Everyone is so sick of Roman's push that they continue to underrate him because of the burn out.
He's a good worker and has had plenty of four-star+ matches.
I'm sick of him because his matches are lazy. He's a good worker and a safe worker because his matches consist of HIM getting his ass kicked between rest holds. That is until the inevitable spear and Superman punch. How can he hurt a guy when he follows the safest match formula known to man. The only reason this guy can pull off a four star rating is because for one, brief shining moment everyone in the world thinks there is a chance that's gonna lose. They hope for it. They pray for it.
It's not just push MCG. This isn't poor Roman can't catch a break. This isn't "he's a good worker and haters are gonna hate" this is a revolt of a fanbase that doesn't live in 1987 and a revolt against the way WWE has shoved us down our throat like an 8 year old kid being told to shut up and eat their Brussels Sprouts, Broccoli and Asparagus. The guy actually kicks out of brass knuckles, kicks out of consecutive finishers by Owens and Jericho and wins his matches the same way almost 90% of the time. Natural, human conditioning dictates that this is not right. Super Roman is reaching Stone Cold levels of absurdity. But they could get away with it with Stone Cold because fans loved him.
This setup between Roman and Undertaker is a blatant disrespect to every fan like myself who is sick of him being God. Because the only force more unstoppable than Roman is supposedly Taker at Mania. But it's gotten SO BAD with Roman now that people will actually pick against the Undertaker now. It's nothing more than a task to avoid fans being able to just write off Undertaker with a W like we always have. And the sad part is NO ONE will be surprised if Roman actually wins.
"Terminator babyfaces" who cannot possibly die are neither popular or entertaining anymore. And if this were a popular formula, it's not gonna come from an unlikable character with poor mic-work, even worse music, an atheistic SWAT attire, greased up hair and a goofy grin. He fails because almost nothing about him is likable.
I haven't been a fan long, especially not when compared to the rest of you (I have been a fan about 15 years on and off) and he is easily one of the most boring wrestlers I have ever watched.