Proposal: TB - NYR - OTT

[Hotlanta]

TB: Erik Karlsson

NYR: Bobby Ryan + TB's 1st/2nd (whatever they don't get in the McDonagh trade) + Anthony Cirelli

OTT: Cal Foote + Ryan Callahan

TB Reasoning: Give up a good center prospect who won't crack the top 6, and your blue chip D prospect thats not NHL ready for the best defensemen in the league and dumping Callahan's contract without disrespecting him by trading him + pick for nothing.

NYR Reasoning: Bobby Ryan isn't what he used to be, but he is a serviceable top 6 forward on a rebuilding team. Maybe he can be flipped at the deadline if NYR retains 50% and he plays well. NYR probably won't be worried about the cap over the net 4 years so this shouldn't be to hard of a pill to swallow, when they get an NHL ready center prospect and a high pick as compensation.

OTT Reasoning: A blue chip D prospect to "replace" your star and Callahan is $20.6 million dollars cheaper than Ryan and will be a good dressing room guy.

Issue: Would Callahan block a trade to Ottawa and be okay being a 4th line player on a cup contender? Would Yzerman buy him out otherwise to force his hand?

I am a Leafs fan, so this trade is not meant to be biased for anyone. In fact, I pray Karlsson doesn't end up in TB.

Click to read more...

 

[Byzantium]

"A blue chip D prospect to "replace" your star" HfBoards in a nut shell

 

[Hotlanta]

Nothing

 

[Toby Flenderson]

Not enough for Karlsson.

Sergachev+Killorn+1st for Karlsson

Leave NYR and Ryan out of it.

 

[Kaapo Takko]

Not nearly enough from Tampa to Ottawa. Add Sergachev and a 1st.

 

[Bluto]

to OTT: Sergachev, ADA and Foote
To NYR Ryan, Tkachuk, Callahan, Whichever pick NYR doesn't get from McD trade
To Tampa: EK

 

[Clamshells]

to OTT: Sergachev, ADA and Foote
To NYR Ryan, Tkachuk, Callahan, Whichever pick NYR doesn't get from McD trade
To Tampa: EK

Brutal

 

[treple13]

That is really really bad to Ottawa

 

[Wallet Inspector]

Foote+Callahan for Karlsson and Ryan

...............

I have no words.

 

[Korpse]

Let's just erase the entire existence of the NHL.

 

[Korpse]

to OTT: Sergachev, ADA and Foote
To NYR Ryan, Tkachuk, Callahan, Whichever pick NYR doesn't get from McD trade
To Tampa: EK

When you think it can't get any worse...

 

[780il]

Tampa is making out like bandits. Start with Sergachev and add futures from there.

 

[CupsOverCash]

I think any team that gets involved does a stand a lone trade with TB. Unless they want to take Ryan too. This could get crazy lol.

 

[Lays]

Terrible for the Rangers. I like Cirelli but why do we need a LHS C who projects as middle 6? We have Zib/Hayes/Chytil/Andersson/Howden..not taking on Ryan for just that return

 

[Lays]

to OTT: Sergachev, ADA and Foote
To NYR Ryan, Tkachuk, Callahan, Whichever pick NYR doesn't get from McD trade
To Tampa: EK

Easy yes from the Rangers although I really don’t want Cally back here and i doubt he wants to be back here, doesn’t he have a NMC?

 

[branch]

Holy f*** this so so so sooooo bad. Lock this thread.

You should be ashamed.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Done no takebacks

 

[Hotlanta]

Maybe my leafs bias against OTT plus all the media saying OTT will get peanuts for Karlsson + Ryan has skewed my perception of the situation. It sounds like this is what it takes to make OTT and NYR happy and I don't see it as something TB touches.

TB: Erik Karlsson

NYR: Bobby Ryan + Cal Foote

OTT: Mikhail Sergachev + Anthony Cirelli or 2nd Round pick + Ryan Callahan

OR

TB: Erik Karlsson
OTT: Mikhail Sergachev + Cal Foote + Anthony Cirelli or 2nd Round pick + Ryan Callahan

But I doubt Ottawa pays for Callahan and keeps Ryan.

 

[Meeqs]

Look Ott is going to get fleeced in this deal, but not THAT fleeced

 

[Faltorvo]

TB: Erik Karlsson

NYR: Bobby Ryan + TB's 1st/2nd (whatever they don't get in the McDonagh trade) + Anthony Cirelli

OTT: Cal Foote + Ryan Callahan

TB Reasoning: Give up a good center prospect who won't crack the top 6, and your blue chip D prospect thats not NHL ready for the best defensemen in the league and dumping Callahan's contract without disrespecting him by trading him + pick for nothing.

NYR Reasoning: Bobby Ryan isn't what he used to be, but he is a serviceable top 6 forward on a rebuilding team. Maybe he can be flipped at the deadline if NYR retains 50% and he plays well. NYR probably won't be worried about the cap over the net 4 years so this shouldn't be to hard of a pill to swallow, when they get an NHL ready center prospect and a high pick as compensation.

OTT Reasoning: A blue chip D prospect to "replace" your star and Callahan is $20.6 million dollars cheaper than Ryan and will be a good dressing room guy.

Issue: Would Callahan block a trade to Ottawa and be okay being a 4th line player on a cup contender? Would Yzerman buy him out otherwise to force his hand?

I am a Leafs fan, so this trade is not meant to be biased for anyone. In fact, I pray Karlsson doesn't end up in TB.

waittt so cal foot and your 1rst gets you erik effening karlsson and you move 2 huge cap dumps???

is this reality here?

 

[Faltorvo]

waittt so cal foot and your 1rst(#31) gets you erik effening karlsson and you move 2 huge cap dumps??? you do realize your 1rst holds the same value as Montreal 2nd?

is this reality here?

 

[Hotlanta]

waittt so cal foot and your 1rst gets you erik effening karlsson and you move 2 huge cap dumps???

is this reality here?

Well OTT gets one of those cap dumps so thats a positive to them and Cirelli is probably worth a late 1st/early 2nd. But yeah I guess I was way way off.

 

[danielpalfredsson]

 

[5cotland]

Alex Killorn, 2020 1st (Tampa), 2019 7th (NYR), Boris Katchouk and Alexander Volkov

Bobby Ryan (30% retain), Ryan Callahan, 2019 4th (Tampa), 2019 4th (Ottawa)

Erik Karlsson, 2019 6th (Ottawa) and Ryan Gropp

 

[BigCanadian]

You are bad people here with your bad offers... For shame!