SPINOFF: Which O trio is better

[Hatter]

unhurt obviously. Who's the better top line?

Deadmarsh - Alison - Palffy
Or
Brown - Kopitar - Williams

I know who I'm taking. Door number one, Monte

Click to read more...

 

[Reaper45]

Love Brown and JDub and Kopi but I gotta go with Deader-Allison-Palffy.

 

[Martyros]

Considering all three were PPG players in the "old" NHL, i'd take the first 3. Too bad they only played together for a handful of games.

 

[redcard]

I'd take Brown and Kopitar over Deader and Allison, but Palffy over Williams is a landslide.

Ultimately, I'll take the ones with the hardware.

 

[DeeMeck]

Considering all three were PPG players in the "old" NHL, i'd take the first 3. Too bad they only played together for a handful of games.

Allison and Deadmarsh were "old" NHL players. Their games might not translate so well to the "new" NHL. Ziggy on the other hand...

 

[Axl Rhoadz]

Not even a competition....Allison-Deadmarsh-Palffy, hands down.

When that line was rolling, they were probably the best line in the league at the time.

 

[johnjm22]

Fully healthy, and in their prime, I'd take Deadmarsh-Allison-Palffy. Easily.

 

[Martyros]

Allison and Deadmarsh were "old" NHL players. Their games might not translate so well to the "new" NHL. Ziggy on the other hand...

Might. Allison was the big if, but i doubt he'd be THAT slow without the knee injury.

 

[YP44]

I'd take Brown and Kopitar over Deader and Allison, but Palffy over Williams is a landslide.

Ultimately, I'll take the ones with the hardware.

For me it would be
Kopitar>Allison
Brown=Deadmarsh (hey Brown got us the cup right)
Palffy >>Williams

 

[bobafettish*]

lapd easy.

 

[Reaper45]

For me it would be
Kopitar>Allison
Brown=Deadmarsh (hey Brown got us the cup right)
Palffy >>Williams

Allison > Kopitar but not by much.
Deader > Brown
Palffy >>> Williams

 

[Butch 19]

Allison > Kopitar but not by much.
Deader > Brown
Palffy >>> Williams

yeah, maybe in bizarro world...

 

[KingsFan7824]

Palffy is the most skilled. He almost makes it LAPD by himself. Absolutely loved Deadmarsh. Allison was a load out on the ice too.

A Cup is a Cup, but I have to go with Allison/Deadmarsh/Palffy. However, because of the way Kopitar and Brown played in the playoffs leading a team to a Cup, it's closer than it would be if you asked this question prior to the playoffs last year.

 

[Rorschach]

I would take Sandstrom, Kurri and Robitaille over the two above lines.

 

[scramble91]

Allison > Kopitar but not by much.
Deader > Brown
Palffy >>> Williams

I would agree with the bottom 2. I think kopitar is a better player than Allison. It's hard to gauge since its 2 different eras and 2 different systems.

 

[CanadianKingsFan14]

Deadmarsh-Allison-Palffy for sure. God I miss them!! I think thats been our best #1 line ever. That line had everything.

 

[Captain Mittens*]

 

[KINGS17]

Fully healthy, and in their prime, I'd take Deadmarsh-Allison-Palffy. Easily.

Well, that's the problem rarely were the three of them fully healthy at the same time.

There is something to be said for durability and these three didn't have it.