MXD
Original #4
- Oct 27, 2005
- 50,846
- 16,591
WARNING : This is a work in progress
. I'll add years on a consistent basis -- I'll just have to "save" my progress here and there. Feel free to comment/add thoughts/flame.
Here is a list of the Cup winners + Finalists, with all their HHOF'ers, hopefuls, likely, locks, should be.
Legend
Hall of Famer
Lock
Likely
Hopefuls
Guy that is better than some guy in, but probably won't get in (for olders) OR Shot in the dark
The "too early to call" guys are ommited. Think Toews, Keith.
The (editorial comments) will probably be deleted once the work is finished - I'm just explaining my position on some debatable classifications.
2009-10
Winner -- Chicago Blackhawks : Hossa
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Pronger
2008-09
Winner -- Pittsburgh Penguins : Crosby, Gonchar, Malkin, Guerin
Finalist -- Detroit Red Wings : Lidstrom, Chelios, Zetterberg, Hossa, Datsyuk, Osgood
2007-08
Winner -- Detroit Red Wings : Hasek, Lidstrom, Chelios, Zetterberg, Datsyuk, Osgood
Finalists -- Pittsburgh Penguins : Crosby, Hossa, Gonchar, Malkin, Roberts
2006-07
Winner -- Anaheim Ducks : Pronger, S. Niedermayer, Selanne (I THINK he's a lock, some might disagree, Giguere (he HAS to add, but he's a guy that, at this point, has a shot to make it).
Finalist -- Ottawa Senators : Alfredsson, Heatley
2005-06
Winner -- Carolina Hurricanes : Recchi, Brind'Amour, Staal (borderline too early, but his the face of his franchise, played some international hockey...),Weight ,C.Ward (see Staal)
Finalist -- Edmonton Oilers : Pronger, Smyth. (For the record, I think Peca has absolutely no chance to get in).
2003-04
Winner -- Tampa Bay : St-Louis, Andreychuck, B. Richards, Lecavalier.
Finalist -- Calgary Flames : Iginla, Kiprusoff
2002-03
Winner -- New Jersey Devils : S. Stevens, S. Niedermayer, M. Brodeur, Nieuwendyk (just too important on many Cup winners, wouldn't consider him an absolutely lock though), Elias
Finalist -- Anaheim Ducks : Oates, Kariya, Giguere (again -- he HAS to add, but doesn't have to add much. He'd be the worst goalie in the Hall if he got in, but has great postseason credentials)
2001-02
Winner -- Detroit Red Wings : Yzerman, Robitaille, Larionov, Hull, Hasek, Lidstrom, Chelios, Fedorov, Shanahan (barring a major brainfart from the committee, Shanahan seems a lock), Datsyuk
Finalist -- Carolina Hurricanes : Francis, Brind'Amour
2000-01
Winner -- Colorado Avanlanche : Roy, Bourque, Sakic, Forsberg, R. Blake (that was a really close call between a likely and a hopeful. Certainly not a lock), Foote (a TRUE shot in the dark, but was on many winning teams).
Finalist -- New Jersey Devils : Stevens, Niedermayer, Brodeur, Mogilny (I think he has a better shot than Elias, but he has to hope. Being short of the 1000 games and the 500 goals mark by so little doesn't help him. In a non-cap world, he reaches 1000/500, and gets much more consideration). , Elias (sorry Jason Arnott)
1999-00
Winner -- New Jersey Devils : Stevens, Niedermayer, Brodeur, Mogilny, Elias
Finalist -- Dallas Stars : Hull, Belfour (some MIGHT not see him as a lock, but the guy was the clear fourth best of his era -- and the guys above him are IMO in the Top-6 goalies of all-time. Should be considered a lock to everyone), Modano (the "face of the franchise" argument), Nieuwendyk, Carbonneau (his name has been mentionned, and while last year was probably his best shot, I won't rule him out yet), Zubov,
1998-99
Winner -- Dallas Stars : Hull, Belfour, Modano , Nieuwendyk, Carbonneau, Zubov, Verbeek (I hope he doesn't, but for the sake of the argument...)
