SENS TOURNAMENT OF LOGOS: QF1 - "OLD 2D" vs. "NEW 2D"

[BonkTastic]

SENS TOURNAMENT OF LOGOS

Quarterfinal #1: "Pre-Lockout 2D Logo" vs "Post-Lockout 2D Logo"

Winner moves on to the Semi-Finals.

Links to the other Quarterfinals:
Quarterfinal #1 - Old 2D vs New 2D
Quarterfinal #2 - Old 3D vs New 3D
Quarterfinal #3 - "SNES" vs Heritage =0=
Quarterfinal #4 - Inaugural Shoulder vs Peace Tower Shoulder vs Shield Shoulder

Click to read more...

 

[Sun God Nika]

Two of the best logos this is the finals.

 

[Six Assets]

1st one

can't go wrong with either one though

 

[Benjamin]

Post looks more well done but its really missing the pointed cape or whatever it is on the back.

 

[DrunkUncleDenis]

#landslide

 

[Very Stable Genius]

Was the new 3D logo actually ever used?

 

[ChocolateLeclaire]

Was the new 3D logo actually ever used?

It's used only on some merchandise.

I've seen it on kids stuff mainly. Piggy banks, toy cars...etc.

And I've seen it on one hat.

 

[Slack]

I've been partial to great1's design ever since first I saw it. Old and new all at once.

But since this is a battle of official logos I'll take the old one.

 

[QuietOnTheFront]

I still think that post lockout logo is too overhyped.. It's the original all the way.

 

[Benjamin]

I've been partial to great1's design ever since first I saw it. Old and new all at once.

But since this is a battle of official logos I'll take the old one.

This logo is 100% perfect.

 

[saskriders]

Should have included both text and laurels old 2d. Prefer text myself, but both are better than new d by a landslide

 

[DrakeAndJosh]

This logo is 100% perfect.

It really is. This could have been our classic logo for decades, don't know why we switched it up.

Really don't know why we ever completely changed the teams brand, they had it right from the start, shouldn't have made changes other than minor tweaks here and there.

This was really a unique look that had character to it, our is so generic right now.

 

[Othello*]

Both are great

 

[Vesa Awesaka]

I like the Ottawa Senator text on the side. Would like it if they put 1992 on it

 

[Senacus Maximus]

I like the post logo because it doesn't have a bad case of off-center like the original does.

But that isn't quite enough to put it past the original. Anything would be better than the current logo though.

 

[L'Aveuglette]

I've been partial to great1's design ever since first I saw it. Old and new all at once.

But since this is a battle of official logos I'll take the old one.

Gimme!

NOW!

 

[mcnorth]

I've been partial to great1's design ever since first I saw it. Old and new all at once.

But since this is a battle of official logos I'll take the old one.

The best of both logos.

 

[Six Assets]

very nice jersey

 

[maclean]

The original 2d logo was so ugly it made me hesitate on whether to support the team

 

[benjiv1]

I've been partial to great1's design ever since first I saw it. Old and new all at once.

But since this is a battle of official logos I'll take the old one.

We should get a petition going to have our logo changed to this. It's literally perfect.

 

[DrunkUncleDenis]

We should get a petition going to have our logo changed to this. It's literally perfect.

Well... maybe not "literally perfect".. I mean, the plume doesn't quite align with the helmet (especially at the bottom), the little gold filler bit between the plume and the helmet is a touch too high.. but if you move any of it, the logo becomes unbalanced, so I'm good with it like this.

 

[Mr Invidious]

I actually think the post-lockout one looks too goofy. Give me the old.

 

[Ragged]

I've been partial to great1's design ever since first I saw it. Old and new all at once.

But since this is a battle of official logos I'll take the old one.

This is pretty darned good. (Puts on nit-picky illustrator hat) Aside from some minor quibbles with line weight, this would get my vote. But, as it is, I guess I go with the original.

 

[DrunkUncleDenis]

I think when all the voting is done, I'm going to put together the results, format it in some spiffy letter, and mail it to management.

We can't miss out on this chance to voice our fan opinion when the jerseys are going to be redesigned in the near future.

 

[Lenny the Lynx]

Was the new 3D logo actually ever used?

I got a tat of it