Proposal: Taylor Hall to Chicago

[Kevin Musto]

To Chicago:

-Taylor Hall

To New Jersey:

-Erik Gustafsson
-Andrew Shaw
-2020 1st
-Chad Krys

Click to read more...

 

[Baksfamous112]

This is going to be a great thread. Following

 

[Jerzey Devil]

Boqvist + 1st

 

[HOPE]

that would be value for a unsigned Hall, the team that will acquire him will most likely be with an extension.

 

[Kevin Musto]

that would be value for a unsigned Hall

Precisely.

 

[Fire Stan Bowman]

so we could afford hall but not panarin? ok stan okayyyy

 

[Baksfamous112]

Boqvist + 1st

Overpayment even for a signed Hall in my opinion. You could get a first or Boqvist but not both.

 

[DarthProbert]

Hawks are 3 pts above NJ in the standings but are buying high end UFAs to be at the expense of 1st rd picks while NJ are selling. Makes sense.

Chicago's 1st is a decent asset but the rest is of little value to NJ.

Neither team does this.

 

[Jerzey Devil]

Overpayment even for a signed Hall in my opinion. You could get a first or Boqvist but not both.

We’ll see. Neither my opinion nor your opinion really matter. Only what a GM feels like he needs to do. A fan base might not be happy afterwards but it is what it is.

 

[Mrfenn92]

No need for the hawks to trade for hall.

 

[JoemAvs]

that would be value for a unsigned Hall, the team that will acquire him will most likely be with an extension.

And why would Dan Ferris and Taylor Hall agree to that?

I am not saying that it is impossible that Hall goes in a Stone, Pacioretty kind of deal which certainly would improve the return but IMO that is not the likelier scenario. Which is that Hall gets traded as a rental for rental value and picks his next team on July 1st.

Also IMO that is too much for even a signed Hall given that the Blackhawks are far from a lock to make the playoffs...

 

[BK]

Not a chance I give up Boqvist and a 1st for Hall. Boqvist is crucial to the Hawks future.

 

[CatchyTune]

I just dont see this being worthwhile for the devils. If they sell Hall it should be for young pieces/picks, not another pending ufa and a bottom 6 vet. The 1st is nice though

 

[HawkeyTalkMan]

Devils are not getting a 1st AND a blue Chip prospect for Hall unsigned, we can all level set on that right?

 

[Taylorst]

Taylor hall isn't worth giving up a 1st round pick or any young asset .
Chicago will probably end up at the bottom of the league again and has no cap space either to offer hall to extend him.

Chicago needs to come to a Jesus moment and realize toews, Keith, Seabrook are all washed up.

Fire Stan and JC bring in a GM who has a proven track record and no emotional ties to this core and off load these guys and rebuild the team.

 

[Kaners Bald Spot]

With Keith injured, you can close this up. Hawks are tanking now.

 

[Toews2Bickell]

Not a chance I give up Boqvist and a 1st for Hall. Boqvist is crucial to the Hawks future.

So is the 2020 1st if the wheels fall off this year. Hawks can't afford to move that 1st for an rental.

 

[Forge]

Devils are not getting a 1st AND a blue Chip prospect for Hall unsigned, we can all level set on that right?

I think that they can get a first and a solid B to B+ level prospect for a rental Hall. Would agree that they are not going to get a first + a blue chip A level prospect though.

 

[HawkeyTalkMan]

I think that they can get a first and a solid B to B+ level prospect for a rental Hall. Would agree that they are not going to get a first + a blue chip A level prospect though.

Depends on which teams first we are talking. It's not going to be someone like Chicago who will be a bubble mid round first pick AND a B prospect of it happens. It would likely be a cup contender and a B if it happens. So like 28-31 OA and a B

Not getting a 10-18th OA pick and B prospect

 

[RememberTheRoar]

so we could afford hall but not panarin? ok stan okayyyy

Stan didn’t propose this, @Kevin Musto did.

This deal is for a rental of Hall at $6 million, this isn’t an outright multi-year signing for ~$12 million.

 

[Kevin Musto]

Stan didn’t propose this, @Kevin Musto did.

What's the difference?

 

[elitepete]

Overpayment even for a signed Hall in my opinion. You could get a first or Boqvist but not both.

Disagree. Boqvist is overrated.

 

[Alberta_OReilly_Fan]

To Chicago:

-Taylor Hall

To New Jersey:

-Erik Gustafsson
-Andrew Shaw
-2020 1st
-Chad Krys

if thats a non lottery protected first it feels like about the best offer jersey might get... I think you are ballpark. I want hall on my bruins but im not sure I would want to beat that offer

 

[SotasicA]

Gustafsson yes for sure. But the Hawks can't give up their 1st because what would be the point of owning the draft lottery good luck talisman without a freaking lottery pick?!

Gustafsson + Saad + prospect for Taylor Hall.

 

[crazyhawk]

Disagree. Boqvist is overrated.

Yeah and one can make this call at this point in his young career.
And to the OP .. Musto Musto Musto .. why why why would we want Taylor Hall? As a rental to a team that is bubble at best? To resign at what crazy cap hit? No let's stay the course and get another high pick and rebuild the natural way.