Finalist -- Buffalo Sabres : Hasek
1997-98
Winner -- Detroit Red Wings : Yzerman, Murphy, Larionov, Fetisov, Lidstrom, Shanahan, Fedorov, Osgood
Finalist -- Washington Capitals : Oates, Bondra (500 goals in the DPE is a damn good argument, but it might be his only argument. If he would have been better in those playoffs, maybe... I still give him an italic, but not a guy I'd get in), Gonchar, Housley (I think he'd already be in, if he had to -- still, somebody might fall in love with his offensive numbers someday and forget everything else), Kolzig (So many to get in Hall before him at his position)
1996-97
Winner -- Detroit Red Wings : Yzerman, Murphy, Larionov, Fetisov, Lidstrom, Shanahan, Fedorov, Osgood
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Hawechuck, Coffey, Lindros (whom I just can't consider a lock. Many wants him in, but many wants him out as well), Brind'Amour, Leclair
1995-96
Winner -- Colorado Avalance : Roy, Sakic, Forsberg, Foote
Finalist -- Florida Panthers : None. Vanbiesbrouck
1994-95
Winner -- New Jersey Devils : Stevens, Brodeur, Niedermayer, Guerin
Finalist -- Detroit Red Wings : Yzerman, Coffey, Fetisov, Ciccarelli, Lidstrom, Fedorov, Osgood, M. Howe (I think he has no chance to get in -- thus, a shot in the dark -- but his case is rather well documented throughout this board)
1993-94
Winner -- NY Rangers : Messier, Leetch, Anderson, Zubov, Richter
Finalist -- Vancouver Canucks : P. Bure (after some reflexion... I classed him as a likely. Not a lock at all (or else, he'd already be in), and there are some reasons to keep him out. However, he was pretty much the 3rd most "famous" NHL'er in his prime, after Lemieux and Roy, and he DID have a terrific prime.
1992-93
Winner - Le Canadien de Montreal : Roy, Savard, Leclair, Carbonneau
Finalist - LA Kings : Gretzky, Kurri, Robitaille, Blake
1991-92
Winner -- Pittsburgh Penguins : Lemieux, Francis, Murphy, Trottier, Mullen, Jagr, Barrasso
Finalist -- Chicago Blackhawks : Goulet, Hasek, Chelios, Belfour, Roenick (I have problems with ranking Roenick here as anything else than a shot in the dark. I think Richards is already ahead of him as far as on ice accomplishments are concerned, Smythe or not).
1990-91
Winner -- Pittsburgh Penguins : Lemieux, Coffey, Mullen, Francis, Trottier, Murphy, Jagr, Recchi, Barrasso
Finalist -- Minnesota North Stars : Modano. Bobby Smith has IMO a most impressive legacy than some of the guys mentionned in this thread, but there's absolutely no way he makes it in the Hall after so long.
1989-90
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Messier, Kurri, Anderson
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Neely, Bourque
1988-89
Winner -- Calgary Flames : MacInnis, Mullen, McDonald, Gilmour (he should be a lock IMO, but the fact he isn't already in makes me wonder), Nieuwendyk, Fleury (I think he has a hope), Roberts
Finalist -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Roy, Robinson, Gainey, Chelios, Carbonneau
1987-88
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Messier, Kurri, Fuhr, Anderson
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Bourque, Neely, Middleton (This one is tricky. He certainly doesn't have the number to get in (considering the years he played), but he seems to get lots of respect. Numbers-wise, I'm not sure he has a better career than Bill Guerin, and is certainly below Bobby Smith, Brad Richards and Theoren Fleury.
1986-87
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Messier, Anderson, Kurri, Coffey, Fuhr
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Howe, Kerr (if he could have managed to play just a little bit longer, he'd be hard to overlook).
