saywut
Registered User
- Jun 11, 2009
- 2,536
- 91
It's this really sweet thing called rebound control.
When Backstrom is on his game, it's fine. When he's not, it isn't just costing a goal, it's costing games.
This last game was the first time all season that I wasn't cringing every time there was ANY sort of offensive pressure. Backstrom just isn't as good as the team made him in the past, we aren't clearing those terrible rebounds like we used to, and Backstrom can't control them as well as he used to.
Deflection? Likely goal against. Any shot to the blocker side? GOLDEN scoring chance on a bad rebound. Glove high? He loses his mind, and ends up on his ass and out of position. Shot from the point? Juicy rebound that the team isn't making up for anymore. Any sort of cross-ice passing? He always over commits on the first shot, so is NEVER in position for a pass vs. a shot.
These issues just don't occur with Harding, because his athleticism usually gets him out of trouble with whatever positioning deficiencies he has.
We don't have the team defense that we did in years past. Which means we need a goalie who doesn't require full team defense like we had in years past. Backstrom requires that, more than almost any other starter in the NHL that I've seen recently.
If Harding's so much better than Backstrom, how come his record is so much worse over the same period on the same team? Backstrom's 164-113-43, Harding's 42-52-8. Average those records over 82 games and the difference is 21 points, or the difference between 8th and 14th in the west last season(95/74). Harding's been a below 50% goalie in 3 of the 4 seasons he's played 10 games, Backstrom's been below 50% just once(the season Harding didn't play, so its safe to assume Harding would be 4/5 seasons below 50% as a back-up had he played).
But I'm sure everyone will jump to the Detroit law and whatnot to say Harding's had to play the 2nd of back to backs against all the good teams and that's why his numbers aren't as good. If Backstrom's playing 50+ a year he's facing tough opponents too. If the team's playing better in front of him, there's a reason for that too.