Proposal: Shea Weber to Toronto

[Unbiased Fan]

No.





Still no.

He doesn’t speak for all leafs fans lol

Toronto: Weber 50% retained

Montreal: Rasmus Sandin, Alex Kerfoot and 1st 2021

that’s a more fair offer. Sandin has tremendous value and is exactly what habs need he projects to be a number 1 guy and is already effective in the NHL.

 

[sansabri]

He doesn’t speak for all leafs fans lol

Toronto: Weber 50% retained

Montreal: Rasmus Sandin, Alex Kerfoot and 1st 2021

that’s a more fair offer. Sandin has tremendous value and is exactly what habs need he projects to be a
number 1 guy and is already effective in the NHL.

lol why would we retain 50% on Weber and take on Kerfoot's bad deal

 

[CatchyTune]

He doesn’t speak for all leafs fans lol

Toronto: Weber 50% retained

Montreal: Rasmus Sandin, Alex Kerfoot and 1st 2021

that’s a more fair offer. Sandin has tremendous value and is exactly what habs need he projects to be a number 1 guy and is already effective in the NHL.

While the OP is terrible for Montreal, there is absolutely no chance I do this. Sandin is too important to move for a 34 year old and trading our 1st every year isnt a recipe for success. Although I would include it in the right deal, the 1st along with Sandin is too much.

lol why would we retain 50% on Weber and take on Kerfoot's bad deal

Nothing is wrong with Kerfoots deal.

 

[sansabri]

Nothing is wrong with Kerfoots deal.

good, cuz we don't want him

 

[Mrfenn92]

Montreal says no easily. Just a bad proposal.

 

[Kshahdoo]

He has 6 years remaining on his deal. Do you think he plays every single one of those contract seasons???

How old is Chara?

 

[Unbiased Fan]

lol why would we retain 50% on Weber and take on Kerfoot's bad deal

Kerfoot isn’t a bad deal. 40 point 2 way 3rd liner he’s not amazing but he’s certainly worth 3.4 million.

 

[biotk]

They get out of half of Webers contract. This is close to the Phaneuf deal if not better.

Phaneuf was bad. Weber is still one the best D in the league, and probably will remain so for another 3 seasons or so.

 

[TBF1972]

He's 34 that contract is brutal

At 3.9m? Not at all. He would be a bargain the first 2-3 seasons. This offer is high way robbery.

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

At 3.9m? Not at all. He would be a bargain the first 2-3 seasons. This offer is high way robbery.

He's going to be 35 in August with 6 or 7 more years remaining I don't know that I want that

 

[mrinsane]

If MB puts Weber with retention on the market many team could be on

 

[TBF1972]

He's going to be 35 in August with 6 or 7 more years remaining I don't know that I want that

Do you hate Dubas for the Muzzin contract?

 

[Qwijibo]

He's going to be 35 in August with 6 or 7 more years remaining I don't know that I want that

He has two more seasons where he makes $6m a year. Then it drops to $3m for a season, then $1m for the last three years. Anyone who believes he’ll keep playing beyond the next 3 seasons if he’s no longer contributing on the ice is out to lunch. Montreal isn’t worried about his contract or him playing it out. Honestly you’d have to overpay to get him

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

Do you hate Dubas for the Muzzin contract?

That's not even close to the same, Muzzin is almost 4 years younger, has 2 or 3 years less on his contract and is over 2 million dollars cheaper.

Not even close to the same, whatever point you trying to make doesn't work in this situation

 

[Prominence]

Even if you make both sides of the trade equal, weber is not he kind of dman dubas would go after.

 

[Didalee Hed]

Toronto doesnt have anyone worth weber 1v1.

 

[MarkusKetterer]

How old is Chara?

He’s gotta be getting close to Methuselah’s age, right?

 

[TrapGod Jr]

I cant believe this is a serious trade offer. I’m pretty sure Weber retires as a Hab.

Hyman +Marner for Tatar + Byron 2nd....... see where im going?

Exactly.

 

[MarkusKetterer]

Weber is vastly better than Phaneuf.

Yea but Phaneuf dated Elisha Cuthbert Did Weber?

 

[Kupo]

They get out of half of Webers contract. This is close to the Phaneuf deal if not better.

As an outsider, this is straight up horseshit for Montreal.

Weber has a crappy contract but he’s still a damn good dmen. And the crappiness in his contract is more detrimental for the Preds.

Awful proposal. Say your apologies and move on for creating an atrocious offer and having the Audacity for trying to defend it.

Shame. SHHHAAAAAAMMMMEEE.

 

[Halla]

DOnt want Weber with his age and contract on the leafs but that being said this is bad for the habs lol.

 

[CraigsList]

Probably better off trading for Petry as a rental.

 

[Flyer lurker]

Weber is not Subban. He still can play all be it not what he used to be. MTL would not pick up 4m and also not get equal value in trade.

 

[TBF1972]

That's not even close to the same, Muzzin is almost 4 years younger, has 2 or 3 years less on his contract and is over 2 million dollars cheaper.

Not even close to the same, whatever point you trying to make doesn't work in this situation

OP states a 50% retention on the Weber contract. You really would prefer:
Muzzin @ 5.625m for 4 years
over
Webber @ 3.957m for 6 years
This is an absolute no brainer for me.

 

[Flyer lurker]

He's going to be 35 in August with 6 or 7 more years remaining I don't know that I want that

Look at cap number vs actual cash number. Actual cash next 2 years 6m a year. Following year 3m. last 3 years 1m. Weber will either play 2 or 3 years and then retire. And Nashville is on the hook for the cash not MTL.