1985-86
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Roy, Robinson, Gainey, Chelios, Carbonneau
Finalist -- Calgary Flames : MacInnis, Mullen, McDonald
1984-85
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Kurri, Coffey, Messier, Anderson, Fuhr
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Howe
1983-84
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Kurri, Coffey, Messier, Anderson, Fuhr
Finalist -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
1982-83
Winner -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
Finalist -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Kurri, Coffey, Messier, Anderson, Fuhr
1981-82
Winner -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
Finalist -- Vancouver Canucks : None
1980-81
Winner -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
Finalist -- Minnesota North Stars : Ciccarelli
1979-80
Winner -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Barber, Clarke
1978-79
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Lafleur, Dryden, Robinson, Savard, Langway, Lapointe, Lemaire, Shutt. Yvan Cournoyer was on the team, but didn't play a single game
Finalist -- New York Rangers : Phil Esposito
1977-78
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montréal : Lafleur, Dryden, Robinson, Savard, Langway, Cournoyer, Lapointe, Lemaire, Shutt
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Park, Ratelle, Cheevers, Middleton
1976-77
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal :Lafleur, Dryden, Robinson, Savard, Langway, Cournoyer, Lapointe, Lemaire, Shutt (With Cournoyer not playing a single game, but was a full-time member of the team that season -- played 60 games)
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Park, Ratelle, Cheevers, Middleton
1975-76
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Lafleur, Dryden, Robinson, Savard, Langway, Cournoyer, Lapointe, Lemaire, Shutt
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Clarke, Parent, Barber
1974-75
Winner -- Philadelphia Flyers : Clarke, Parent, Barber
Finalist -- Buffalo Sabres : Perreault, Martin (Can't name many guys with 4 AST berths (two 1st, two 2nd) who aren't in the HHOF, even though it's pretty obvious as to why he's out -- AST's at a weak position + short longevity + wasn't best player on his team...)
1973-74
Winner -- Philadelphia Flyers : Clarke, Parent, Barber
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Orr, Esposito, Bucyk
1972-73
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Cournoyer, F. Mahovlich, Lapointe, Lemaire, S. Savard, H. Richard, Lafleur, Robinson, Laperriere, Dryden, Shutt (Shutt played 50 games in the Reg. Season and one in the playoffs. Pretty sure he has his name on)
Finalist -- Chicago Blackhawks : Mikita, T.Esposito
1971-72
Winner -- Boston Bruins : Orr, Esposito, Bucyk, Cheevers
Finalist -- New York Rangers : Park, Ratelle, Gilbert, Giacomin (Ratelle only played 6 games, but was extremely effective in regular season)
1970-71
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Beliveau, Dryden, F. Mahovlich, H. Richard, Lapointe, Cournoyer, Lemaire, Laperriere. S. Savard played 35 games in the regular season. JC Tremblay is the best or 2nd best D-Men not in the Hall.
Finalist -- Chicago Blackhawks : Bo. Hull, Mikita, Esposito
1969-70
Winners -- Boston Bruins : Orr, Esposito, Bucyk, Cheevers
Finalist -- St-Louis Blues : Plante, Hall.
1968-69
Winners -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, S. Savard, Cournoyer, Lemaire, Laperriere, Worsley, Duff . Tremblay, Vachon (best goalie not in the Hall).
Finalist -- St- Louis Blues : Plante, Hall. Arbour (not as a player)
1967-68
Winners -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, S. Savard, Cournoyer, Lemaire, Laperriere, Worsley, Duff. Tremblay, Vachon
Finalist -- St-Louis Blues : Moore, Hall, Harvey
1966-67
Winners -- Toronto Maple Leafs : Kelly, Sawchuck, F. Mahovlich, Horton, Bower, Keon, Pronovost, Stanley, Pulford, Armstrong
Finalist -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, Cournoyer, Laperriere, Worsley, Duff Tremblay, Vachon
1965-66
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, Cournoyer, Worsley, Duff. Laperrière was sidelined during the playoffs. Tremblay
Finalist -- Detroit Red Wings : G. Howe, Bathgate, Ullman, Delvecchio, Gadsby. Some want Paul Henderson in.
1964-65
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, Cournoyer, Laperriere, Worsley, Duff. Tremblay.
Finalist -- Chicago Blackhawks : Bo. Hull, Mikita, Esposito, Hall, Pilote
. I'll add years on a consistent basis -- I'll just have to "save" my progress here and there. Feel free to comment/add thoughts/flame.
