Speculation: Top 10 Leafs scoring leaders for 2019-2020 - FINAL RESULTS

[Leafs1993]

Here are the results for the leading scorers this upcoming season based on your votes.

1. Auston Matthew (58.2% 124 votes)
2. Mitch Marner (63.5% 73 votes)
3. John Tavares (86.0% 49 votes)
4. William Nylander (73.2% 101 votes)
5. Morgan Rielly (59.2% 42 votes)
6. Tyson Barrie (79.2% 61 votes)
7. Andreas Johnsson (68.9% 82 votes)
8. Kasperi Kapanen (78.3% 36 votes)
9. Alex Kerfoot (65.7% 23 votes)
10. Zach Hyman (32.8% 21 votes TIE)
10. Jake Muzzin (32.8% 21 votes TIE)

Do you agree with this list?

Please feel free to post your top 10 point predictions here. I will bump this in April to see who was close.

Thanks to all who participated!

Click to read more...

 

[Leafs1993]

My top 10

1. Auston Matthews 95-100 points
2. Mitch Marner 90-95 points
3. William Nylander 80-85 points
4. John Tavares 80-85 points
5. Morgan Rielly 70-75 points
6. Tyson Barrie 60-65 points
7. Kasperi Kapanen 55-60 points
8. Andreas Johnsson 50-55 points
9. Alex Kerfoot 40-45 points
10. Jake Muzzin 35-40 points

 

[Leafs1993]

Also top 10 from previous season can be found here:

Speculation: - Top 10 leading scorers for 2018-2019 - Final Results

 

[Kamiccolo]

I think it will be very different. Matthews is unlikely to play a full season, and Marner will miss games due to hold out. IMO..

1. Tavares
2. Matthews
3. Nylander
4. Marner
5. Rielly
6. Johnsson
7. Barrie
8. Kapanen

Who knows after that

 

[MyBudJT]

Johnsson is too high. Other then that, not a bad list.

 

[mulefarm]

I think Barrie will have many more points than Reilly, especially if Barrie is on the first power play.

 

[Eye Test]

Matthews
Marner
Tavares
Nylander
Reilly
Barrie
Muzzin
Johnson
Kap
Hyman

 

[slozo]

Here are the results for the leading scorers this upcoming season based on your votes.

1. Auston Matthew (58.2% 124 votes)
2. Mitch Marner (63.5% 73 votes)
3. John Tavares (86.0% 49 votes)
4. William Nylander (73.2% 101 votes)
5. Morgan Rielly (59.2% 42 votes)
6. Tyson Barrie (79.2% 61 votes)
7. Andreas Johnsson (68.9% 82 votes)
8. Kasperi Kapanen (78.3% 36 votes)
9. Alex Kerfoot (65.7% 23 votes)
10. Zach Hyman (32.8% 21 votes TIE)
10. Jake Muzzin (32.8% 21 votes TIE)

Do you agree with this list?

Please feel free to post your top 10 point predictions here. I will bump this in April to see who was close.

Thanks to all who participated!

I'm still shocked at the overwhelming majority who keep voting for Matthews, who has come 2nd or 3rd to Marner each of their three years together. I would bet on history repeating itself over a new thing happening (not that Matthews couldn't lead of course, totally possible).

Also surprised that everyone sees flawless scoring curves upward for Johnsson and Kappy . . . again, it's possible, but I'm betting on at least 1 to falter or go through a rough stretch.

My prediction:
1. Mitch Marner - 100-110+
2. John Tavares - low 90s
3. Auston Matthews - low 90s
4. William Nylander - 70s
5. Morgan Rielly - 57 - 67
6. Tyson Barrie - 50 - low 60s
7. Zach Hyman - high 40s, maybe even 50ish
8. Kasperi Kapanen - 40s
9. Johnsson - 40s
10. Alex Kerfoot - 40s

 

[Havoc]

I'm still shocked at the overwhelming majority who keep voting for Matthews, who has come 2nd or 3rd to Marner each of their three years together. I would bet on history repeating itself over a new thing happening (not that Matthews couldn't lead of course, totally possible).

Also surprised that everyone sees flawless scoring curves upward for Johnsson and Kappy . . . again, it's possible, but I'm betting on at least 1 to falter or go through a rough stretch.

