Starting 5 prospects who do you pick

[FlamesFan18]

Pelletier - Zary - Francis

HM: Phillips, Gawdin, and Ruzicka

Mackey - Poirier

HM: Kuznetsov and Kinvall

Wolf

 

[yogibear]

my son goes with:
Raymond Zegras Byfield
Sanderson Seider

 

[TheKingSlayer]

Boldy - Byfield - Reichel
Harley - Seider
Jesper Wallstedt

Smart and heavy line with two smart d-men on the back with size and skating. The best goalie prospect since Carey Price between the pipes. Looks like a great top 5 for me. Certainly not the best 5 prospects, but makes for an excellent foundation to build around.

 

[SelltheTeamFrancesco]

Podkolzin-Byfield-Zegras

Seider-Drysdale

Knights

 

[Sasha Orlov]

Michkov - Bedard - Caufield
Seider - Drysdale

 

[Techcoockie]

Seider is #1 on that same list... Just won best defenseman in the SHL

Yet Norlinder destroyed him in the playoff

 

[Nico Cauzuki]

Zegras - Byfield - Caufield
Sanderson - Seider
Knight

HM : Drysdale & Raymond

 

[Copenhagen91]

Yet Norlinder destroyed him in the playoff

Good argument

 

[dekelikekocur]

Yet Norlinder destroyed him in the playoff

Define "Destroyed"

Norlinder had 7 games, 6 blocked shots, 1 hit 5 points.

Sure, had same amount of points but Seider isn't an offensive defensemen, who btw racked up 25 hits 18 blocked shots and played 13 games while being a full year younger.

So in not quite twice as many games had 3 times as many blocked shots, 25x more hits.

I'd say Seider did more for his team's success than Norlinder...

 

[Spilot23]

Yet Norlinder destroyed him in the playoff

Norlinder > Seider confirmed just like Scheifele > McDavid

 

[Techcoockie]

Define "Destroyed"

Norlinder had 7 games, 6 blocked shots, 1 hit 5 points.

Sure, had same amount of points but Seider isn't an offensive defensemen, who btw racked up 25 hits 18 blocked shots and played 13 games while being a full year younger.

So in not quite twice as many games had 3 times as many blocked shots, 25x more hits.

I'd say Seider did more for his team's success than Norlinder...

Yet you forgot that Seider did not produce in playoff compared to Norlinder, let's normalize the stats first.

Seider: 13gp, 1g-4a-5P
Norlinder: 7gp, 3g-2a-5P

so, let's put those at 13-14gp.

Seider in 13gp has 1 goal, 4 assists and 5p, 18blocked shots
Norlinder in 13gp would have 6 goals, 4 assists and 12 blocked shots.

So, 1 goal vs 6 goals for a Defenseman is ENROMOUS and Norlinder brings an offensive game that Seider doesn't have.

you see it with montreal where the D produced ZERO POINT in the current playoff that you need offensive minded D before stacking big guys. so who is the best player I'm wondering ?

 

[Techcoockie]

Norlinder > Seider confirmed just like Scheifele > McDavid

For Playoff performances I would take Sheifele and Mckin before Mcdavid to be frank, regular season no though.

 

[dekelikekocur]

Yet you forgot that Seider did not produce in playoff compared to Norlinder, let's normalize the stats first.

Seider: 13gp, 1g-4a-5P
Norlinder: 7gp, 3g-2a-5P

so, let's put those at 13-14gp.

Seider in 13gp has 1 goal, 4 assists and 5p, 18blocked shots
Norlinder in 13gp would have 6 goals, 4 assists and 12 blocked shots.

So, 1 goal vs 6 goals for a Defenseman is ENROMOUS and Norlinder brings an offensive game that Seider doesn't have.

you see it with montreal where the D produced ZERO POINT in the current playoff that you need offensive minded D before stacking big guys. so who is the best player I'm wondering ?

If Norlinder was a better defensemen, you wouldn't have to make up imaginary numbers to account for his short amount of games played.

 

[Techcoockie]

If Norlinder was a better defensemen, you wouldn't have to make up imaginary numbers to account for his short amount of games played.

we keep ratio it to 7gp if you want, or does it break your logic that Norlinder is trash ?

 

[dekelikekocur]

we keep ratio it to 7gp if you want, or does it break your logic that Norlinder is trash ?

Who's team went further and who played the greater contribution to the team success?

There is no break in the logic. You're trying to adjust things to compensate for an inferior player to create a comparison. When the only comparison is already established and clearly Seider is the better player.

Now run along and root for the habs, I hear they're gonna start challenging the leafs to a longest drought competition.

 

[Golden_Jet]

Zegras Pinto Caufield
Seider Sanderson
Knight

 

[frisco]

Byfield-Holtz-Raymond
Drysdale-Sanderson
Knight

My Best-Carey