I don't mean the skates sizing is a half size bigger I mean after converting skate sizing into shoe sizing. In conversion her shoe size is 9 and the skates she's wearing is 9.5 after conversion. (That's all in women's sizing) I never thought half size would cause so much issues. After conversions I wear 1.5 size bigger than I wear my shoes. Unfortunately a trip to a good Pro shop would be a very long trip for us. Might just have to put her back in the old skates and wait till we go on an out of state vacation. Thanks for the help!
I see. That doesn't necessarily mean they're only a half size too big - they could be a full size or more too big. Shoe size isn't the best way to determine skate size as some people wear their shoes tighter than others and, like skates, different brands of shoes are sized differently.
Personally, I wear an 8EE skate, 10W dress shoes, 10 sandals and usually 10.5 running shoes. So I'm dropping down 2 full sizes or 2.5 vs. running shoes and my toes barely feather the caps when standing and just come off when in a skating position. Some people drop down even further.
If you can't get to a good shop then the next best option is to measure her feet like in this video:
http://www.hockeytutorial.com/uncategorized/ice-hockey-skate-sizing-chart-width-and-length/
You can then use the chart on the same page as a general guide (keep in mind that it was made in 2011; so some sizing for some brands has changed) as well as post the numbers here for general sizing advice. Trying skates on is the ideal, but working with actual foot measurements is much better than guessing best on shoe size.
My feet are 10.6 inches long...the chart suggests someone with that length of foot should take a size 8 skate in most brands (although in some brands I can fit into a 7.5 and in others I need an 8.5) and that is what I use. I did not base my skate purchase on that chart, but actually went to stores and tried them on, but it does appear the chart is fairly accurate based on my measurements. It should at least be able to tell you if the length is within a half size or way off.