My prediction:
1. Mitch Marner - 100-110+
2. John Tavares - low 90s
3. Auston Matthews - low 90s
4. William Nylander - 70s
5. Morgan Rielly - 57 - 67
6. Tyson Barrie - 50 - low 60s
7. Zach Hyman - high 40s, maybe even 50ish
8. Kasperi Kapanen - 40s
9. Johnsson - 40s
10. Alex Kerfoot - 40s

Up to 3 players get points on goals. How does Marner have a 110 range but Tavares Matthews are low 90s with Nylander in 70s lol. Marner isn't putting up 41 like Kucherov so Tavares will need to score 60+ goals next season.

Must be his agent in disguise trying to get him that 12 mil contract.

 

[MattySnipes]

My 1. - 3. are different. 4. - 10. is the same minus Muzzin.

1. Marner
2. Tavares
3. Matthews

10. Hyman

 

[Boutette]

Overall a pretty conservative list.

 

[Duckrider]

I think it will be very different. Matthews is unlikely to play a full season, and Marner will miss games due to hold out. IMO..

1. Tavares
2. Matthews
3. Nylander
4. Marner
5. Rielly
6. Johnsson
7. Barrie
8. Kapanen

Who knows after that

Why would you think that? Last 5 seasons have not been complete.

 

[Kamiccolo]

Why would you think that? Last 5 seasons have not been complete.

I'm not sure what you mean. Did you quote the wrong post?

 

[Leafs at Knight]

I think it will be very different. Matthews is unlikely to play a full season, and Marner will miss games due to hold out. IMO..

1. Tavares
2. Matthews
3. Nylander
4. Marner
5. Rielly
6. Johnsson
7. Barrie
8. Kapanen

Who knows after that

Pretty dumb to make predictions on stuff that may or may not happen.

 

[ACC1224]

Marner
Matthews
Tavares

 

[Kamiccolo]

Pretty dumb to make predictions on stuff that may or may not happen.

Then why are you in a thread about the very topic?

 

[Leafs at Knight]

Then why are you in a thread about the very topic?

There's a difference with predicting the top 10 scorers - obviously predicting based on if their healthy vs. making up hypothetical situations to base a list off of.

 

[Kamiccolo]

There's a difference with predicting the top 10 scorers - obviously predicting based on if their healthy vs. making up hypothetical situations to base a list off of.

He hasn't played a full season in 2 years and it's unreasonable to think that could happen again? Or that, as reported, RFA's are planning to hold out and Dubas is making moves to prepare for it?

Or are you a Matthews fan being offended?

 

[Leafs at Knight]

He hasn't played a full season in 2 years and it's unreasonable to think that could happen again? Or that, as reported, RFA's are planning to hold out and Dubas is making moves to prepare for it?

Or are you a Matthews fan being offended?

The entire point of these lists is based off of every player being healthy. Of course injuries are going to happen, but just randomly guessing what you might think will happen and then making a list is just dumb. The Marner situation has been beaten to death, there's just a good of a chance if not better that he's playing game 1 vs. sitting out.

And lol why would I be offended; the crap you posted is what the mainboard trolls use against Matthews - he could very well be healthy for the full year.

 

[Leafs1993]

He hasn't played a full season in 2 years and it's unreasonable to think that could happen again? Or that, as reported, RFA's are planning to hold out and Dubas is making moves to prepare for it?

Or are you a Matthews fan being offended?

As I stated in every thread, these predictions are based off no significant roster changes and Mitch Marner resigning

 

[slozo]

The entire point of these lists is based off of every player being healthy. Of course injuries are going to happen, but just randomly guessing what you might think will happen and then making a list is just dumb. The Marner situation has been beaten to death, there's just a good of a chance if not better that he's playing game 1 vs. sitting out.

And lol why would I be offended; the crap you posted is what the mainboard trolls use against Matthews - he could very well be healthy for the full year.

It is definitely not stupid to predict a player won't play a full 82 games, when in the last 2 seasons the player lost significant time.

 

[slozo]

Up to 3 players get points on goals. How does Marner have a 110 range but Tavares Matthews are low 90s with Nylander in 70s lol. Marner isn't putting up 41 like Kucherov so Tavares will need to score 60+ goals next season.

Must be his agent in disguise trying to get him that 12 mil contract.

I'm predicting that both Tavares and Matthews miss some time. And Marner's a beast. That's how.

 

[hockeynorth]

1. Matthews 100+
2. Marner 90+
3. Nylander low 80s
4. Tavares low 80s
5. Barrie mid 60s
6. Rielly low 60s
7. Johnsson high 50s
8. Kapanen low 50s
9. Mikheyev high 40s
10. Kerfoot low 40s