Here is a list of the Cup winners + Finalists, with all their HHOF'ers, hopefuls, likely, locks, should be.
Legend
Hall of Famer
Lock
Likely
Hopefuls
Guy that is better than some guy in, but probably won't get in (for olders) OR Shot in the dark
The "too early to call" guys are ommited. Think Toews, Keith.
The (editorial comments) will probably be deleted once the work is finished - I'm just explaining my position on some debatable classifications.
2009-10
Winner -- Chicago Blackhawks : Hossa
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Pronger
2008-09
Winner -- Pittsburgh Penguins : Crosby, Gonchar, Malkin, Guerin
Finalist -- Detroit Red Wings : Lidstrom, Chelios, Zetterberg, Hossa, Datsyuk, Osgood
2007-08
Winner -- Detroit Red Wings : Hasek, Lidstrom, Chelios, Zetterberg, Datsyuk, Osgood
Finalists -- Pittsburgh Penguins : Crosby, Hossa, Gonchar, Malkin, Roberts
2006-07
Winner -- Anaheim Ducks : Pronger, S. Niedermayer, Selanne (I THINK he's a lock, some might disagree, Giguere (he HAS to add, but he's a guy that, at this point, has a shot to make it).
Finalist -- Ottawa Senators : Alfredsson, Heatley
2005-06
Winner -- Carolina Hurricanes : Recchi, Brind'Amour, Staal (borderline too early, but his the face of his franchise, played some international hockey...),Weight ,C.Ward (see Staal)
Finalist -- Edmonton Oilers : Pronger, Smyth. (For the record, I think Peca has absolutely no chance to get in).
2003-04
Winner -- Tampa Bay : St-Louis, Andreychuck, B. Richards, Lecavalier.
Finalist -- Calgary Flames : Iginla, Kiprusoff
2002-03
Winner -- New Jersey Devils : S. Stevens, S. Niedermayer, M. Brodeur, Nieuwendyk (just too important on many Cup winners, wouldn't consider him an absolutely lock though), Elias
Finalist -- Anaheim Ducks : Oates, Kariya, Giguere (again -- he HAS to add, but doesn't have to add much. He'd be the worst goalie in the Hall if he got in, but has great postseason credentials)
2001-02
Winner -- Detroit Red Wings : Yzerman, Robitaille, Larionov, Hull, Hasek, Lidstrom, Chelios, Fedorov, Shanahan (barring a major brainfart from the committee, Shanahan seems a lock), Datsyuk
Finalist -- Carolina Hurricanes : Francis, Brind'Amour
2000-01
Winner -- Colorado Avanlanche : Roy, Bourque, Sakic, Forsberg, R. Blake (that was a really close call between a likely and a hopeful. Certainly not a lock), Foote (a TRUE shot in the dark, but was on many winning teams).
Finalist -- New Jersey Devils : Stevens, Niedermayer, Brodeur, Mogilny (I think he has a better shot than Elias, but he has to hope. Being short of the 1000 games and the 500 goals mark by so little doesn't help him. In a non-cap world, he reaches 1000/500, and gets much more consideration). , Elias (sorry Jason Arnott)
1999-00
Winner -- New Jersey Devils : Stevens, Niedermayer, Brodeur, Mogilny, Elias
Finalist -- Dallas Stars : Hull, Belfour (some MIGHT not see him as a lock, but the guy was the clear fourth best of his era -- and the guys above him are IMO in the Top-6 goalies of all-time. Should be considered a lock to everyone), Modano (the "face of the franchise" argument), Nieuwendyk, Carbonneau (his name has been mentionned, and while last year was probably his best shot, I won't rule him out yet), Zubov,
1998-99
Winner -- Dallas Stars : Hull, Belfour, Modano , Nieuwendyk, Carbonneau, Zubov, Verbeek (I hope he doesn't, but for the sake of the argument...)
