Proposal: Toews to Boston

Status
Not open for further replies.

HIROJIMA

Registered User
Feb 8, 2009
121
28
Sup dudes, was just talking to my hockey buddies about a trade proposal that would land Jonathan Toews in Boston. We did not think of the financials or anything, so I'm sorry if the cap hits don't make sense and don't add all up.

My thinking here is that the Bruins are in dire need of a Center, specifically one who is good at faceoffs and shows great leadership. Boston unfortunately was unable to get over the hump in game 7 and it may have had something to do with their Center's. Toews has absolutely been the image of the Blackhawks, especially winning those 3 Stanley Cups with his pals Kaner, Seabrooksy, and Duncker.

The offer:

BOS sends:

Charlie McAvoy
Brandon Carlo
2nd round pick in 2022
5th round pick in 2021
David Pastrnak

CHI sends:

Jonathan Toews
Erik Gustafsson
Brent Seabrook
Olli Maata
7th rounder in 2021

The Breakdown:

Boston will be sending troubled young defensemen Charlie McAvoy as part of this deal, as he has yet to find his footing in the NHL, who hasn't really shown much "wow" in this time in the NHL. In return, they would be acquiring an upgrade in Gustafsson, who has quietly been Chicago's tank on the backend and PP specialist (99 career points in 181 games, better than half a point per game). Toews is going to add that 1-2 punch with Bergeron, slotting down Krejci to 3C, and either moving Coyle to wing or as the 4C. Maata is a great depth defensemen who was a key piece on the blueline for the Penguins in their cup run recently. Pastrnak would help fill a need for the Hawks, acquiring a young forward with much promise, with the possibility of chipping in 25-30 goals a season to go along with Debrincat and Kane. I also feel that Carlo-Seabrook is a pretty comparable swap, with BOS getting the experience once again of an elite defensemen and championship prowess.

I felt that Kirby Dach going to BOS would have also added a nice element to this, but i thought BOS would laugh at the asking price from CHI's end, as Dach was just drafted in the top10 in last year's draft.

I know what you're thinking, why would Chicago want to part with all of its core, essentially leaving Kane on an island by himself with fellow cup champion Saad? CHI is clearly on the downhill here and definitely needs to rebuild. BOS needs to think big picture. True Stanley cups are won down the middle (ask the LA Kings, St. Louis Blues, Penguins), what bigger piece than Top100 player of all-time Johnny Toews?

Please let me know your thoughts, i think Toews to BOS is the trade offer that no one's thought about and it really irks me.
 

BruinsPortugal

Registered User
Dec 3, 2009
5,045
1,680
Portugal
michael-jordan-laugh.gif
 

bearcountry17

Registered User
Jun 4, 2012
3,251
1,893
South Shore, MA
Posting GIF's instead of actual replies? Cool.

Ok. This is the worst proposal I have ever seen on here and that’s saying something.

Seabrook would need multiple firsts going along with him for a team to take that contract, Toews with that contract barely has any value outside Chicago.
Gustavsson is a nice player but irrelevant in Boston with Krug. Mattaa is meh.

so all that plus a sweet 7th round pick gets you

One of the best RWs in the game at only 23 years old on a bargain contract

A 21 year old right handed #1 dman on a bargain contract

A 22 year old right handed #3 dman on a bargain contract

A second and a fifth round pick.

Honestly you should just say it was for a goof and save yourself from any more embarrassment.
 
Last edited:

BostonBob

4 Ever The Greatest
Jan 26, 2004
13,783
6,821
Vancouver, BC
Sup dudes, was just talking to my hockey buddies about a trade proposal that would land Jonathan Toews in Boston. We did not think of the financials or anything, so I'm sorry if the cap hits don't make sense and don't add all up.


The offer:

BOS sends:

Charlie McAvoy
Brandon Carlo
2nd round pick in 2022
5th round pick in 2021
David Pastrnak

CHI sends:

Jonathan Toews
Erik Gustafsson
Brent Seabrook
Olli Maata
7th rounder in 2021

- I wouldn't trade McAvoy alone for this package
- I wouldn't trade Carlo alone for this package
- I wouldn't trade a 2nd round pick and a 5th round pick for this package
- I sure as hell wouldn't trade Pastrnak alone for this package

You are right about one thing though - you and your " buddies " certainly did not think about anything before coming up with this joke of a trade proposal. Can we please enforce a lifetime ban for this poster.....or at least a lifetime ban from making anymore trade proposals. :shakehead
 

BruinsFan37

Registered User
Jun 26, 2015
1,604
1,728
This is not even a remotely fair trade. Boston's future for Chicago's aging core + less talented players. Pasta alone is worth most of that package, nevermind McAvoy, nevermind Carlo, nevermind the draft picks. But what the hell I'll play along for fun...

Would need at least 50% retention on Towes and Seabrook;
I'll give you no retention on Gustafsson or Maata; and
You can keep the 2nd and 5th round picks and give Boston the 1st round picks for the next three years instead.

Do that, I'd think about it for what your're asking... maybe. Still likely turn it down though.

But since we're talking such a ridiculous trade lets go for broke...

You need to take Backes (no retention) and send Boston DeBrincat. Do that and you can keep one of your three 1st round picks...

e1feea2df73447797ac9ebf37b09848a.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: HabsWhiteKnightLOL

Canucks1096

Registered User
Feb 13, 2016
5,608
1,667
Toews at 10.5 has very little value.

Bergeron Krejci Coyle is pretty deep at center. Don't think Toews is much of an upgrade or even an upgrade on Krejci at this point in his career

Seabrook has Negative Value, you need add a valuable asset to get rid of that contract

I don't think you realize how good Pastrnak is.

Not sure what Bos cap situation is but they are adding a lot of cap. Not sure if they can afford adding so much salary.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HabsWhiteKnightLOL

Hitemwith4

Registered User
Jul 1, 2019
547
357
Shut this down quick

Boston's gm would have to be high as shit to accept this deal WOW this is bad for Boston like horribly bad like god dam bad

Shut it down !
 
  • Like
Reactions: HabsWhiteKnightLOL

ChiTownPhilly

Not Too Soft
Feb 23, 2010
2,105
1,391
AnyWorld/I'mWelcomeTo
Chicago fan here... relieved to discover that OP lists self as Florida Panthers fan- which saves us the trouble of having to perform ostracism/disfellowship/shunning rites. Whew!:phew:

We know that current Toews is a negative asset. Current Seabrook is a candidate for the NHL's most negative asset. Yeah- even if this is a wind-up, it's a really weak, unfunny joke.
 

Section88

Kaner? I hardly know her
Jul 11, 2017
5,599
4,833
Toews and seabrook going their way with pastrnak and mcavoy coming our way. Never thought id see something like that
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad