Top 10 Post-Expansion Playoff Goalies of all Time #5

[blundluntman]

Pretty simple premise: Who are your top 10 playoff goaltenders of all time post-1967?

Rank	Player	% of Vote	Link to Poll Discussion
1	Patrick Roy	49/103 (47.6%)	Poll 1
2	Dominik Hasek	19/32 (59.4%)	Poll 2
3	Ken Dryden	48/121 (39.7%)	Poll 3
4	Martin Brodeur	40/72 (55.6%)	Poll 4

Also, as far as recommendations are concerned: I will now request posters to make a case (not an essay, just a couple of sentences) for the player they want to be added due to some dispute over previous selections. There are a lot of players that have been mentioned and I don't want to add too many all at once.

Click to read more...

 

[Dr Pepper]

Smith winning 4 Cups in a row with the Isles, that's gotta count for something, right?

Sure between him and Fuhr they weren't putting up god-tier numbers in those 80s Cup runs, at least not comparable with today's standards, but it was enough to get the win on some powerhouse teams.

 

[tarheelhockey]

To me it’s between Belfour and Esposito.

 

[Rebels57]

Bernie Parent won back to back Cups, Conn Smythes, and Vezinas. He was a better and more accomplished goalie than everyone left on this list.

 

[Voight]

Smith winning 4 Cups in a row with the Isles, that's gotta count for something, right?

Sure between him and Fuhr they weren't putting up god-tier numbers in those 80s Cup runs, at least not comparable with today's standards, but it was enough to get the win on some powerhouse teams.

He did win the Conn Smythe in 1983

 

[frisco]

Smith winning 4 Cups in a row with the Isles, that's gotta count for something, right?

Sure between him and Fuhr they weren't putting up god-tier numbers in those 80s Cup runs, at least not comparable with today's standards, but it was enough to get the win on some powerhouse teams.

He gets my vote. Smith was 88-36 with four Cups and a Smythe in the playoffs. He was a solid 31-23 in years the Islanders did NOT win the Cup.

My Best-Carey