I do agree on trading Backstrom, he should be able to fetch something very valuable.
But what if we sweetened the deal by adding Carlson into the mix. Yes I think we should keep Green, much more poised and focused, he's entering his prime defensively and his offense will be there for the foreseeable future
Carlson can be replaced by one of our upcoming D prospects Bowey, Orlov,...) and has tremendous value for the actual player that he is
Backstrom + Carlson to Edmonton. No point in trying to get McDavid, the pick will not be traded, but I think we can can manage to snatch a Center/Winger combination of Hall, Nugent-Hopkins, Yakupov or Draisatl.
Kuz can take over 1C duty, he's really been a revelation during the Playoffs and the rest of the top 6 can be filled in by the Edmonton players whom while likely less talented than Backy still have the necessary skills to produce. But they also bring the youth and the GRIT indispensable to perform in the playoffs. With the exception of the NYI series where Backy started shooting more, he was mostly ineffective against the rangers which killed Ovi's influence on that series. The two best lines against the rangers were by far the Kuz and Beagles lines that were able to create chances with much less skill but a lot more grit and that's what our top 6 needs some more.
I can see Edmonton being interested in such deal as they are clearly lacking in the D and leadership department and would certainly have interest in acquiring guys like Carlson and Backstrom to complement their young roster with more maturity and experience.
It is a huge move but you have to change the look and feel of your team. The Rangers' roster is much more grit inclined than skill, to the point where you'd be hard pressed to find caps fans that would swap their roster for our roster....yet they win much more than we do.
Okay, there's a lot of things I disagree with here.
First, the Carlson vs Green comparison. You already know what I think about it, I told you in the other thread.
Now, we don't even know when Orlov will be ready to come back with us full time, but it won't be on the first pairing. Bowey is very young, he's at least 1 or 2 years away from the NHL.
If you want to trade Backstrom and Carlson, don't go get the busts from Edmonton. Yakupov is a huge disappointment, Draisaitl can barely skate at the NHL level, RNH is decent but a lot worse than Backstrom, Hall is decent too but would be stuck behind Ovi in the depth chart. If you want to get a player from Edmonton, go get McDavid. I don't advocate such a move, but this is the player I'd be looking for if trading Backstrom + Carlson.
Those Oilers kids have gone through the worst development in the NHL, have no experience in the playoffs and no other experience than losing in the regular season. I don't know why you want players like that.
Our top 6 doesn't need more grit. We already have grinders like Ward, Chimera or Brouwer getting top 6 minutes. If anything, it needs a true secondary scoring threat. It looks like it will be the Kuzya + Bura combo that will provide us the secondary scoring.
Now is not the time to retool. We need to keep acquiring assets to make a Cup run in the next 3 years.
We will retool when Ovi turns 35.