Finalist -- Buffalo Sabres : Hasek
1997-98
Winner -- Detroit Red Wings : Yzerman, Murphy, Larionov, Fetisov, Lidstrom, Shanahan, Fedorov, Osgood
Finalist -- Washington Capitals : Oates, Bondra (500 goals in the DPE is a damn good argument, but it might be his only argument. If he would have been better in those playoffs, maybe... I still give him an italic, but not a guy I'd get in), Gonchar, Housley (I think he'd already be in, if he had to -- still, somebody might fall in love with his offensive numbers someday and forget everything else), Kolzig (So many to get in Hall before him at his position)
1996-97
Winner -- Detroit Red Wings : Yzerman, Murphy, Larionov, Fetisov, Lidstrom, Shanahan, Fedorov, Osgood
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Hawechuck, Coffey, Lindros (whom I just can't consider a lock. Many wants him in, but many wants him out as well), Brind'Amour, Leclair
1995-96
Winner -- Colorado Avalance : Roy, Sakic, Forsberg, Foote
Finalist -- Florida Panthers : None. Vanbiesbrouck
1994-95
Winner -- New Jersey Devils : Stevens, Brodeur, Niedermayer, Guerin
Finalist -- Detroit Red Wings : Yzerman, Coffey, Fetisov, Ciccarelli, Lidstrom, Fedorov, Osgood, M. Howe (I think he has no chance to get in -- thus, a shot in the dark -- but his case is rather well documented throughout this board)
1993-94
Winner -- NY Rangers : Messier, Leetch, Anderson, Zubov, Richter
Finalist -- Vancouver Canucks : P. Bure (after some reflexion... I classed him as a likely. Not a lock at all (or else, he'd already be in), and there are some reasons to keep him out. However, he was pretty much the 3rd most "famous" NHL'er in his prime, after Lemieux and Roy, and he DID have a terrific prime.
1992-93
Winner - Le Canadien de Montreal : Roy, Savard, Leclair, Carbonneau
Finalist - LA Kings : Gretzky, Kurri, Robitaille, Blake
1991-92
Winner -- Pittsburgh Penguins : Lemieux, Francis, Murphy, Trottier, Mullen, Jagr, Barrasso
Finalist -- Chicago Blackhawks : Goulet, Hasek, Chelios, Belfour, Roenick (I have problems with ranking Roenick here as anything else than a shot in the dark. I think Richards is already ahead of him as far as on ice accomplishments are concerned, Smythe or not).
1990-91
Winner -- Pittsburgh Penguins : Lemieux, Coffey, Mullen, Francis, Trottier, Murphy, Jagr, Recchi, Barrasso
Finalist -- Minnesota North Stars : Modano. Bobby Smith has IMO a most impressive legacy than some of the guys mentionned in this thread, but there's absolutely no way he makes it in the Hall after so long.
1989-90
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Messier, Kurri, Anderson
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Neely, Bourque
1988-89
Winner -- Calgary Flames : MacInnis, Mullen, McDonald, Gilmour (he should be a lock IMO, but the fact he isn't already in makes me wonder), Nieuwendyk, Fleury (I think he has a hope), Roberts
Finalist -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Roy, Robinson, Gainey, Chelios, Carbonneau
1987-88
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Messier, Kurri, Fuhr, Anderson
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Bourque, Neely, Middleton (This one is tricky. He certainly doesn't have the number to get in (considering the years he played), but he seems to get lots of respect. Numbers-wise, I'm not sure he has a better career than Bill Guerin, and is certainly below Bobby Smith, Brad Richards and Theoren Fleury.
1986-87
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Messier, Anderson, Kurri, Coffey, Fuhr
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Howe, Kerr (if he could have managed to play just a little bit longer, he'd be hard to overlook).
