Toews, Kane, Saad, Debrincat vs Getzlaf, Perry, Rakell, Henrique

[Rolo]

Which quintet would you take for now and the future?

Click to read more...

 

[StatisticsAddict99]

Blackhawks, AINEC.

 

[rent free]

chicago

 

[MMC]

Getzlaf > Toews
Kane > Perry
Henrique = Saad
Rakell > Debrincat

Will take Ducks for now

 

[Binister]

Surprised about the lopsided result

Getzlaf >> Toews
Kane >> Perry
Henrique = Saad
Rakell >> DeBrincat

 

[tony d]

Ducks. Yeah, the lopsided result is surprising.

 

[olli]

Getzlaf>Toews
Kane>>Perry
Henrique>Saad
Rakell>Debrincat
It's close. Once you factor in cap hits I'll take the ducks.

 

[bsu]

The results! lol!

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Getzlaf~Kane
Rakell>>Toews
Debrincat>Henrique
Saad>Perry

Super tough. I think without contracts I’ll take Hawks, with I’ll take Ducks. Voted Ducks.

 

[Rolo]

Getzlaf~Kane
Rakell>>Toews
Debrincat>Henrique
Saad>Perry

Super tough. I think without contracts I’ll take Hawks, with I’ll take Ducks. Voted Ducks.

Interesting way to compare it, but you need to do it by position IMO.

C - Getzlaf / Toews
RW - Perry / Kane
LW - Debrincat, Saad / Henrique, Rakell

*plenty aware Henrique also plays C, and Rakell can as well.

 

[Kaners Bald Spot]

Everyone is forgetting about Nick Schmaltz, who is following the career trajectory of Scheifele, and who I believe will explode next year.

 

[bsu]

Everyone is forgetting about Nick Schmaltz, who is following the career trajectory of Scheifele, and who I believe will explode next year.

What does he have to do with this poll? Should we mention the Ducks young defensemen and goalie as well?

 

[Regal]

It seems pretty clearly in the Blackhawks favour here. Kane is the best player here, even with a down season, and is 4 years younger than the Ducks best player, Getzlaf. Rakell and DeBrincat are both good young wingers. Rakell is more proven, but is also closer to his prime being 24 compared to 20, and gets to play with Getzlaf, whereas DeBrincat didn't get to play much with Kane. I would take Rakell, but overall a Kane- DeBrincat pairing is probanly slightly more valuable than a Getzlaf-Rakell pairing due to age and having the best player. Then you have Toews-Saad, which is way better than Henrique-Perry. For all the crap Toews gets, his worst year offensively is still better than Henrique's best, and he's still a good possession and defensive player and better than Henrique there, while only being 2 years older. And while Saad had a poor year, he's shown he's consistently been a high end ES producer and possession player and should bounce back next year. Both he and Toews shot career low percentages and that line should be much more productive next year. Meanwhile, Perry is 8 years older and had been regressing hard the last two seasons.

 

[The Moose is Loose]

Getzlaf > Toews
Kane > Perry
Henrique = Saad
Rakell > Debrincat

Will take Ducks for now

Lol. There should be about 5 >>> between Perry and Kane. Also Id take Saad easily over Henrique.

Chicago easily