 147 | 151 | .974 | .107 | 24.8% | 493 | 57.2%
Mike Vernon | 1997 | 123 | 131 | .939 | .105 | 58.2% | 100 | 110 | .909 | .106 | 85.8% | 102 | 108 | .944 | .104 | 53.4% | 349 | 65.4%
Garth Snow | 1997 | 93 | 103 | .903 | .113 | 85.9% | 29 | 35 | .829 | .102 | 168.1% | 24 | 28 | .857 | .093 | 153.6% | 166 | 114.7%
Chris Osgood | 1998 | 158 | 171 | .924 | .116 | 65.5% | 152 | 162 | .938 | .110 | 56.1% | 92 | 99 | .929 | .098 | 72.2% | 432 | 63.5%
Olaf Kolzig | 1998 | 161 | 168 | .958 | .080 | 52.1% | 159 | 170 | .935 | .097 | 66.7% | 150 | 163 | .920 | .099 | 80.6% | 501 | 66.3%
Dominik Hasek | 1999 | 134 | 146 | .918 | .095 | 86.5% | 75 | 81 | .926 | .116 | 63.9% | 186 | 198 | .939 | .104 | 58.3% | 425 | 69.0%
Ed Belfour | 1999 | 163 | 175 | .931 | .096 | 71.4% | 182 | 197 | .924 | .104 | 73.2% | 143 | 152 | .941 | .096 | 61.7% | 524 | 69.3%
Ed Belfour | 2000 | 126 | 133 | .947 | .100 | 52.6% | 191 | 204 | .936 | .106 | 60.1% | 187 | 201 | .930 | .092 | 75.7% | 538 | 64.1%
Martin Brodeur | 2000 | 108 | 117 | .923 | .114 | 67.5% | 154 | 169 | .911 | .095 | 93.4% | 138 | 147 | .939 | .101 | 60.6% | 433 | 75.3%
Patrick Roy | 2001 | 165 | 175 | .943 | .110 | 51.9% | 170 | 181 | .939 | .100 | 60.8% | 167 | 178 | .938 | .114 | 54.2% | 534 | 55.7%
Martin Brodeur | 2001 | 130 | 148 | .878 | .102 | 119.2% | 92 | 99 | .929 | .117 | 60.4% | 127 | 146 | .870 | .113 | 115.2% | 393 | 102.9%
Arturs Irbe | 2002 | 71 | 75 | .947 | .099 | 53.9% | 152 | 158 | .962 | .106 | 35.8% | 148 | 161 | .919 | .099 | 81.6% | 394 | 57.9%
Dominik Hasek | 2002 | 118 | 128 | .922 | .095 | 82.2% | 155 | 168 | .923 | .094 | 82.3% | 113 | 120 | .942 | .092 | 63.4% | 416 | 76.8%
Jean-Sebastien Giguere | 2003 | 189 | 202 | .936 | .099 | 65.0% | 122 | 123 | .992 | .095 | 8.6% | 183 | 201 | .910 | .083 | 107.9% | 526 | 68.2%
Martin Brodeur | 2003 | 129 | 137 | .942 | .091 | 64.2% | 178 | 191 | .932 | .108 | 63.0% | 148 | 160 | .925 | .090 | 83.3% | 488 | 70.0%
Miikka Kiprusoff | 2004 | 176 | 187 | .941 | .103 | 57.1% | 136 | 147 | .925 | .095 | 78.8% | 157 | 170 | .924 | .100 | 76.5% | 504 | 70.0%
Nikolai Khabibulin | 2004 | 126 | 133 | .947 | .092 | 57.2% | 162 | 179 | .905 | .095 | 100.0% | 157 | 171 | .918 | .089 | 92.0% | 483 | 85.4%
Dwayne Roloson | 2006 | 163 | 175 | .931 | .107 | 64.1% | 170 | 182 | .934 | .097 | 68.0% | 19 | 23 | .826 | .112 | 155.3% | 380 | 71.5%
Cam Ward | 2006 | 100 | 109 | .917 | .097 | 85.1% | 128 | 142 | .901 | .110 | 89.6% | 184 | 200 | .920 | .102 | 78.4% | 451 | 83.6%
Jean-Sebastien Giguere | 2007 | 147 | 155 | .948 | .090 | 57.3% | 149 | 164 | .909 | .091 | 100.5% | 90 | 101 | .891 | .108 | 100.8% | 420 | 84.7%
Ray Emery | 2007 | 137 | 148 | .926 | .088 | 84.5% | 113 | 123 | .919 | .123 | 66.1% | 108 | 124 | .871 | .098 | 131.7% | 395 | 93.6%
Chris Osgood | 2008 | 96 | 105 | .914 | .095 | 90.2% | 119 | 129 | .922 | .108 | 71.8% | 132 | 142 | .930 | .106 | 66.4% | 376 | 74.9%
Marc-Andre Fleury | 2008 | 133 | 144 | .924 | .079 | 96.7% | 124 | 132 | .939 | .104 | 58.3% | 205 | 222 | .923 | .089 | 86.0% | 498 | 81.8%
Chris Osgood | 2009 | 176 | 193 | .912 | .096 | 91.8% | 138 | 148 | .932 | .097 | 69.7% | 173 | 186 | .930 | .108 | 64.7% | 527 | 76.0%
Marc-Andre Fleury | 2009 | 158 | 180 | .878 | .098 | 124.7% | 109 | 118 | .924 | .088 | 86.7% | 178 | 195 | .913 | .097 | 89.9% | 493 | 101.8%
Michael Leighton | 2010 | 66 | 70 | .943 | .075 | 76.2% | 133 | 140 | .950 | .090 | 55.6% | 141 | 161 | .876 | .094 | 132.2% | 371 | 92.7%
Antti Niemi | 2010 | 150 | 167 | .898 | .106 | 96.0% | 129 | 136 | .949 | .099 | 52.0% | 157 | 178 | .882 | .090 | 131.1% | 481 | 96.6%
Tim Thomas | 2011 | 142 | 149 | .953 | .098 | 47.9% | 206 | 225 | .916 | .093 | 90.8% | 238 | 246 | .967 | .098 | 33.2% | 620 | 57.6%
Roberto Luongo | 2011 | 153 | 164 | .933 | .090 | 74.5% | 176 | 189 | .931 | .086 | 80.0% | 163 | 183 | .891 | .091 | 120.1% | 536 | 92.0%
Jonathan Quick | 2012 | 96 | 102 | .941 | .082 | 71.7% | 124 | 132 | .939 | .086 | 70.5% | 125 | 132 | .947 | .096 | 55.2% | 366 | 65.3%
Martin Brodeur | 2012 | 123 | 134 | .918 | .098 | 83.8% | 153 | 165 | .927 | .095 | 76.6% | 135 | 150 | .900 | .075 | 133.3% | 449 | 97.7%
Tuukka Rask | 2013 | 147 | 157 | .936 | .085 | 74.9% | 134 | 136 | .985 | .113 | 13.0% | 218 | 234 | .932 | .100 | 68.4% | 527 | 56.0%
Corey Crawford | 2013 | 184 | 198 | .929 | .084 | 84.2% | 127 | 137 | .927 | .092 | 79.3% | 185 | 200 | .925 | .082 | 91.5% | 535 | 85.7%
Henrik Lundqvist | 2014 | 204 | 217 | .940 | .099 | 60.5% | 142 | 154 | .922 | .090 | 86.6% | 179 | 194 | .923 | .076 | 101.7% | 565 | 81.8%
Jonathan Quick | 2014 | 163 | 178 | .916 | .102 | 82.6% | 184 | 207 | .889 | .096 | 115.7% | 136 | 146 | .932 | .079 | 86.7% | 531 | 96.7%
Corey Crawford | 2015 | 124 | 131 | .947 | .090 | 59.4% | 243 | 264 | .920 | .093 | 85.5% | 151 | 161 | .938 | .107 | 58.0% | 556 | 71.4%
Ben Bishop | 2015 | 156 | 166 | .940 | .092 | 65.5% | 174 | 193 | .902 | .096 | 102.5% | 133 | 144 | .924 | .079 | 96.7% | 503 | 88.6%
Martin Jones | 2016 | 200 | 217 | .922 | .089 | 88.0% | 126 | 137 | .920 | .089 | 90.2% | 191 | 205 | .932 | .089 | 76.7% | 559 | 84.4%
Matt Murray | 2016 | 187 | 202 | .926 | .099 | 75.0% | 132 | 146 | .904 | .093 | 103.1% | 127 | 138 | .920 | .095 | 83.9% | 486 | 86.0%
Pekka Rinne | 2017 | 151 | 162 | .932 | .100 | 67.9% | 172 | 186 | .925 | .091 | 82.7% | 111 | 125 | .888 | .101 | 110.9% | 473 | 85.1%