1985-86
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Roy, Robinson, Gainey, Chelios, Carbonneau
Finalist -- Calgary Flames : MacInnis, Mullen, McDonald
1984-85
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Kurri, Coffey, Messier, Anderson, Fuhr
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Howe
1983-84
Winner -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Kurri, Coffey, Messier, Anderson, Fuhr
Finalist -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
1982-83
Winner -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
Finalist -- Edmonton Oilers : Gretzky, Kurri, Coffey, Messier, Anderson, Fuhr
1981-82
Winner -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
Finalist -- Vancouver Canucks : None
1980-81
Winner -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
Finalist -- Minnesota North Stars : Ciccarelli
1979-80
Winner -- New York Islanders : Potvin, Bossy, Trottier, Smith, Gillies
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Barber, Clarke
1978-79
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Lafleur, Dryden, Robinson, Savard, Langway, Lapointe, Lemaire, Shutt. Yvan Cournoyer was on the team, but didn't play a single game
Finalist -- New York Rangers : Phil Esposito
1977-78
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montréal : Lafleur, Dryden, Robinson, Savard, Langway, Cournoyer, Lapointe, Lemaire, Shutt
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Park, Ratelle, Cheevers, Middleton
1976-77
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal :Lafleur, Dryden, Robinson, Savard, Langway, Cournoyer, Lapointe, Lemaire, Shutt (With Cournoyer not playing a single game, but was a full-time member of the team that season -- played 60 games)
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Park, Ratelle, Cheevers, Middleton
1975-76
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Lafleur, Dryden, Robinson, Savard, Langway, Cournoyer, Lapointe, Lemaire, Shutt
Finalist -- Philadelphia Flyers : Clarke, Parent, Barber
1974-75
Winner -- Philadelphia Flyers : Clarke, Parent, Barber
Finalist -- Buffalo Sabres : Perreault, Martin (Can't name many guys with 4 AST berths (two 1st, two 2nd) who aren't in the HHOF, even though it's pretty obvious as to why he's out -- AST's at a weak position + short longevity + wasn't best player on his team...)
1973-74
Winner -- Philadelphia Flyers : Clarke, Parent, Barber
Finalist -- Boston Bruins : Orr, Esposito, Bucyk
1972-73
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Cournoyer, F. Mahovlich, Lapointe, Lemaire, S. Savard, H. Richard, Lafleur, Robinson, Laperriere, Dryden, Shutt (Shutt played 50 games in the Reg. Season and one in the playoffs. Pretty sure he has his name on)
Finalist -- Chicago Blackhawks : Mikita, T.Esposito
1971-72
Winner -- Boston Bruins : Orr, Esposito, Bucyk, Cheevers
Finalist -- New York Rangers : Park, Ratelle, Gilbert, Giacomin (Ratelle only played 6 games, but was extremely effective in regular season)
1970-71
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Beliveau, Dryden, F. Mahovlich, H. Richard, Lapointe, Cournoyer, Lemaire, Laperriere. S. Savard played 35 games in the regular season. JC Tremblay is the best or 2nd best D-Men not in the Hall.
Finalist -- Chicago Blackhawks : Bo. Hull, Mikita, Esposito
1969-70
Winners -- Boston Bruins : Orr, Esposito, Bucyk, Cheevers
Finalist -- St-Louis Blues : Plante, Hall.
1968-69
Winners -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, S. Savard, Cournoyer, Lemaire, Laperriere, Worsley, Duff . Tremblay, Vachon (best goalie not in the Hall).
Finalist -- St- Louis Blues : Plante, Hall. Arbour (not as a player)
1967-68
Winners -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, S. Savard, Cournoyer, Lemaire, Laperriere, Worsley, Duff. Tremblay, Vachon
Finalist -- St-Louis Blues : Moore, Hall, Harvey
1966-67
Winners -- Toronto Maple Leafs : Kelly, Sawchuck, F. Mahovlich, Horton, Bower, Keon, Pronovost, Stanley, Pulford, Armstrong
Finalist -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, Cournoyer, Laperriere, Worsley, Duff Tremblay, Vachon
1965-66
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, Cournoyer, Worsley, Duff. Laperrière was sidelined during the playoffs. Tremblay
Finalist -- Detroit Red Wings : G. Howe, Bathgate, Ullman, Delvecchio, Gadsby. Some want Paul Henderson in.
1964-65
Winner -- Le Canadien de Montreal : Béliveau, H. Richard, Cournoyer, Laperriere, Worsley, Duff. Tremblay.
Finalist -- Chicago Blackhawks : Bo. Hull, Mikita, Esposito, Hall, Pilote
Last edited: