Three Hall of Famers there, and Hatcher is in the US HoF (not the HHoF in Toronto). How the f*** did that team not win a single Cup?
No elite offensive players and a stacked Pens team imo. We had Gartner, Gustaffson, Ridley, Pivonka, Miller, Hunter, Ciccarelli then Bondra and Kristich (and Im forgetting a few more) but we never had a truly elite offensive player.
Gartner and Gustaffson were the closest we had to true elite playmakers. The others were great players but relied on the play and teammates, they couldnt single handidly take over games or shifts and make things happen.
Penguins with Lemiuex, Stevens, Jagr, Francis etc just skated circles around our lunch pale guys.
We won a ton of regular season games but come playoffs, we just couldnt get out of the first or second round. Ever. One year we made it to the conf finals and Andy Moog stood on his head and shut us down. I think 4-1 or even 4-0.
That was life as a Caps fan. Lots of free jerrys pizza and regular season wins ... but alergic to the playoffs.