Limitations include the typical caveats for Save Percentage statistics, including shot counting, variance in shot difficulty, and anchor games (in which a goaltender's statistics in a series are weighed down by 1-2 bad games more than they are bolstered by 4-5 great games). Also the regular season shooting percentage used for the expectation number does not have ENG scoring removed, which would unfortunately require reading 70-82 box scores for every opponent of every goaltender. Not an impossible task, but one that would require the sacrifice hundreds of hours of research and probably my marriage.

Statistics this time were compiled entirely from Hockey-Reference, and there were slight differences in some rounds compared to previous presentations of the error rate vs. expectation statistic.

Top 3rd Round Performances, 1968-2017
1. Jean-Sebastien Giguere, 2003 (8.6% on 123 shots)
2. Tuukka Rask, 2013 (13.0% on 136 shots)
3. Rogie Vachon, 1969 (29.8% on 107 shots)
4. Arturs Irbe, 2002 (35.8% on 158 shots)
5. John Vanbiesbrouck, 1996 (45.6% on 224 shots)
6. Patrick Roy, 1989 (46.6% on 133 shots)
7. Billy Smith, 1982 (47.9% on 122 shots)
8. Kirk McLean, 1994 (48.0% on 169 shots)
9. Grant Fuhr, 1984 (48.4% on 76 shots)
10. Greg Stefan, 1987 (49.1% on 129 shots)

Top 4th Round Performances, 1980-2017
1. Patrick Roy, 1996 (24.8% on 151 shots)
2. Billy Smith, 1983 (29.5% on 128 shots)
3. Tim Thomas, 2011 (33.2% on 246 shots)
4. Bill Ranford, 1990 (46.2% on 156 shots)
5. Mike Vernon, 1997 (53.4% on 108 shots)
6. Patrick Roy, 2001 (54.2% on 178 shots)
7. Jonathan Quick, 2012 (55.2% on 132 shots)
8. Corey Crawford, 2015 (58.0% on 161 shots)
9. Dominik Hasek, 1999 (58.3% on 198 shots)
10. Patrick Roy, 1993 (60.1% on 155 shots)

Top Round 1-3 Performances, 1968-2017
1. Jean-Sebastien Giguere, 2003 (39.6% on 496 shots)
2. John Davidson, 1979 (46.0% on 374 shots)
3. Rogie Vachon, 1969 (46.8% on 257 shots)
4. Richard Brodeur, 1982 (54.0% on 463 shots)
5. Patrick Roy, 1993 (54.3% on 492 shots)
6. Ilya Bryzgalov, 2006 (54.5% on 285 shots)
7. Tuukka Rask, 2013 (55.4% on 527 shots)
8. John Vanbiesbrouck, 1996 (55.6% on 616 shots)
9. Arturs Irbe, 2002 (56.5% on 319 shots)
10. Patrick Roy, 1986 (56.8% on 379 shots)

Top Round 2-4 Performances, 1980-2017
1. John Vanbiesbrouck, 1996 (52.1% on 558 shots)
2. Patrick Roy, 2001 (55.7% on 534 shots)
3. Tuukka Rask, 2013 (56.0% on 527 shots)
4. Patrick Roy, 1996 (57.2% on 493 shots)
5. Tim Thomas, 2011 (57.6% on 620 shots)
6. Arturs Irbe, 2002 (57.9% on 394 shots)
7. Pelle Lindbergh, 1985 (58.2% on 385 shots)
8. Patrick Roy, 1993 (60.1% on 444 shots)
9. Patrick Roy, 1986 (61.3% on 426 shots)
10. Kirk McLean, 1994 (62.1% on 598 shots)

Top Four-Round Performances, 1975-2017
1. Patrick Roy, 1993 (55.7% on 647 shots)
2. John Vanbiesbrouck, 1996 (58.8% on 735 shots)
3. John Davidson, 1979 (59.2% on 535 shots)
4. Jean-Sebastien Giguere, 2003 (59.3% on 697 shots)
5. Tuukka Rask, 2013 (59.4% on 761 shots)
6. Richard Brodeur, 1982 (60.4% on 594 shots)
7. Jonathan Quick, 2012 (60.4% on 538 shots)
8. Dominik Hasek, 1999 (60.7% on 587 shots)
9. Patrick Roy, 1986 (61.3% on 504 shots)
10. Patrick Roy, 2001 (62.6% on 622 shots)
​

Click to read more...

 

[Killion]

.... my God. What did I just see?

 

[quoipourquoi]

.... my God. What did I just see?

I should have included a picture of my cat Vanbootzbrouck this time!

 

[Killion]

^^^ Wouldve helped, been appreciated, anything to break it up. Beautiful work, job.... but Holy Moly... eyes, brain fried.

 

[Doctor No]

This is great - sorry I missed it the first time!

 

[MadLuke]

This look really great, is Roy the only one to appear more than once in those top list ?

Really show is playoff greatness, with 4 different year's appearing in there.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

In the top 10's, no Ken Dryden or Martin Brodeur? Is that correct?

 

[quoipourquoi]

In the top 10's, no Ken Dryden or Martin Brodeur? Is that correct?

Ken Dryden has the 3rd best EvE among three-round goaltenders in 1977 (essentially 1968-1979 finalists and 1980-2017 conference finalists). He only falls outside the top-10 when compared to goaltenders through three rounds.

Martin Brodeur falls just outside the top-10 categories for three-round (1994) and four-round (1995) goaltenders, as well as Stanley Cup Finals (2000).