As an outsider with no dog in this fight you're going to be disappointed in just about every way. Petry isn't that valuable
How valuable is "not that valuable"?
If you're suggesting that Petry isn't valuable enough to return an asset of some kind, you're incorrect.
the Jarry contract is a true head scratcher and not very good he's too inconsistent and injury prone.
Jack Campbell, a goalie not as good as Jarry, got a 5x$5M contract last offseason.
Joonas Korpisalo, a goalie not as good as Jarry, for a 5x$4M contract this offseason.
Jarry got market value for a goalie of his caliber.
You're welcome to disagree with all of those deals and say that the market is stupid or whatever, but nonetheless, the market is the market.
Then you also go onto say that Karlsson won't return much.
I didn't say Karlsson wouldn't return much. I said the return wouldn't match the exorbitant suggestions being thrown around here.
I saw the ridiculous suggestion that he would return two 1st and a high-end prospect. That's ludicrous.
Half of that is still 'much'. A 1st and a decent prospect.
Alot of words here that simply boil down to you trying to not only convince others but it seems like yourself the Penguins are in a situation that they really aren't.
Nope. Not only did I state my case, but I actually provided reasoning for it.
Petry is 6'3", a RD, and scored at a half a point per game rate last season. All of those things have value on the trade market.
You, on the other hand, have simply given a lot of words, because it's apparently fun for people to underrate Penguins players not named Crosby or Malkin.
Jarry is too inconsistent and injury prone? Compared to who, exactly?